Skip to main content

Keith Keane

Keith Keane

Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
29
As much as admire him for giving 100% every game and wears his heart on his sleeve he just simply isn't a centre midfielder, he's to slow when he has the ball and never asks for the ball from any of the back 3 or 4 which central midfielder should be doing all the time, that's why we end up too many times playing a long ball forward. He can also become a bit of a headless chicken chasing the ball around and leaving his man free In the middle of the park. But the problem is we don't have anyone good enough to replace him.
All in all today we weren't good enough in any area, Humpherey's had a poor game but the more skillfull plays can be like that, Brian Mooney had games like that (even though on his day was 20x the player of Humphreys) and were very frustrating to watch. Thought Garner did well when he came on. his link up play is far better than Beavon.
All in all today was frustrating, Tranmere were a poor team and we played awful.
 
As much as admire him for giving 100% every game and wears his heart on his sleeve he just simply isn't a centre midfielder, he's to slow when he has the ball and never asks for the ball from any of the back 3 or 4 which central midfielder should be doing all the time, that's why we end up too many times playing a long ball forward. He can also become a bit of a headless chicken chasing the ball around and leaving his man free In the middle of the park. But the problem is we don't have anyone good enough to replace him.
All in all today we weren't good enough in any area, Humpherey's had a poor game but the more skillfull plays can be like that, Brian Mooney had games like that (even though on his day was 20x the player of Humphreys) and were very frustrating to watch. Thought Garner did well when he came on. his link up play is far better than Beavon.
All in all today was frustrating, Tranmere were a poor team and we played awful.

Also he missed our best chance in the first half from that brilliant through ball when he had a one to one with their goalie.
 
There goal came from him losing the ball too easily and then not getting up.

Never the MOTM in a million years!
 
Keane is similar to King - he is far, far better than you imagined when you found out we were signing him and googled to see what he was about. You want him to succeed more than anything, it would be brilliant. However, these things don't make him good enough.
 
I like Keane in midfield to be honest. He's certainly not the best all round but he breaks up play well. He's no worse than Welsh anyway. Our options in midfield as a whole are our biggest weakness by far and is the area we need to strengthen far more than any other.
 
Welsh is a much better player than Keane, his positional sense is better, his timing of a tackle is better and he's more comfortable on the ball. Keane's tackling is always 100% but most of the time just barges in and will take anything that moves!
 
I love Keano too, although he is verging on mentalism. He was close to a two footed lunge today, and also trampled their Monakana lookalike whilst he was down, which I thought was a little underhand.
 
One of the worst MOM awards ever (and there have been some shockers). The fella next to me had just said that Keane has had his worst game in a long while and then the next second he was announced as man of the match. Him and Welsh are too similar. I would prefer to give someone else a bash in there, particularly at home. We do have options - Mousinho, King, Byrom, the two young lads.
 
There goal came from him losing the ball too easily and then not getting up.

Harsh he was attacking in their final third, there were then 8 men at least between where he lost the ball and the goal, he couldn't do anything about that...unless you never want him to go forward.

I think Bailey was MOTM but I don't think anyone had a great game, you could pick any of them for the award as non particularly deserved it.
 
Back
Top