Skip to main content

Leaders

Leaders

Joined
Apr 1, 2015
Messages
190
Where are they? Where in our team can you find the leaders, ones to help drag us out this poor run because I for once certainly don't see one in Tom Clarke. Yes he scored the winner against Blackpool but that was 2 and a bit years ago, about time he was stripped of captaincy and it was given to Welsh, Hunts or even Bailey Wright. Clarke isn't vocal enough and often is caught out a lot, change needed.
 
Where are they? Where in our team can you find the leaders, ones to help drag us out this poor run because I for once certainly don't see one in Tom Clarke. Yes he scored the winner against Blackpool but that was 2 and a bit years ago, about time he was stripped of captaincy and it was given to Welsh, Hunts or even Bailey Wright. Clarke isn't vocal enough and often is caught out a lot, change needed.

I sort of agree with you in that if a player isn't wholly confident in himself, which Clarke appears not to be at this level, then it's a) bound to affect his own leadership and b) difficult to expect the others to follow.
 
To be fair, we have no idea what sort of an influence on the players he (Clarke) is off the pitch - it may be that he is the perfect role model for younger professionals and that's why SG's picked him. And I do like Clarke, I think he is passionate and he is determined, he's just a bit quiet. That's not always the death knell for a captaincy.

On the pitch though, I agree that Welsh is more of a "verbal organiser", and he's in a role where it would suit him to be Captain.
 
I was disappointed that as Captain, Clarke didn't lead by example and take one of the 5 penalties t'other night.
 
Where are they? Where in our team can you find the leaders, ones to help drag us out this poor run because I for once certainly don't see one in Tom Clarke. Yes he scored the winner against Blackpool but that was 2 and a bit years ago, about time he was stripped of captaincy and it was given to Welsh, Hunts or even Bailey Wright. Clarke isn't vocal enough and often is caught out a lot, change needed.

There was a similar thread last year.

I was disappointed that as Captain, Clarke didn't lead by example and take one of the 5 penalties t'other night.

Really? You think a captain has to take a penalty in a shoot out? Would you want him or say Huntington taking a penalty over a more attacking player?
 
Really? You think a captain has to take a penalty in a shoot out? Would you want him or say Huntington taking a penalty over a more attacking player?

Lead by example.

It only 12 yards out ffs. One on One.
 
Can someone please remind me what the whole Club/Team Captain jazz is about with Welsh and Clarke?

For me Welsh would be captain all day long, on and off the pitch.
 
Lead by example.

It only 12 yards out ffs. One on One.

I'd rather the best 5 penalty takers stepped up tbh.

If it was as simple as you say then why are so many penalties missed? Messi has missed 6 out of his last 12. I'm sure if Clarke had stepped up and put it over the bar there'd be "why is Clarke taking a pen when Browne, Johnson, Hugill, Keane haven't?"
 
I'd rather the best 5 penalty takers stepped up tbh.

If it was as simple as you say then why are so many penalties missed? Messi has missed 6 out of his last 12. I'm sure if Clarke had stepped up and put it over the bar there'd be "why is Clarke taking a pen when Browne, Johnson, Hugill, Keane haven't?"

Hindsight and all that but of those mentioned, 3 missed.

Just my view that a Captain should be in the 5. The odds are with the guy taking the penalty, not the keeper. Ryan Kidd, as an example of a defender who didn't score many, often stepped up and converted.
 
Can someone please remind me what the whole Club/Team Captain jazz is about with Welsh and Clarke?

For me Welsh would be captain all day long, on and off the pitch.

So you have personal experience of Tom Clarke & John Welsh's influence off the pitch to jump to that conclusion do you?

For me there should be leaders all over the pitch in any team & it not just be down to the captain. The captain of a team doesnt necessarily have to be the most vocal
 
Can someone please remind me what the whole Club/Team Captain jazz is about with Welsh and Clarke?

For me Welsh would be captain all day long, on and off the pitch.

I couldn't disagree more. Although Welsh has genuine passion and he wears his heart on his sleeve, that doesn't make him captain material. That was epitomised in the Rotherham away leg. Once they went 3-2 up on aggregate his head dropped. He was subbed and sat on the bench with his head on his knees facing away from the pitch. A captain should be geeing up his team-mates whether on the pitch or off. That's not the kind of character you want inspiring the rest of the team. I agree that we are lacking someone with the grit that the likes of Gregan, Lucketti, O'Neil had in spades.
 
Pickford should have taken one. Power reigns after 120mins. And DJ shouldn't have repeated his pen albeit even more casually.
 
Back
Top