Skip to main content

Keith Keane

Keith Keane

Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
3,648
There are that many player threads I don't know if we have one for Keane? Feel free to merge if we do.

Thought he was our stand out player last night. His distribution of the ball was excellent and I thought he out played the Burnley players. His communication with other players is also spot on.

Also, I had a quick look at the Burnley forum and they seem to agree. A couple of them even saying they would like to see a bid made for him. I really hope they don't as other than Keane and Byrom last night, I thought we where pretty poor.
 
Shrewd Westley signing and no there isn't a topic currently but numerous conversation regarding the matter. Would rather have Welsh in there and Keane at right back with Clarke at centre half.

Thought he was ok last night but my PNE MOTM was Byrom
 
Shrewd Westley signing and no there isn't a topic currently but numerous conversation regarding the matter. Would rather have Welsh in there and Keane at right back with Clarke at centre half.

Thought he was ok last night but my PNE MOTM was Byrom

You just don't like Keane because he looks like a chav...
 
Please keep him as a defensive centre midfielder. He is better than Welsh in that position and his talents would now be wasted if he reverted to right back.

Hopefully he will forge a strong partnership with Byrom who impressed in pre season and last night.
 
Please keep him as a defensive centre midfielder. He is better than Welsh in that position and his talents would now be wasted if he reverted to right back.

Hopefully he will forge a strong partnership with Byrom who impressed in pre season and last night.

Some fans do seem a but fickle. Byrom did play well last night and is now the new saviour (I have been praising him to) but Welsh is cast aside after being last seasons player of the year
 
Some fans do seem a but fickle. Byrom did play well last night and is now the new saviour (I have been praising him to) but Welsh is cast aside after being last seasons player of the year
No one's casting Welsh aside, it's just that Keane's playing better than him right now. The fact that he played well last season doesn't matter now, the team has to be picked on who's in form and right now Keane is in better form than Welsh. That doesn't mean Welsh won't play again, it's just he might have to sit on the bench for a few games and when he gets his chance, it's up to him to take it and win back his place in the side.
 
No one's casting Welsh aside, it's just that Keane's playing better than him right now. The fact that he played well last season doesn't matter now, the team has to be picked on who's in form and right now Keane is in better form than Welsh. That doesn't mean Welsh won't play again, it's just he might have to sit on the bench for a few games and when he gets his chance, it's up to him to take it and win back his place in the side.

No issue with that at all mate just the post I replied to it says he is better
 
No issue with that at all mate just the post I replied to it says he is better
Welsh is better on the ball, but Keane breaks up play better, it just depends what you prefer in a player. At least everyone's arguing over who's the better option, rather than who's less shit like in previous seasons.
 
Welsh is better on the ball, but Keane breaks up play better, it just depends what you prefer in a player. At least everyone's arguing over who's the better option, rather than who's less shit like in previous seasons.

I think Welsh is good at breaking up play and good in the tackle
 
Thought Keane was fantastic and proved he could play Championship football. He's not a midfielder in the classical sense, but gives his all by being totally committed. Byrom is a perfect foil by his passing skills. He looks to have lost weight since last season and was impressive. It was like signing a new player. Welsh and Keane are similar in that they tackle and break up play- it's up to the manager which gets the nod each week. Surely we will use both during this campaign.
 
I think Welsh is good at breaking up play and good in the tackle

So do I.

But that last night was the best midfield performance I've seen in a while.

Keane just edging Byrom for MOM in my opinion with both of them having fantastic games and for that reason, I'd keep it the same on Saturday.
 
So do I.

But that last night was the best midfield performance I've seen in a while.

Keane just edging Byrom for MOM in my opinion with both of them having fantastic games and for that reason, I'd keep it the same on Saturday.


While I agree with you to a certain extent Burnley passed it through and round us last night, decent they (Keane and Byrom) may be but far from good enough if we are to mount some sort of promotion push.

The midfield was not helped by Holmes pissing about all over the place and doing nothing, Humphrey was absent second half.
 
While I agree with you to a certain extent Burnley passed it through and round us last night, decent they (Keane and Byrom) may be but far from good enough if we are to mount some sort of promotion push.

The midfield was not helped by Holmes pissing about all over the place and doing nothing, Humphrey was absent second half.

We won't know until we try Billy!
 
While I agree with you to a certain extent Burnley passed it through and round us last night, decent they (Keane and Byrom) may be but far from good enough if we are to mount some sort of promotion push.

The midfield was not helped by Holmes pissing about all over the place and doing nothing, Humphrey was absent second half.

Burnley did get in and around us at some points, but to be fair, no one in league one will play with the kind of tempo Burnley did last night, they was quick and sharp and closed down very quick, after the first 5/10 mins i feared the worst for the night, thankfully we managed to get a foothold in the game.
 
Burnley did get in and around us at some points, but to be fair, no one in league one will play with the kind of tempo Burnley did last night, they was quick and sharp and closed down very quick, after the first 5/10 mins i feared the worst for the night, thankfully we managed to get a foothold in the game.


If you are being honest Mark, Burnley hardly got out of second gear after the break, we huffed and puffed and did very little, not helped by Holmes doing nothing all over the pitch and Humphrey just doing nothing second half.
 
If you are being honest Mark, Burnley hardly got out of second gear after the break, we huffed and puffed and did very little, not helped by Holmes doing nothing all over the pitch and Humphrey just doing nothing second half.


Holmes got on my nerves last night, left Laird exposed all game long and made more problems down the right than he solved. To say Burnley never tried to up it second half i think is a little unfair, Burnley didnt get chance to play at any real tempo, and barring the error by stucks for the free kick goal and the lucky 5 or 6 ricochets the ball took for the second, burnley never really looked dangerous.
 
This from a Burnley fan last night......

It reminded me of the times when we were a lower division club and played higher division clubs in the cup. Often we played well, looked the better team, but ended up losing, the higher division teams always seemed to find a way to win and that was the case in this game last night. As far as football was concerned they played us off the park, we were only comfortable in the last ten minutes when they ran out of steam. That was one of the least convincing 2-0 wins you're ever likely to see.

Not sure just how much we're missing Wallace, but it certainly didn't improve us not having him in, we were all over the place in midfield last night.
 
Holmes got on my nerves last night, left Laird exposed all game long and made more problems down the right than he solved. To say Burnley never tried to up it second half i think is a little unfair, Burnley didnt get chance to play at any real tempo, and barring the error by stucks for the free kick goal and the lucky 5 or 6 ricochets the ball took for the second, burnley never really looked dangerous.

honestly Mark they didn't have to, we were just what we are, an average 3rd division team that huffed and puffed but hardly set the heather alight.
 
Holmes got on my nerves last night, left Laird exposed all game long and made more problems down the right than he solved. To say Burnley never tried to up it second half i think is a little unfair, Burnley didnt get chance to play at any real tempo, and barring the error by stucks for the free kick goal and the lucky 5 or 6 ricochets the ball took for the second, burnley never really looked dangerous.
Holmes was playing in the middle behind Hume and Beavon, that's the problem wing backs bring, they have no cover in front of or behind them.
 
Back
Top