Skip to main content

Leader

Leader

Joined
Nov 9, 2010
Messages
8,287
Location
York
I said it last season that in my view we would not get promoted for one reason - the absence of a leader. Someone who could literally drag a team by their bollocks over the winning line. A Gregan. A Lucketti. A Moyes.

Pleased as I am with the signings, my main worry remains as to where that leadership is coming from. I really thought we would sign Peter Clarke to fulfil that role but it seems not. So who? Welshy, Bailey etc are nice guys and couldn't do more for the club but they are not natural leaders. Big problem to solve.
 
I said it last season that in my view we would not get promoted for one reason - the absence of a leader. Someone who could literally drag a team by their bollocks over the winning line. A Gregan. A Lucketti. A Moyes.

Pleased as I am with the signings, my main worry remains as to where that leadership is coming from. I really thought we would sign Peter Clarke to fulfil that role but it seems not. So who? Welshy, Bailey etc are nice guys and couldn't do more for the club but they are not natural leaders. Big problem to solve.


I'm certain that it isn't someone who's here already
 
I agree with the idea we need someone who can really take the lead of the team on the pitch. Especially noticeable that this has been absent were on occasions last seasons where we went behind in games, there wasn't a player who could force the team to fight back. We very rarely came out on top when things got tough.

For me Welsh just isn't a big enough presence to do this successfully, nor is he talented enough to step his game up and set an example for the rest of the team when it is required.
 
I'd make Joey Garner the Captain.

Lead from the front with an aggressive but lethal player.
 
I agree we haven't had a great leader/captain since lucketti or Gregan. I don't agree with Jack about Garner as I simply don't like strikers or goalies to be captain. No the player needs to be a central defender or midfielder.
 
I said it last season that in my view we would not get promoted for one reason - the absence of a leader. Someone who could literally drag a team by their bollocks over the winning line. A Gregan. A Lucketti. A Moyes.

Pleased as I am with the signings, my main worry remains as to where that leadership is coming from. I really thought we would sign Peter Clarke to fulfil that role but it seems not. So who? Welshy, Bailey etc are nice guys and couldn't do more for the club but they are not natural leaders. Big problem to solve.



I don't think Moyes was the 'leader' that would drag a team by their bollocks (unless your talking about him as a manager??)
 
Such players are few and far between. The national team haven't got one! I don't think it's absolutely necessary as long as you have a core of experienced players, which we have with the likes of Clarke, Wiseman, Kilkenny and Davies who can hopefully be leaders in their particular areas of the pitch.
 
I've never liked strikers as captains. Fine when things are going well but hard to focus on scoring when your having to sort the rest of the team out when things aren't going to plan.
 
I agree we haven't had a great leader/captain since lucketti or Gregan. I don't agree with Jack about Garner as I simply don't like strikers or goalies to be captain. No the player needs to be a central defender or midfielder.

agree with this
 
Leader

I'd make Joey Garner the Captain.

Lead from the front with an aggressive but lethal player.

Not for me.

We don't want to do anything which could effect Joey from banging in more goals next season and I don't like strikers as captains anyway.

I think the OP does make a great point though.
 
I said it last season that in my view we would not get promoted for one reason - the absence of a leader. Someone who could literally drag a team by their bollocks over the winning line. A Gregan. A Lucketti. A Moyes.

Pleased as I am with the signings, my main worry remains as to where that leadership is coming from. I really thought we would sign Peter Clarke to fulfil that role but it seems not. So who? Welshy, Bailey etc are nice guys and couldn't do more for the club but they are not natural leaders. Big problem to solve.


King would make a great leader
 
A leader is certainly required. I don't mind Welsh but he's no captain. Not by a long shot. The fact he was sat on the bench with his head down during the Rotherham game told me everything. He should have been stood up rallying the players on the pitch, not wallowing. He obviously cares, but that's not enough.
 
King would make a great leader

Disagree. Seems like the joker of the squad. Can't imagine him bollocking the players around him. The main issue is that we don't have any commanding players, even at centre back.

We've had a long line of central defenders who have been a bit weak in terms of presence. The likes of Craig Morgan, Neil Collins etc. Big powerful lads but they don't have a presence of authority. Someone like Lucketti took no shit, was never bullied off the ball, wasn't afraid to bollock his team mates and had courage in his convictions. Gregan was the same.
 
I said it last season that in my view we would not get promoted for one reason - the absence of a leader. Someone who could literally drag a team by their bollocks over the winning line. A Gregan. A Lucketti. A Moyes.

Pleased as I am with the signings, my main worry remains as to where that leadership is coming from. I really thought we would sign Peter Clarke to fulfil that role but it seems not. So who? Welshy, Bailey etc are nice guys and couldn't do more for the club but they are not natural leaders. Big problem to solve.

Even though we released him when he was a youngish midfielder, Alan McCormack was exactly that for Brentford last year.
 
Disagree. Seems like the joker of the squad. Can't imagine him bollocking the players around him. The main issue is that we don't have any commanding players, even at centre back.

We've had a long line of central defenders who have been a bit weak in terms of presence. The likes of Craig Morgan, Neil Collins etc. Big powerful lads but they don't have a presence of authority. Someone like Lucketti took no shit, was never bullied off the ball, wasn't afraid to bollock his team mates and had courage in his convictions. Gregan was the same.


But he would kick fuck out of you if you disagreed so i think he'd be a good leader😉

Yes i suppose he is a joker and not serious enough if that makes sense. In that case Keano but i think he will be off soon. Plus hes not first team anymore.:thumbsup:
 
No - Do not give our talisman, only top goal scorer anymore pressure by having to wear the armband.

Leave him free of any other duties apart from putting the ball in the back of the Onion Bag!

Not joey Garner as captain
 
Back
Top