Skip to main content

Loan players

Loan players

Joined
Jul 8, 2010
Messages
12,720
We currently have 4 players on loan, and I think this is one area that Grayson has got it spot on. Johnstone is an excellent keeper, but the timing of his signing seemed a little strange, but these opportunities don't come along very often. I don't think it did Johnstone/Stuckmann or the team any favours with us still involved in 2 cups. One game Johnstone then the next Stuckers until we went out of both Cup competitions.

Beckford is a decent/good signing IMO. He makes intelligent runs and is a class finisher. He appears to have the right mental attitude for this team.

Robinson comes accross as so dedicated to this club you have to question that he isn't actually a PNE player. He has the best attitude of any loan player we've had in a very long time IMO. He is improving at a rate of knots and I really hope we can make him a permanent signing in the summer. If Villa were to tell him he hadn't got a future with them, I think he would be a shoe in to sign for us.

Gallagher obviously wants to sign permanently for us, but I think we would need to be in the Championship for that to happen. He is a quality player who has worked harder as the season has progressed.

These 4 players have made a difference, and i would love to see them all here next season.

In comparison, MK Dons currently have 8 players on loan, but they can only name 5 of them in their squad at any one time. Robinson seems to be trying to keep them all happy by rotating them, and that isn't working at the moment.

For the first time this season, I don't think another loan signing would do us much good. In fact, another loan signing could upset the apple cart.

I would be interested in other opinions regarding our loan signings and whether people would like any further signings to come in.

Personally, I wouldn't bring in another loan unless we pick up a serious injury to a major player. Daniel Johnson for instance has made a big difference, and if he got injured I don't think we have anyone to do the job he does. I think we have suitable replacements for most positions but Johnson would be a big loss to replace.
 
gallagher will sign whatever division, assuming grayson wants him

agree graysons loans have been excellent in general

johnstone is a class above
 
At the moment, i wouldnt do anything to rock the boat. Good players for every position, we pose a real attacking threat, and looking at what we have going forward (gally, johnson, garner, kev, robinson, humphrey & beckford) you'd arguably say we have the best and most experienced attack in the division.
 
We currently have 4 players on loan, and I think this is one area that Grayson has got it spot on. Johnstone is an excellent keeper, but the timing of his signing seemed a little strange, but these opportunities don't come along very often. I don't think it did Johnstone/Stuckmann or the team any favours with us still involved in 2 cups. One game Johnstone then the next Stuckers until we went out of both Cup competitions.

Beckford is a decent/good signing IMO. He makes intelligent runs and is a class finisher. He appears to have the right mental attitude for this team.

Robinson comes accross as so dedicated to this club you have to question that he isn't actually a PNE player. He has the best attitude of any loan player we've had in a very long time IMO. He is improving at a rate of knots and I really hope we can make him a permanent signing in the summer. If Villa were to tell him he hadn't got a future with them, I think he would be a shoe in to sign for us.

Gallagher obviously wants to sign permanently for us, but I think we would need to be in the Championship for that to happen. He is a quality player who has worked harder as the season has progressed.

These 4 players have made a difference, and i would love to see them all here next season.

In comparison, MK Dons currently have 8 players on loan, but they can only name 5 of them in their squad at any one time. Robinson seems to be trying to keep them all happy by rotating them, and that isn't working at the moment.

For the first time this season, I don't think another loan signing would do us much good. In fact, another loan signing could upset the apple cart.

I would be interested in other opinions regarding our loan signings and whether people would like any further signings to come in.

Personally, I wouldn't bring in another loan unless we pick up a serious injury to a major player. Daniel Johnson for instance has made a big difference, and if he got injured I don't think we have anyone to do the job he does. I think we have suitable replacements for most positions but Johnson would be a big loss to replace.

agree but the loan window does close on the last Thursday in March so if we do sign someone it will have to be by 5pm on that last Thursday in March?
 
We currently have 4 players on loan, and I think this is one area that Grayson has got it spot on. Johnstone is an excellent keeper, but the timing of his signing seemed a little strange, but these opportunities don't come along very often. I don't think it did Johnstone/Stuckmann or the team any favours with us still involved in 2 cups. One game Johnstone then the next Stuckers until we went out of both Cup competitions.

Beckford is a decent/good signing IMO. He makes intelligent runs and is a class finisher. He appears to have the right mental attitude for this team.

Robinson comes accross as so dedicated to this club you have to question that he isn't actually a PNE player. He has the best attitude of any loan player we've had in a very long time IMO. He is improving at a rate of knots and I really hope we can make him a permanent signing in the summer. If Villa were to tell him he hadn't got a future with them, I think he would be a shoe in to sign for us.

Gallagher obviously wants to sign permanently for us, but I think we would need to be in the Championship for that to happen. He is a quality player who has worked harder as the season has progressed.

These 4 players have made a difference, and i would love to see them all here next season.

In comparison, MK Dons currently have 8 players on loan, but they can only name 5 of them in their squad at any one time. Robinson seems to be trying to keep them all happy by rotating them, and that isn't working at the moment.

For the first time this season, I don't think another loan signing would do us much good. In fact, another loan signing could upset the apple cart.

I would be interested in other opinions regarding our loan signings and whether people would like any further signings to come in.

Personally, I wouldn't bring in another loan unless we pick up a serious injury to a major player. Daniel Johnson for instance has made a big difference, and if he got injured I don't think we have anyone to do the job he does. I think we have suitable replacements for most positions but Johnson would be a big loss to replace.

Agree with all of this.

The CM position is slightly lacking in depth but it would be a bonus if we added anyone. The current squad is capable of finishing 2nd IMO.

Like you say, I'd leave a loan space open right until the end of the window in case a key player is injured.
 
Agree with all of this.

The CM position is slightly lacking in depth but it would be a bonus if we added anyone. The current squad is capable of finishing 2nd IMO.

Like you say, I'd leave a loan space open right until the end of the window in case a key player is injured.

Or if villa Re-call Robinson back again which they can now? HAHA
 
Or if villa Re-call Robinson back again which they can now? HAHA

Good point that Keith. I would be gutted if he was recalled again, and I reckon Robinson would be equally as gutted. I love his attitude & his body language says he loves it here.
 
We currently have 4 players on loan, and I think this is one area that Grayson has got it spot on. Johnstone is an excellent keeper, but the timing of his signing seemed a little strange, but these opportunities don't come along very often. I don't think it did Johnstone/Stuckmann or the team any favours with us still involved in 2 cups. One game Johnstone then the next Stuckers until we went out of both Cup competitions.

Beckford is a decent/good signing IMO. He makes intelligent runs and is a class finisher. He appears to have the right mental attitude for this team.

Robinson comes accross as so dedicated to this club you have to question that he isn't actually a PNE player. He has the best attitude of any loan player we've had in a very long time IMO. He is improving at a rate of knots and I really hope we can make him a permanent signing in the summer. If Villa were to tell him he hadn't got a future with them, I think he would be a shoe in to sign for us.

Gallagher obviously wants to sign permanently for us, but I think we would need to be in the Championship for that to happen. He is a quality player who has worked harder as the season has progressed.

These 4 players have made a difference, and i would love to see them all here next season.

In comparison, MK Dons currently have 8 players on loan, but they can only name 5 of them in their squad at any one time. Robinson seems to be trying to keep them all happy by rotating them, and that isn't working at the moment.

For the first time this season, I don't think another loan signing would do us much good. In fact, another loan signing could upset the apple cart.

I would be interested in other opinions regarding our loan signings and whether people would like any further signings to come in.

Personally, I wouldn't bring in another loan unless we pick up a serious injury to a major player. Daniel Johnson for instance has made a big difference, and if he got injured I don't think we have anyone to do the job he does. I think we have suitable replacements for most positions but Johnson would be a big loss to replace.

Spot on.
Wouldn't bring any other player in now, firstly because we don't need anyone and secondly because we don't want to rock an already steady ship.
We have the quality and depth required to go up, it's just down to Grayson and the boys.
As belated as it may have been, Grayson has discovered the best XI and the winning formula, so it could prove detrimental if he started tinkering with the system now.
 
gallagher will sign whatever division, assuming grayson wants him

agree graysons loans have been excellent in general

johnstone is a class above

He's still a patch on the worlds greatest goalkeeper ever Mr Thorsten Stuckkmann, according to some on here anyway 😉
 
Robinson for me is probably one of the best loan signings we have had, like others have said his attitude is top class.

The re-call is a worry, I hate Tim Sherwood but I find myself hoping they do well so they don't think of bringing Cal back.
 
Robinson for me is probably one of the best loan signings we have had, like others have said his attitude is top class.

The re-call is a worry, I hate Tim Sherwood but I find myself hoping they do well so they don't think of bringing Cal back.

If Aston Villa Recall Robinson it would be a real bummer ! He's obviously enjoying his time here at PNE,playing very well, chipping in with Goals and growing in Confidence game by game. A recall now could hamper his and our Ambitions ! Fuck off Villa 🙂
 
If Aston Villa Recall Robinson it would be a real bummer ! He's obviously enjoying his time here at PNE,playing very well, chipping in with Goals and growing in Confidence game by game. A recall now could hamper his and our Ambitions ! Fuck off Villa 🙂

A recall of Robinson would rob us of a player who provides is with some pace upfront on the left. But with Beckford and Ebanks-Blake in reserve it would not necessarily diminish our goal threat. It would be unfortunate - and I certainly don't want it to happen - but not necessarily disastrous.
 
Any chance we will sign Robinson in the summer?. If so we could sort it out with Villa now and therefor insure we keep him for the rest of the season.
 
Back
Top