Skip to main content

Man Utd Review

Man Utd Review

In defence of Humphrey, there aren't many defenders who are quicker than him but have to say Luke Shaw is the fastest I've ever seen. Not easy to do your job against players like him so credit where it's due. At least Shaw didn't cheat!

I think it's wrong to decide who was better than who last night. The lads gave everything for the shirt so cut them some slack please. It was a one off game, it's over and we move on.

Judge our boys against League opposition but not against prem players.
 
I thought all of the lads put in a good shift against a team in the top 4 of the Premier League. Luck just wasn't with us and if we had won a few more 50-50's in midfield we could have won last night. How I saw things:

COYW!

Yes - won't repeat all you wrote but very much as I saw it. Humphrey, as so often, was very good running back towards our goal but almost totally ineffective when trying to go forward. Ebanks-Blake would surely have made more sense as a substitute that Robinson. It was our inability to impose ourselves in central midfield that allowed them to put us under near continuous pressure after they upped their game.
 
All in all they didn't let us down, they did the club proud and so did the fans. In my opinion I though Humphrey worked his socks off and dos what he could against top opposition, I did feel that he seemed to be in awe of going up against such players and could tell when trying to go forward. I'd of given Reid a go from the start. I do like Kilkenny, on his day he is a decent player but again I think tonight showed his short comings when it came to getting stuck in and putting his body on the line. Gallagher as always has that quality and was on a number of occasions complemented by the commentary, at times it seemed like he wasn't fully switched on and would get caught in possession. The back 3 were great, Clarke gave everything for the shirt, just wish we'd stop giving niggly little free kicks in an around the box. KD did his job, Neville even pointed out that falling over and drawing fouls was what he's great at. Lucky to be on the pitch though mind you! Garner was limited but was still able to play some good balls and put himself about, would have been great had he scored. As for Laird, he still could if had a stinker and I wouldn't mind. He gave us something to shout about which I think is what most PNE fans wanted at the end of the day. The initial shot was most likely going wide but he took it on and got the goal so good on him, let's hope it fills him with confidence and gives him a boost the rest of the season. It's a night like last night that can give the players a huge boost, to see the fans getting behind them will have done wonders, if I was a player is be wanting more of that.
 
Personally I can't see any reason at all to criticise any of North End's players last night. The first thing a manager/coach should ask of his players is 100 % effort, and from what I saw, SG got that last night, and one can't ask for more.

Only one word to say about Dowd...........INCOMPETENT. I would have used the word BIASED, but I think incompetent sums him up best as there is absolutely no way he could have seen contact between Stuckmann and Rooney from his position 30 yards or so behind play. Nowadays a referee has to be almost as fit as the players, clearly that is not the case with the rotund Dowd.

SG has a hard task now of lifting our players v Scunthorpe, with a good performance v Man Utd, it would be easy to take this game lightly, and if so, that will be a big mistake. 3 pts v Scunthorpe and we will keep the promotion effort going in the right direction.
 
That's why they've got the third best defence in the premier league???

As I said its a fiction that the Prem is that good. You honestly thought with 4 in defence and Blind protecting them (5) that they looked solid. They have a good record because they pack midfield, even Rooney (a bloody good striker) plays midfield. Big Sam was right they only look dangerous when they revert to bypassing the midfield.
So no that defence is tripe.
 
Was the left sided team mate of Luke Shaw sat in the Sir Tom Finney Stand?

Only asking because he seemed to pass the ball there quite a lot...
 
Back
Top