Lets get it reet!
- Joined
- May 8, 2004
- Messages
- 19,187
A silly thread in my opinion. Some of the Stuckman love is getting embarrassing. As for Laird, I actually like him but a big loss? Not for me.
Simon is taking a sensible approach and I do believe we are going to be announcing some big things in the coming weeks. Stop over reacting and enjoy the ride.
Simon is taking a sensible approach and I do believe we are going to be announcing some big things in the coming weeks. Stop over reacting and enjoy the ride.
Are we playing this Saturday?
Exactly.............some very much jumped to conclusions and big time impatience shown by the OP. Not to mention totally unfounded veiled criticism of SG.
Neither of the players in question made the starting line up v Swindon, it's not like we are losing proven players at the level we will be playing at next season is it?
We a re the 'Mighty Whites' we are PRESTON, we need a squad of 25-30, at the moment, 8 out, 1 in, the diamond who got a hat trick is the only addition.
A squad of thirty ?
Often less is more !
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2014
- Messages
- 2,465
Sentimentally I'd have liked both to stay as back up but neither leaving will dent our hopes of a good season.
+1
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2010
- Messages
- 3,891
" A silly thread in my opinion. Some of the Stuckman love is getting embarrassing. As for Laird, I actually like him but a big loss? Not for me.
Simon is taking a sensible approach and I do believe we are going to be announcing some big things in the coming weeks. Stop over reacting and enjoy the ride. "
It is his team , he got Huddersfield who'd always been a good League One team up , and had to sell his best forward Rhodes to Blackburn , the plan was survival in the Championship ; not setting the division alight . The problem was that he had a bad run , was it ten or 12 matches ? and got the sack , normally at Preston there's been bad runs in January and slow starts ; he's hardly going to make the same mistakes again after the Terriers and Dirty Leeds .
" Uncle Trev " Hemmings wants a top 12 finish with probably the play offs the next season , so not being funny , we'll just have to trust him and his staff .
Some good points - you don't to be like Yeovil , who to be fair weren't that good in League 1 and had an absolutely threadbare budget , Doncaster or Barnsley who kept the 'kin Lashers up , or even Rotherham . Going back a bit further , I remember Scunthorpe being a yo - yo team http://www.onefootballforum.co.uk/index.php?threads/the-quality-of-this-league.5990/
As a long shot - I fancy Milton Keynes to do quite well , they could do better than Bristol - though I could be wrong .
Simon is taking a sensible approach and I do believe we are going to be announcing some big things in the coming weeks. Stop over reacting and enjoy the ride. "
Exactly, no room for sentiment.
It is his team , he got Huddersfield who'd always been a good League One team up , and had to sell his best forward Rhodes to Blackburn , the plan was survival in the Championship ; not setting the division alight . The problem was that he had a bad run , was it ten or 12 matches ? and got the sack , normally at Preston there's been bad runs in January and slow starts ; he's hardly going to make the same mistakes again after the Terriers and Dirty Leeds .
" Uncle Trev " Hemmings wants a top 12 finish with probably the play offs the next season , so not being funny , we'll just have to trust him and his staff .
Some good points - you don't to be like Yeovil , who to be fair weren't that good in League 1 and had an absolutely threadbare budget , Doncaster or Barnsley who kept the 'kin Lashers up , or even Rotherham . Going back a bit further , I remember Scunthorpe being a yo - yo team http://www.onefootballforum.co.uk/index.php?threads/the-quality-of-this-league.5990/
As a long shot - I fancy Milton Keynes to do quite well , they could do better than Bristol - though I could be wrong .
Last edited:
" A silly thread in my opinion. Some of the Stuckman love is getting embarrassing. As for Laird, I actually like him but a big loss? Not for me.
Simon is taking a sensible approach and I do believe we are going to be announcing some big things in the coming weeks. Stop over reacting and enjoy the ride. "
It is his team , he got Huddersfield who'd always been a good League One team up , and had to sell his best forward Rhodes to Blackburn , the plan was survival in the Championship ; not setting the division alight . The problem was that he had a bad run , was it ten or 12 matches ? and got the sack , normally at Preston there's been bad runs in January and slow starts ; he's hardly going to make the same mistakes again after the Terriers and Dirty Leeds .
" Uncle Trev " Hemmings wants a top 12 finish with probably the play offs the next season , so not being funny , we'll just have to trust him and his staff .
Some good points - you don't to be like Yeovil , who to be fair weren't that good in League 1 and had an absolutely threadbare budget , Doncaster or Barnsley who kept the 'kin Lashers up , or even Rotherham . Going back a bit further , I remember Scunthorpe being a yo - yo team http://www.onefootballforum.co.uk/index.php?threads/the-quality-of-this-league.5990/
As a long shot - I fancy Milton Keynes to do quite well , they could do better than Bristol - though I could be wrong .
I think we will do the best of the 3 that went up personally and think the other two may struggle. I don't think Agard and Wilbraham will be too effective in the Championship and will MK Dons not have already lost their best player?
How does strengthening for the Championship equate to keeping our reserve keeper and a left back who had also dropped down the pecking order in the last weeks of League One and evidently wasn't ever going to be the player he was pre-injury? Both have been terrific servants for the clubs and very likeable characters, but it is onwards and upwards for us whilst they remain in the lower leagues.
+1. I liked them both but not good enough.
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2004
- Messages
- 9,016
I suspect that in the case of laird it was nothing to do with the contract at all but more that he knew he wouldn't be first choice and maybe just maybe he realises that it may be beyond him? I mean the 3 year deal at Scunthorpe or 2 years for a far bigger club in the championship and lets face it the wage offered here I would think will be far and above the Scunthorpe one.....don't think this was a bad decision by PNE but all laird himselfWho in our management team 'PNE', gave the go-ahead to not keep hold of Laird and Stuckmann, utter bad decisions, this squad needs strengthening, rebuilding for the Championship, don't think that we can afford to not compete for the likes of the named two.
I hope that Grayson has a list as long as his arm. One thing is for sure we need about 6 or 7 additions, 2 must be keepers.
Give us some positives Larry? We just lost a 'Talisman' 'The Stuck' and Scott Laird, some good news please.......
Who in our management team 'PNE', gave the go-ahead to not keep hold of Laird and Stuckmann, utter bad decisions, this squad needs strengthening, rebuilding for the Championship, don't think that we can afford to not compete for the likes of the named two.
I hope that Grayson has a list as long as his arm. One thing is for sure we need about 6 or 7 additions, 2 must be keepers.
Give us some positives Larry? We just lost a 'Talisman' 'The Stuck' and Scott Laird, some good news please.......
Can I take this opportunity to remid you that todays date is the 12th of June?
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 2,896
Listen - I know nowt about football,
true
I'll tell you what, I have never in a long time been so proud of PNE. PNE 4 - Swindon 0.
Watched the game in Spain and I got shit faced and mental.
I have the faith in Larry.
COYW.
you were shit faced when you wrote this thread
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2010
- Messages
- 3,891
I think we will do the best of the 3 that went up personally and think the other two may struggle. I don't think Agard and Wilbraham will be too effective in the Championship and will MK Dons not have already lost their best player?
Funnily enough some of the Bristol fans think Wilbraham is too old and Agard - who ironically was signed from Rotherham for a undisclosed fee , some allege it was about 1m ; isn't strong enough for the Championship . I think Evans went wrong with Rotherham doing a Westley or John Beck chopping and changing players , I'd need to know where the orders were coming from though ; was it Evans himself ; or did they come from upstairs ?
http://www.otib.co.uk/index.php?/topic/169756-kieran-agard/ " HLR
Posted 27 April 2015 - 09:11 AM
Is anyone else worried that Agard is going to really struggle in the championship next year? Don't get me wrong, he works hard, but there's very often very little end product, very easily shoved off the ball and his touch is mostly horrendous. Really want him to come good as he does give his all but not sure how he will do if he is a regular starter.... "
However the formation that Evans had at Rotherham and the one that Cotterill plays at Bristol are totally different and may not suit him ? , they still got 99 points though .
" Red Army
Posted 27 April 2015 - 10:11 AM
I could be wrong but at Rotherham he didn't play as an out and out striker he played on the right in a 3 man attack so you could argue that he isn't being played in his best position. Think I remember the Rothetham manager saying that Agard best position is on the right prior to signing.
This position isn't in our normal formation so he has had to adjust.
http://www.themillers.co.uk/news/article/kieran-agard-lands-monthly-award-1522495.aspx "
MK Dons have arguably relied too much on loan players - maybe they can attract them from London & South Eastern Clubs as the place is supposed to be halfway between London & Birmingham . I respect the amount of goals they scored in League 1 and the players that they have bought through . It doesn't matter if you like the franchisee idea and Karl Robinson or not .
Preston could do reasonably well , Beckford even at his age and Garner are definitely Championship standard , all they have to do is give them the service and defend properly . Maybe Simon Grayson is strengthening the defence and midfield to Championship standard ?
Last edited:
Quite an interesting decision by Laird when you consider how much he had become a fixture in the side until right at the end of the season. I suspect that having let Buchanan go and with no apparent competition from Ben Davies, Grayson told him that he was looking for a left back and with Woods proving capable of filling that role too, he may have felt his time was up. During all his time here Scott has given his all and there has been healthy competition for the left back spot when he wasn't recuperating from his broken leg.I suspect that in the case of laird it was nothing to do with the contract at all but more that he knew he wouldn't be first choice and maybe just maybe he realises that it may be beyond him? I mean the 3 year deal at Scunthorpe or 2 years for a far bigger club in the championship and lets face it the wage offered here I would think will be far and above the Scunthorpe one.....don't think this was a bad decision by PNE but all laird himself
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2005
- Messages
- 6,233
Who in our management team 'PNE', gave the go-ahead to not keep hold of Laird and Stuckmann, utter bad decisions, this squad needs strengthening, rebuilding for the Championship, don't think that we can afford to not compete for the likes of the named two.
I hope that Grayson has a list as long as his arm. One thing is for sure we need about 6 or 7 additions, 2 must be keepers.
Give us some positives Larry? We just lost a 'Talisman' 'The Stuck' and Scott Laird, some good news please.......
Laird has a good attitude which seems to be enough for fans who look for nothing more than 100% effort players. On the analysis, Laird is responsible for many a good attacking move faltering.
Stuckmann another great servant but he has played his best football already, and he isn't going to progress at the higher level.
Smart move in my opinion, based on skill level and liability when on the ball.