Skip to main content

Man Utd Review

Man Utd Review

JB

Joined
Jan 20, 2015
Messages
1,317
My opinion only:

On the whole i think North end can be very proud of their efforts last night, and i feel theres some players who arn't getting the recognition that they deserved, the back 3 were fantastic, hardly put a foot wrong all game! I feel John welsh had a good game and made some important interceptions/tackles that went un noticed and Big Kevin davies was a a right handful and won the majority of headers and tried to link up play very well. Garner worked extremely hard and tried his best to make things happen.

Im afraid Humphrey was awful his effort was there put panicked on the ball, secondly i know hes been our best player of late but i felt gallagher was awful last night, if this was his first appearance in a north end shirt we'd all be slating him this morning, Neil Kilkenny again he worked very hard but panicked on the ball and often just kicked it into touch or to another Utd player!

The First goal im afraid was not offside, i dont like this offside rule nonsense and i dont agree but regardless of weather i agree with it or not, thats the rule and it wasnt offside! the second goal a little push granted but overall that happens in every game so i dont think that warrented a foul in all honesty and the penalty Absolutly not and anybody defending Wayne Rooney on this occasion needs to give their head a wobble!

Just my opinion i know some of you will disgaree but thats how i saw it.[/SIZE]
 
My opinion only:

On the whole i think North end can be very proud of their efforts last night, and i feel theres some players who arn't getting the recognition that they deserved, the back 3 were fantastic, hardly put a foot wrong all game! I feel John welsh had a good game and made some important interceptions/tackles that went un noticed and Big Kevin davies was a a right handful and won the majority of headers and tried to link up play very well. Garner worked extremely hard and tried his best to make things happen.

Im afraid Humphrey was awful his effort was there put panicked on the ball, secondly i know hes been our best player of late but i felt gallagher was awful last night, if this was his first appearance in a north end shirt we'd all be slating him this morning, Neil Kilkenny again he worked very hard but panicked on the ball and often just kicked it into touch or to another Utd player!

The First goal im afraid was not offside, i dont like this offside rule nonsense and i dont agree but regardless of weather i agree with it or not, thats the rule and it wasnt offside! the second goal a little push granted but overall that happens in every game so i dont think that warrented a foul in all honesty and the penalty Absolutly not and anybody defending Wayne Rooney on this occasion needs to give their head a wobble!

Just my opinion i know some of you will disgaree but thats how i saw it.[/SIZE]
Humphrey and Gallagher were excellent last night.
 
Can't really fault anyone but the game passed Kilkenny by a bit, I said before the game that I'd probably play King and give him the sole job of marking Fellaini who bossed it.

I think your way off in slating Gallagher, he was very good in possession but you don't get as many touches as you would like when playing United! My MoM was probably KD though even though he should have seen a 2nd yellow.

Humphrey did well for me.
 
And Kilkenny was ............????

He didn't tackle.
He didn't win a header.
He didn't pass.
He couldn't hold the ball.
He didn't run with the ball.
He didn't do anything meaningful at all.

He was a waste of a shirt last night.

But Larry likes him.
 
My opinion only:

On the whole i think North end can be very proud of their efforts last night, and i feel theres some players who arn't getting the recognition that they deserved, the back 3 were fantastic, hardly put a foot wrong all game! I feel John welsh had a good game and made some important interceptions/tackles that went un noticed and Big Kevin davies was a a right handful and won the majority of headers and tried to link up play very well. Garner worked extremely hard and tried his best to make things happen.

Im afraid Humphrey was awful his effort was there put panicked on the ball, secondly i know hes been our best player of late but i felt gallagher was awful last night, if this was his first appearance in a north end shirt we'd all be slating him this morning, Neil Kilkenny again he worked very hard but panicked on the ball and often just kicked it into touch or to another Utd player!

The First goal im afraid was not offside, i dont like this offside rule nonsense and i dont agree but regardless of weather i agree with it or not, thats the rule and it wasnt offside! the second goal a little push granted but overall that happens in every game so i dont think that warrented a foul in all honesty and the penalty Absolutly not and anybody defending Wayne Rooney on this occasion needs to give their head a wobble!

Just my opinion i know some of you will disgaree but thats how i saw it.[/SIZE]

I disagree with at about half of that.

Gallagher was named North End's man of the match - and quite rightly so.

Humphrey and Kilkenny had nothing to be ashamed of. Both were pretty effective IMO - Of course, no every pass was well placed... but that was the case for a lot of Man United players last night too!

Luis Van Gaal said that they were lucky to be awarded their first goal because Rooney was offside. And I agree with him.
 
I just wish Humphrey had the confidence he did earlier in the season, he has the pace to take the ball past a man but there was a couple of times last night he decided to check back inside when there was space to run in to.

I thought Gally played very well, he seems really up for the cause and wasn't afraid to get stuck in last night.

I have to agree about the offside, its contentious, but I think if that had been ruled out against North End we would have been in uproar. The rule definitely needs clarifying so it is black and white.

Their second goal was a foul, just because it happens all the time doesn't make it fine, much like diving, which of course Rooney did.
 
Humphrey and Gallagher were excellent last night.

Got to disagree on this one.

I don't expect Gally to dominate games against team like United but I thought he looked lightweight and disinterested at times. He need to sit on Blind who controlled the game.

Humphrey had a few good games but dissapeared...
 
Humphrey was coming up against 100 million pounds worth of Left Midfield, a LB who is England standard and one of the fastest in the country if not the continent asking him to take on his man and beating him was out of the question. His only weapon really is his pace and against Di Maria and Shaw he comes up against 2 of the fastest players in the Premier League, he did his defensive duties thats the only thing he could really contribute to the team.
 
Thought Humphrey was poor again last night. He seems to have returned to his dire performances with no end product of last season, after perhaps flattering to deceive a little with what looked to be more promising displays earlier in this campaign.
 
Read Rons post above, sums up Humphrey's contribution perfectly. Personally I would have gone with Wiseman earlier at Humphrey's expense. He was never going to do out-pace Shaw and its harsh to criticise him in that regard. Wiseman wasn't either but offers more with the ball at feet.
 
The teams workrate was top drawer. You can't fault one single player for a lack of it.

Special mentions though for Clarke, Huntington, SKD and John Welsh who for me, was MOM.
 
I think last night United where there for the taking. A decent Championship side would have won that. United were abject. Central defenders of a standard I have never seen before in a top English side, rubbish. I assume Blind was playing so deep to protect them. Valencia great going forward but shocking defensively.
Without Carrick they are clueless and looked at Deepdale they where clueless.
£60mill for Di Maria who sanctions this utter waste of money.
The rest of their squad must be crap if that was the best they could put out and it says a lot for the Prem that United stand 3rd. It made me realise that we are being fed pure fiction in regard to the standard of footie in the Prem.
 
yes but he did do a lot of pointing
He didn't tackle.
He didn't win a header.
He didn't pass.
He couldn't hold the ball.
He didn't run with the ball.
He didn't do anything meaningful at all.

He was a waste of a shirt last night.

But Larry likes him.[/QUOTE]
 
Humphrey has had some good games for us this season & at times has looked a real threat.
He seems like an honest hard working individual & always gives his all where he can.
I think he just lacks natural ability, he has some - but not enough in my opinion.
Humphrey looks like a rabbit in headlights the majority of the time & constantly makes the wrong decision.
I feel harsh saying this as I feel he does put a lot of effort in, but he needs to be dropped IMO...
 
I thought all of the lads put in a good shift against a team in the top 4 of the Premier League. Luck just wasn't with us and if we had won a few more 50-50's in midfield we could have won last night. How I saw things:

Stuckers - Can't blame for any of the goals - 1: Put off by Off-side Rooney 2: Decent save from first shot went straight back to Fellaini 3: Never touched Rooney but ref wasn't in good mood. When we were ahead he did everything right - catching and claiming everything he should have done. Would recall Johnstone at weekend though.

Humphrey - Effort was there, sadly skill and creativity weren't. Was fighting a losing battle against one of the fastest and most expensive left hand sides in the country.
Clarke - Solid and held his own several times against their strikers, remember an excellent header he did to stop it falling to Rooney at the back stick. A player right on top of his game and one of the best CB's in the league.
Huntington - Again solid, but not as impressive or composed as Clarke.
Wright - Not bad considering he had been out for a while and this is one of his first matches back. Put in some good tackles.
Laird - Honestly thought we were going to be singing "Super Scotty Laird" all night after his goal. Was one of the better players in white last night to boot. Very good performance.

Kilkenny - Ran about a lot more than usual as he couldn't play his usual game of (trying to) dictate the play against better opposition. Panicked a lot and just passed the ball into open spaces too often.
Welsh - Better of the midfield partnership. He is one of the most underrated players in our squad. Not the best in terms of attacking quality, but no one can do the job he does as well as him.
Gallagher - Couldn't get involved as much as he normally does. If not for the decent set pieces, I couldn't have told that he was playing.

SKD - Better than I've seen for a while. Won most headers in 1st half. Good management from Grayson to stop him getting sent off in second half - the way Dowd was reffing he could well have got a second yellow last night.
Garner - We've bloody missed him. Was a bugger all night, and put it on a plate for Laird's goal.

Subs:
Robinson - Rusty, only just back fit, and thrown in at the deep end against United, was a poor substitution I thought. Can't judge him from last night's cameo.
Reid - Did nothing to help the team, usually passed it into touch. Disappointing.
Wiseman - Wasn't all too involved.

United were definitely there for the taking last night, just a shame things didn't fall our way on the night. That's the furthest I've seen PNE get in the FA Cup, and we had our insane moment when Laird scored against one of the biggest clubs in the world, so now let's get behind the team and the management for the final few games, and push for automatic promotion. COYW!
 
Generally, I think many are being too harsh on our own players in this thread. The upshot was that in a rather rubbish first half the millionaires did not manage a single goal attempt on (or off?) target and in an 11 v 11 game, all our players can take some credit for that. In a much better second half, 4 goals were scored, 3 of which have generated considerable national debate, but all 3 went in favour of the team who are on first name terms with the ref. Make of that what you will.
 
. Central defenders of a standard I have never seen before in a top English side, rubbish. I assume Blind was playing so deep to protect them. Valencia great going forward but shocking defensively.
Without Carrick they are clueless and looked at Deepdale they where clueless.
£60mill for Di Maria who sanctions this utter waste of money.
The rest of their squad must be crap if that was the best they could put out and it says a lot for the Prem that United stand 3rd. It made me realise that we are being fed pure fiction in regard to the standard of footie in the Prem.

That's why they've got the third best defence in the premier league???
 
We were playing a team 3rd in the Premier League with players who cost over £200 million between them... yet we still get people complaining about certain players.

First of all, nobody had a bad game. Everybody contributed something.

All three United goals were contentious - shows how much of a game we gave them that they had to resort to such tactics. They never got through us and never outclassed us. We are two divisions below, we need to give ourselves more credit.

Player ratings:

Stuckmann - 6.5
Clarke - 8
Huntington - 7
Wright - 8
Humphrey - 7
Kilkenny - 6
Welsh - 7
Gallagher - 8
Laird - 8
Davies - 7.5
Garner - 7.5

Should've brought Robinson on a tad earlier I think.
 
We were playing a team 3rd in the Premier League with players who cost over £200 million between them... yet we still get people complaining about certain players.

First of all, nobody had a bad game. Everybody contributed something.

All three United goals were contentious - shows how much of a game we gave them that they had to resort to such tactics. They never got through us and never outclassed us. We are two divisions below, we need to give ourselves more credit.

Player ratings:

Stuckmann - 6.5
Clarke - 8
Huntington - 7
Wright - 8
Humphrey - 7
Kilkenny - 6
Welsh - 7
Gallagher - 8
Laird - 8
Davies - 7.5
Garner - 7.5

Should've brought Robinson on a tad earlier I think.

What makes you give Humph a better rating than Killa?
 
We'll all have different takes on last night's match. Having watched it live, I watched it again when I got home, and thought we played better on the telly! I thought Stucky was slow off his line when he conceded the penalty, although he'd raced out previously to good effect. It will have been a close call to put Humphrey in before Wiseman at right wing back, but I thought he justified the manager's selection by marking Shaw and breaking forward sporadically well. Clarke and Huntington were immense at the back for us whilst Wright seemed rusty. He got beaten twice in the move for their equalising goal but tried his best. Welsh was a colossus in midfield, a real tiger who won the ball and used it skilfully. I thought Kilkenny concentrated too much on marking Di Maria, to the detriment of his passing game. Garner and Davies were a real handful for the fragile United defence. Kev turned back the years with his flick-on s and cushioned headers. Laird was lively going forward and took his chance well but always looked susceptible to Valencia's pace. Gallagher was given mom by the sponsors but only flitted into the match occasionally and was disappointing. I wasn't that impressed with Man.U as a team or individually. Only Fellaini caused us any problems, mainly by his size and ability to shield the ball. Overall a great team effort and a boost for our promotion push.
 
Back
Top