Keeper!
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
I agree - we survived pre-Christmas on meagre scoring but lots of Pickford-inspired clean sheets.People moaning about us this season forget how integral the goalkeeper was last season. I reckon Pickford saved us at least 12 points last season.
Sent from my LG-H815 using Tapatalk
After Pickford went back, the clean sheets completely dried up, but we managed to score enough goals to get over the line.
This season was always going to be a case of scoring more goals than last year to survive, because we could no longer rely on clean sheets thanks to Pickford's brilliance for the first 5 months.
Then the owner sanctioned the sale of Joe Garner just before the transfer window closed...
- Joined
- May 30, 2014
- Messages
- 4,821
Excellent Thracia and much more eloquently written than I can offer.I agree - we survived pre-Christmas on meagre scoring but lots of Pickford-inspired clean sheets.
After Pickford went back, the clean sheets completely dried up, but we managed to score enough goals to get over the line.
This season was always going to be a case of scoring more goals than last year to survive, because we could no longer rely on clean sheets thanks to Pickford's brilliance for the first 5 months.
Then the owner sanctioned the sale of Joe Garner just before the transfer window closed...
Sent from my LG-H815 using Tapatalk
He was crap last season, utterly amazed we signed him. Must be on a fair wedge too, and another one with no hope of a profit down the line.
I remember people jumping up and down with glee when he signed.
I actually thought we looked much weaker at the back end of last season when he played.
Inspires absolutely no confidence in the back 3/4/5 and does not speak. Does not come for crosses and ends up in very odd positions.
Maxwell can't do any worse, but we should ha e brought Sam back. Huge bollock dropped by Grayson.
- Joined
- May 24, 2016
- Messages
- 5,141
Said it in the summer. He's not that good. The defence have no faith in him. Should have brought Sam back.
Johnstone wasn't available and that was made clear to PNE right at the start of the summer.
Johnstone wasn't available and that was made clear to PNE right at the start of the summer.
Rubbish.
- Joined
- May 24, 2016
- Messages
- 5,141
Rubbish.
Nope - wasn't available for either loan or permanent transfer.
That is why, despite numerous clubs in the Championship wanting him on loan, he is still at Man Utd as the 3rd choice keeper.
He was crap last season, utterly amazed we signed him. Must be on a fair wedge too, and another one with no hope of a profit down the line.
Fwiw I agree with you about Lindegaard, and also about no hope of profit. The club should look to bring in players with a decent sell-on potential, a bit like Barnsley. It puts the club in a strong position and means all the funds can be reinvested back into the side every time a player is sold.
However, we sold Garner a few weeks ago to uproar amongst many supporters. So if we did develop players and sell them on for profit, the club would be in the wrong then too, so I guess they just can't win on this issue of selling players for profit ?
He was crap last season, utterly amazed we signed him. Must be on a fair wedge too, and another one with no hope of a profit down the line.
To be honest I said he was no good, after the first game I watched him play.😱 I hope to be proved wrong, but as far as I am concerned, at the moment, he is poor. Was underwhelmed when we signed him. Don't mean to be horrible, but it's how I feel.
I'd rather have gone for Rudd on loan again. Or Johnstone, or seen if Gunn was available from Man City. Lindergaard has been average at best. A few pieces of brilliance, but a lot of garbage as well.
Here we go. Is carlo nash still playing? What about lonergan or iain turner? Can you think of any other ex keepers you would have gone for? By the way rudd made a very costly error for charlton the other week.
Here we go. Is carlo nash still playing? What about lonergan or iain turner? Can you think of any other ex keepers you would have gone for? By the way rudd made a very costly error for charlton the other week.
So just because they're an ex player, that means they're not good enough to return? I'd like them back because they are better than what we have.
Rudd making a costly error the other week doesn't change the fact that he's a good keeper. All keepers make mistakes in their career.
I did also mention Gunn from Man City.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Maxwell for me. Lindegard seems to be in on reputation at the moment.
So just because they're an ex player, that means they're not good enough to return? I'd like them back because they are better than what we have.
Rudd making a costly error the other week doesn't change the fact that he's a good keeper. All keepers make mistakes in their career.
I did also mention Gunn from Man City.
Gunn was going nowhere this summer....
http://talksport.com/football/manch...ig-impression-pep-guardiola-during-pre-season
Apparently Pep personally intervened to ensure he didn't go out on loan anywhere
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2009
- Messages
- 2,876
Maxwell for me. Lindegard seems to be in on reputation at the moment.
Worth a try. When your keeper and centre half look poor it can only end one way and that's conceding goals.
Rubbish.
Talk was when Forest showed interest, United quoted them £4m.
Digest that.
Talk was when Forest showed interest, United quoted them £4m.
Digest that.
We were quoted £2 million for Vermijl yet he joined for about one tenth of that amount.
We were quoted £2 million for Vermijl yet he joined for about one tenth of that amount.
United have a slightly stronger financial muscle than Wednesday with which to hold their selling nerve in the market. Very very rare that United undervalue a player they are selling, it's usually the other way as they over inflate the price to receive top dollar instead!
United have a slightly stronger financial muscle than Wednesday with which to hold their selling nerve in the market. Very very rare that United undervalue a player they are selling, it's usually the other way as they over inflate the price to receive top dollar instead!
They also need to recoup some of the £89 million they shelled out for Pogba! Lol.
Can see Sam re-joining next summer when Anders deal is up. Just hope it's in the championship....
- Joined
- May 24, 2016
- Messages
- 5,141
We were quoted £2 million for Vermijl yet he joined for about one tenth of that amount.
It was 500k for Vermijl.
As for United they don't need to drop their asking price because of the money they've got and he wasn't for sale anyway as he is needed there as the 3rd choice keeper.
At the age of 24 I think Johnstone will leave next summer to finally play instead of making up the numbers at United. However it will be very difficult to sign him as the competition will be enormous to get a young English keeper like that on a free.