Skip to main content

Kilkenny?

Kilkenny?

Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
17,283
Location
Cheshire
Although John welsh has been outstanding in recent games, Compared to Kilkenny where there is always a mistake in him especially that he cant tackle & gets caught drewlling on the ball a lot. in saying all that is it worth just giving Kilkenny a start in tomorrows game especially up against Jones & Smith who are slow but tough tacklers but having Kilkenny in the midfield for this game he might be able to move the ball quicker after he receives the ball of our back four & by doing so stop Jones/Smith getting their tackles in & dictating the game? ( only a suggestion)
 
Kilkenny is a defensive liability. There's been a few occasions this season(I.e. Rochdale away, fleetwood at home) when players just run past him and the opposition score.

He should have come on on Friday because Vale, like Bradford, had 10 men, but we need battlers in the middle for tuesday and he certainly isn't one.
 
If we want to beef up our midfield there are only two ways to do it. One is to bring in either King or Kilkenny at the expense of either Robinson or Gallagher to supplement Welsh and Johnson. The other is to revert to the wing-back formation with three defenders at the back and Humphrey, Welsh, Johnson and Laird across the middle.
 
I felt we should have brought him on once Vale went down to 10 men, he did a great job at Bradford of spreading the opposition and creating the space for us to move the ball around.

In terms of starting, I'm not sure who you would leave out for him? But I have to say I wouldn't be opposed to the idea altogether, but would be interested to see how the team would line up with him in there.
 
If we want to beef up our midfield there are only two ways to do it. One is to bring in either King or Kilkenny at the expense of either Robinson or Gallagher to supplement Welsh and Johnson. The other is to revert to the wing-back formation with three defenders at the back and Humphrey, Welsh, Johnson and Laird across the middle.

Or you don't play Beckford or Garner, and you play 4-5-1/4-3-3. Play 3 centre midfielders in Welsh, Johnson and Kilkenny, and have Robinson and Gallagher out wide supporting Garner or Beckford. We should have done this as soon as we went 2-1 up at Vale. Kilkenny was instrumental when he came on against 10 man Bradford.
 
Or you don't play Beckford or Garner, and you play 4-5-1/4-3-3. Play 3 centre midfielders in Welsh, Johnson and Kilkenny, and have Robinson and Gallagher out wide supporting Garner or Beckford. We should have done this as soon as we went 2-1 up at Vale. Kilkenny was instrumental when he came on against 10 man Bradford.

+1 Kilkenny has his faults but his biggests attributes are his willingness to receive the ball and his composure on it.
 
Or you don't play Beckford or Garner, and you play 4-5-1/4-3-3. Play 3 centre midfielders in Welsh, Johnson and Kilkenny, and have Robinson and Gallagher out wide supporting Garner or Beckford. We should have done this as soon as we went 2-1 up at Vale. Kilkenny was instrumental when he came on against 10 man Bradford.

No Garner by himself is a false strategy - though Robinson sticking closer to him could work, as might Ebanks-Blake or Davies. Yes we would still need width and apart from Gallagher moving wide we would get it by having Laird at left-back and either Wiseman or Woods at right-back, which in turn would mean only two out of Clarke, Huntington and Wright.
 
No Garner by himself is a false strategy - though Robinson sticking closer to him could work, as might Ebanks-Blake or Davies. Yes we would still need width and apart from Gallagher moving wide we would get it by having Laird at left-back and either Wiseman or Woods at right-back, which in turn would mean only two out of Clarke, Huntington and Wright.

When Robinson returned to us, and Beckford was not in the starting 11, we played 5 of which we won 4 and drew 1. 2.6 points a game average. Our formation was flexible in them games, and we played 4-4-2, 4-3-3 and 4-5-1. But I would say we mostly didn't play 2 straight up front as Robinson isn't well suited in that position yet.

This changed from Crewe onwards, when Beckford has started every game since, meaning we've always gone 2 up front. Played 9, won 4 and drawn 5. 1.89 points a game average.

Quite a big drop in form since we've changed formation to play 2 upfront. This isn't down to Beckford, but it does show that Garner upfront alone, can work. It certainly allows to be more flexible and able to adapt at any part of the game without making a sub.
 
When Robinson returned to us, and Beckford was not in the starting 11, we played 5 of which we won 4 and drew 1. 2.6 points a game average. Our formation was flexible in them games, and we played 4-4-2, 4-3-3 and 4-5-1. But I would say we mostly didn't play 2 straight up front as Robinson isn't well suited in that position yet.

This changed from Crewe onwards, when Beckford has started every game since, meaning we've always gone 2 up front. Played 9, won 4 and drawn 5. 1.89 points a game average.

Quite a big drop in form since we've changed formation to play 2 upfront. This isn't down to Beckford, but it does show that Garner upfront alone, can work. It certainly allows to be more flexible and able to adapt at any part of the game without making a sub.

This is an important thread. Most particularly the post I've highlighted. We were at our most dynamic when we had one out an out striker, Welsh sitting and four roaming midfielders in Humphrey, Robinson, Johnson and Gallagher.

Since Beckford has come in, we've been playing without a right winger which has caused us no end of problems defensively. Likewise, we've not been getting the best out of Garner. I'd bench Beckford as we know he can do the business but it's for the greater good that he plays second fiddle to Joey.
 
Don't know what he's been like for you (if ,indeed he's been playing) ,but he was pretty shite for us. One good game in 4/5 .Always talked a good game with loads of pointing and gestures !

Anyhoo, getting tight for you lads, come on win this one and ease the pressure on yourselves then do the bizzo against the inbreds, jobs a good'un ! We're still all rooting for ya. Come on in the water's lovely !
 
Don't know what he's been like for you (if ,indeed he's been playing) ,but he was pretty shite for us. One good game in 4/5 .Always talked a good game with loads of pointing and gestures !

Anyhoo, getting tight for you lads, come on win this one and ease the pressure on yourselves then do the bizzo against the inbreds, jobs a good'un ! We're still all rooting for ya. Come on in the water's lovely !

Unless he has completely changed, if Kilkenny is the answer, you are asking the wrong question...
 
Back
Top