Skip to main content

Keeper!

Keeper!

We have been spoiled with the three young loanee keepers especially the last one.

Lindegaard has decent pedigree and whilst no Pickford I don't feel he is our problem.

I agree with other posters it is the other end of the pitch where we needed to improve but haven't on the evidence of the first few games
 
We have been spoiled with the three young loanee keepers especially the last one.

Lindegaard has decent pedigree and whilst no Pickford I don't feel he is our problem.

I agree with other posters it is the other end of the pitch where we needed to improve but haven't on the evidence of the first few games

Spoke to a bloke today who lives a couple of doors away from Maxwell. Didn't know Maxwell turned down Rangers to come to Preston.
He also told me what Lindegaard was being paid. If it's true, he will have to play a damn sight worse than he has before he gets dropped
 
Considering the number of goals against so far maybe now may not be the time to consider a keeper change, there are bigger fires burning a few yards further down the pitch ?
Glad to see you back Edgy we have been sadly lacking in sane voices recently.

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk
 
Considering the number of goals against so far maybe now may not be the time to consider a keeper change, there are bigger fires burning a few yards further down the pitch ?

Spot on as a summary but there are a number of things going on during the 90 mins of play.

Sure there was an improvement after half time on Saturday but this was built on more possession and building an attack instead of hoof-scramble-defend that we saw in the first half. This is not the first time we have seen this happen on match day.

Anders in not the reason for our defeats in isolation but does play a part like most of our players have. I would point out that the outfield has seen a decent amount of rotation in an attempt to find the extra % needed to change our fortunes.

We are loosing due to a small margin and have nothing on the pitch that naturally plays or provides leadership in possession. The keeper is a key position for both of these traits and we saw a change in play from Anders in the second half after instruction no doubt from SG.

The confidence grows from the back when no one is fearful of lack of support from those sweeping up behind them when a mistake is made. All to often I feel the line of defence is looking over its shoulder and in attack we sit deep and end up with vain attempt to cross the ball in.

There is a % improvement available and indeed required in the keeper performance like else where. We win very little from Anders playing long it just does not work. Barnsley were instantly back at us almost every time. Clearance by the defence under pressure gave away even more possession with a throw in or a gift to the opposition. Anders was rarely used and offered little support with a small improvement at half time.

Since we are now all championship snobs it seems Anders must be better than our other keeper from L1 and Sam a perm player who played for us in L1 is still the way to go.

I have seen quality in leadership and possession from maxwell the very thing we can gain something from on match day.

This is not an Anders bashing but more a - use what we have situation after all there is no worry when a change is made further up the field.
 
Not saying he should or shouldnt be dropped, but ultimately keepers should be treated no different than other players.

If strikers arent scoring, it warrants them to get dropped.
If defenders arent keeping clean sheets, it warrants them to get dropped.

Anders doesnt exactly fill out his shirt and doesnt look overly imposing, perhaps something he is aware of and therefore doesnt tend to come for crosses/corners.

Maxwell isnt here just to play in cup competitions, but if given a chance and makes a cock up there will immediately be a thread on here about why we signed 2 keepers who arent up to the standard of championship football
 
The first change for me on Tuesday would be to drop Anders.

He makes the odd good save but his command of his area is poor, his clean sheet record since signing has been shocking. He should have done better for quiet a few goals we have conceded so far this season.

Yes it was only Oldham but Maxwell looked commanding and confident and a decent shot stopper.

I would give him a chance.

That said I honestly can't see Grayson doing it.

**bangs head on desk, repeatedly**
 
Nothing spectacular last night from Anders but decent starting positions allowed him to make 3 decent saves and as many routine ones.

I agree that he does not seem to come off his line much at set pieces watching him last night but I thought Cardiffs long throws in the first half an whitinghams corners and free kicks second half were decent.

Give the op a break its all about opinions. Last night in the opening exchanges I heard Tom Clarke is not fit to be in this team and Robinson has no left foot!
 
Maxwell

Maxwell

I thought Maxwell had a great game tonight. Nothing spectacular, but did the basics really well. He positioned himself and the wall perfectly against Gomezs free kicks and even seemed to second guess what the Spaniard was thinking. He was also a superb sweeper behind the back four although once nearly got caught out. His kicking did improve as the game wore on as well. Really impressed!
 
I thought Maxwell had a great game tonight. Nothing spectacular, but did the basics really well. He positioned himself and the wall perfectly against Gomezs free kicks and even seemed to second guess what the Spaniard was thinking. He was also a superb sweeper behind the back four although once nearly got caught out. His kicking did improve as the game wore on as well. Really impressed!

Agreed,like an extra defender at times.
 
I thought Maxwell had a great game tonight. Nothing spectacular, but did the basics really well. He positioned himself and the wall perfectly against Gomezs free kicks and even seemed to second guess what the Spaniard was thinking. He was also a superb sweeper behind the back four although once nearly got caught out. His kicking did improve as the game wore on as well. Really impressed!

Completely agree especially with the sweeper keeper bit. Did the basics perfectly, even when he dropped the cross he smothered it second attempt and made absolutely sure they didn't get a shot away. Looks like he can make a save as well as prevent having to make a save because his judgment coming off his line tonight to clear any danger was very good.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
His kicking was poor 3 or 4 times in 1st half. Dropped a catch late in 2nd. I'll put it down to nerves on his 1st league game for us.

But I really enjoyed the command of his area. Swept up a lot of through balls at edge of box. Deserves to start in goals for a while.
 
Back
Top