Skip to main content

Keith Keane

Keith Keane

Harsh he was attacking in their final third, there were then 8 men at least between where he lost the ball and the goal, he couldn't do anything about that...unless you never want him to go forward.

I think Bailey was MOTM but I don't think anyone had a great game, you could pick any of them for the award as non particularly deserved it.

Yeah, Bailey a decent shout, but also though Laird had a very good game yesterday. Despite me not being his biggest fan, I thought he showed his best form yesterday - possibly because we were in a 4-4-2.
 
Keane is flat footed and always runs "on his heels" he cannot change direction quickly and this is perhaps the reason why his tacking is so clumsy, just not a midfield player.
 
I thought we started off well playing 4-4-2 with Humphreys on the right and laird and Gallagher on the left troubling them but our central two especially Keane never asks for the ball or look to switch it which could get our wingers one on one against there markers. by the time our wingers do get the ball they are doubled up on especially Humphreys as Clarke doesn't look to help him going forward.
I do like trying other formations but with the players we have 3-4-1-2 doesn't suit us, we have two of the best full backs in the division in Keane and Laird, Plenty of great wingers in Humphereys, Holmes, Gallagher, Hayhurst and Monakana, all with one of the best headers of the ball in the division in Davies. so why play a formation that doesn't use our strengths going forward and makes us play longer and central as the wing backs aren't far enough forward because of defending duties. I just feel we are short of one good central midfielder that has a good passing range and quick vision to speed our attacks up and get our wingers up against there full backs one on one.
 
Keane is flat footed and always runs "on his heels" he cannot change direction quickly and this is perhaps the reason why his tacking is so clumsy, just not a midfield player.

Absolutely right. Looks shocked when he gets the ball and takes an age to make a decision about his pass.
 
Absolutely right. Looks shocked when he gets the ball and takes an age to make a decision about his pass.

As we saw twice in very good positions yesterday. Decent at right back, despite him flying in all the time, but is now getting lost in the middle. Welsh is a better option.
 
One of the worst MOM awards ever (and there have been some shockers). The fella next to me had just said that Keane has had his worst game in a long while and then the next second he was announced as man of the match. Him and Welsh are too similar. I would prefer to give someone else a bash in there, particularly at home. We do have options - Mousinho, King, Byrom, the two young lads.

Both are out and out spoilers,our midfield lacks any creativity at all and needs to be addressed a.s.a.p.
Tranmere looked the poorest team to come to deepdale this season and even they footballed us off the park at times, as have most if we are being honest.Its a damn good job that most of them couldnt hit a barn door with a banjo in the striking department or things would be much worse.
On the positive side gallagher added vision and skill, if he keeps the positive attitude he will make a difference and Garner looked a handful when he came on as did Holmes.
 
Both are out and out spoilers,our midfield lacks any creativity at all and needs to be addressed a.s.a.p.
Tranmere looked the poorest team to come to deepdale this season and even they footballed us off the park at times, as have most if we are being honest.Its a damn good job that most of them couldnt hit a barn door with a banjo in the striking department or things would be much worse.
On the positive side gallagher added vision and skill, if he keeps the positive attitude he will make a difference and Garner looked a handful when he came on as did Holmes.

I can't recall them passing us off the park.

Gallagher definitely a plus and agree with points about Holmes also. If we're going to play 4-4-2 then I would use these two as our wingers, with them swapping flanks every now and then.
 
Maybe passing us off the park was overstating it, most teams to visit deepdale this season have for periods in the game been much better than us at passing and keeping the ball while making progress up the field, something that we seem to really struggle with.
 
Why do fans become animated about the MOM award? It is conferred by the Sponsor and guests, probably one table of 12, some of whom will not know who Preston's players are.
 
Why do fans become animated about the MOM award? It is conferred by the Sponsor and guests, probably one table of 12, some of whom will not know who Preston's players are.

Exactly. Yesterday was one of those where there wasn't really a mom IMO but for impact then give it Garner!
 
Keane is a decent squad player and a solid right back in a straight 4-4-2. There's good reason he drifted into non-league though in that he just isn't that talented a footballer. Grayson can't wave a magic wand overnight and he must work with what he have.

Patience is required in a god-forsaken era of human evolution whereby none is allowed.
 
Keane is a decent squad player and a solid right back in a straight 4-4-2. There's good reason he drifted into non-league though in that he just isn't that talented a footballer. Grayson can't wave a magic wand overnight and he must work with what he have.

Patience is required in a god-forsaken era of human evolution whereby none is allowed.

Spot on.

Needs to play in defence or not at all for me.
 
Agree with what others have been saying, he's too similar of a player as Welsh, both defensive midfielders, we need a midfielder who can get forward into attacking positions and put a through ball to the strikers or have a pop at goal themselves. Poor perfomance from Keane on Saturday to be fair, but he was no worse than any of the other players. Frustrating performance on the whole.
 
Back
Top