Skip to main content

Killkenny & Brownhill ?

Killkenny & Brownhill ?

I think Brownhill was great (again) when he came on, he should be starting games, not just coming on now and again as a sub.
 
Does anyone think that both Neil & Josh could play together as a 2CM in a 4 man midfield or are they too lightweight?

Probably too lightweight. But along with Welsh they could make a good platform from which Gallagher, Garner and either Davies could form the spearhead.
 
I think Brownhill was great (again) when he came on, he should be starting games, not just coming on now and again as a sub.

I agree & that's why I'm asking because SG has admitted on Radio Lancs tonight that John welsh has went for a scan on his injury Knee at tea time tonight & they hope that's there's no damaged done. So I was just wondering If Welsh is out for a while could Josh & Neil play together as 2 CM in a 4 man midfield.
 
I think Brownhill was great (again) when he came on, he should be starting games, not just coming on now and again as a sub.

Personally I thought Brownhill and King coming on changed the game in their favour.

Bit too fucking early for my liking as well. Double sub concerning both 5 mins later - would have been 5 points in the bag.
 
Kilkenny and Brownhill would be too lightweight in the centre of midfield, you could play Brownhill in there with either Keane and Welsh plus Kilkenny.

The problem is I don't like 4-3-3 at home because it gives us no width and we are forced to play through the middle, which is recent games has been packed with 5 midfielders plus the striker dropping back in the hope that they get a point.
 
Kilkenny and Brownhill would be too lightweight in the centre of midfield, you could play Brownhill in there with either Keane and Welsh plus Kilkenny.

The problem is I don't like 4-3-3 at home because it gives us no width and we are forced to play through the middle, which is recent games has been packed with 5 midfielders plus the striker dropping back in the hope that they get a point.

Problem with Keane is that he offers nothing with the ball and at times his positional sense leaves a lot to be desired.
 
Kilkenny and Brownhill would be too lightweight in the centre of midfield, you could play Brownhill in there with either Keane and Welsh plus Kilkenny.

The problem is I don't like 4-3-3 at home because it gives us no width and we are forced to play through the middle, which is recent games has been packed with 5 midfielders plus the striker dropping back in the hope that they get a point.

I go against the grain and maintain that 3 at the back suits our players much better. It allows is to play 3 in the middle and that is the only way Keane can be effective IMO as he is simply not up to playing in a 2 at this level. Three at the back does not necessarily need to be defensive, it depends on the mindset of the wide players and three gives us the height and passing of King.

I wonder when we will see Byrom again? He's got another contract so Grayson must see something and the number of our players who comment on his ability suggests there's more to come - Laird commented last night that we haven't seen the best of him.
 
3 at the back suits our players much better. It allows is to play 3 in the middle and that is the only way Keane can be effective IMO as he is simply not up to playing in a 2 at this level

Three at the back does suit us - in away matches where we can sit back and hit the opposition on the break. But whatever formation we play at home we are hamstrung by our lack of consistently effective attacking midfielders. In any case the three in the middle becomes two if Gallagher is behind the strikers. Also with no fullbacks we are more or less comitted to playing Humphrey on the right and Laird on the left because of their defensive qualities - yet neither has proven particularly good at the attacking side of that role though Humphrey seems to have upped his act a bit in the last couple of matches. Laird, though, is simply out-of-position - he is a left-back in a back four. A wide midfielder able both to defend and attack - someone like Coutts or Sedgwick (when we first signed him) - would solve a lot of problems for us.
 
Last edited:
Brownhill and Kilkenny would only be effective in the centre if we were playing really shite opposition or if supported by a strong defensive CM.
 
Three at the back does suit us - in away matches where we can sit back and hit the opposition on the break. But whatever formation we play at home we are hamstrung by our lack of consistently effective attacking midfielders. In any case the three in the middle becomes two if Gallagher is behind the strikers. Also with no fullbacks we are more or less comitted to playing Humphrey on the right and Laird on the left because of their defensive qualities - yet neither has proven particularly good at the attacking side of that role though Humphrey seems to have upped his act a bit in the last couple of matches. Laird, though, is simply out-of-position - he is a left-back in a back four. A wide midfielder able both to defend and attack - someone like Coutts or Sedgwick (when we first signed him) - would solve a lot of problems for us.

Cartwright would have been ideal for the player you suggest in my view but obviously all three have gone! I think Humphrey is infuriating but in the three formation he can be a threat, particularly with the ball in between the full back and centre half he can run onto. He rarely however makes a situation happen himself, he relies on someone else creating it for him, normally Gallagher but we need to find a way to get Brownhill in there to do the same.

I'm not sure about Laird. I do think he's better at full back than wing back but the lack of an in form left winger impacts on him when he's at full back. Gallagher does not play as a conventional winger and as such the pragmatic thing is to play Laird wing back - although not ideal, it's probably the best use of resources at the moment.
 
Thanks wld. I think last night's starting formation was basically a compromise that didn't work. If we have four at the back plus Gallagher and two strikers then assuming two of the other three outfield players are Welsh (or Keane) and Kilkenny then we need the third to be Brownhill (or Keane) to give us a balanced midfield - the width then has to come from Wiseman and Laird getting up in support. If want to play a conventional 4.4.2 with Humphrey wider on the right then we need Holmes (or Hayhurst) on the left because Gallagher is not a wide player and will always end up behind the strikers (the same, as Randall says, is he case with Brownhill). Of those two options I think we should start with that first 4.3.1.2 formation at home with Humphrey and Holmes held back for possible use later against tiring opposition - it isn't perfect but it seems to me to be the best use of the resources we actually possess.
 
Last edited:
Brownhill over Killkenny for me every time.

Nice tidy footballer that he is Killkenny, he never hurts the opposition, sideways or backwards most of the time, doesn't score goals and powder puff in the tackle.


Brownhill is a better tackler, has a killer ball, will run at the opposition and scores goals.
 
Nope, not as far as I'm concerned. Has anyone even taken notice of his complete inability to defend or close down?

He's a great talent but there's a reason Grayson only plays him in a midfield three. What we need is to play our strongest 442, preferably with Welsh in with Kilkenny, then continue to play positively throughout (even after taking the lead, Simon) .
 
Back
Top