Skip to main content

Marnick & Reach

Marnick & Reach

norfolk white

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 10, 2004
Messages
16,891
Having again not seen many games this season what are peoples opinions on the chance we have of permanently signing these two in the summer or do you think Sheff Wed will want Marnick and Middlesborough will want Reach back. Would either do you think manage at the moment in the Prem if their clubs are promoted or if Sheff Wed stay down this season do you think they will want Marnick back for next season? Thanks
 
I would suspect our chances of buying Reach depend heavily on whether they win promotion. That said, even if he is made available I fear we will face severe competition from other Championship sides.

On Vermijl, I reckon he will be made available permanently by Wednesday. Their owner has some serious dough and they are likely to spend big again whether they go up this season or not. I just don't see Marnick being in their plans whilst they continually look to strengthen. I suppose arguably the bigger question is will SG want to sign him permanently or look at other options ?
 
This is purely guess work and only my opinion, but if Sheffield Wednesday thought anything of Vermaijl I don't think they would have allowed him out on a full season loan.

If Middlesborough get promoted, I can't see Reach being part of their Premier League plans.

Whether we want to sign them/be able to afford to sign them is another matter.

I think we would sign Reach but not sure about Vermaijl.
 
Vermijl is decent but he's not better than Woods imo.

Personally, I think we should always be looking at players who can upgrade us and even though I like Vermijl, I don't think he would do that.

I think we would get priced out if Adam Reach was made available.
 
Don't think Vermijl is part of Sheff w plans. If SG wants him, I can see him coming back. On Reach, depends if they get promoted. Would love Reach to sign on a permanent, class player.
 
Having again not seen many games this season what are peoples opinions on the chance we have of permanently signing these two in the summer or do you think Sheff Wed will want Marnick and Middlesborough will want Reach back. Would either do you think manage at the moment in the Prem if their clubs are promoted or if Sheff Wed stay down this season do you think they will want Marnick back for next season? Thanks

Marnick hasn't done an awful lot wrong, so absolutely - and at his age, you don't tend to lend players out for the season if you've got a role for them. I would prefer to see him play on the right in our current formation, allowing Woods to play on the left.

Reach is a no brainer if he's available - although I'd rather he wasn't playing wing back (and I suspect he would rather not play there).
 
This is purely guess work and only my opinion, but if Sheffield Wednesday thought anything of Vermaijl I don't think they would have allowed him out on a full season loan.

If Middlesborough get promoted, I can't see Reach being part of their Premier League plans.

Whether we want to sign them/be able to afford to sign them is another matter.

I think we would sign Reach but not sure about Vermaijl.

We wanted to sign Vermijl permanently last Summer. Sheffield Wednesday would only allow a years loan. Suggests they wanted to see how he progresses before deciding whether to sell him or not.
 
What position will Grimshaw be playing. I thought one of the options was right back. If so, would we need Marnick?
 
Don't think either will be here next season.

We have Woods, Grimshaw and Humphrey for the RB/RWB role next season if fit. We all know that Humphrey is liked by Grayson so he'll be staying.

As for Reach, I think he'll leave Boro if they go up or not - but I don't think we'll be able to compete with other clubs in terms of the transfer fee, probably a few million.
 
We have Woods, Grimshaw and Humphrey for the RB/RWB role next season if fit.

Good point, it will be interesting to see if we do let Marnick go back without signing a RB.

As you say, we've got those 3 options next season, plus as Pilchard pointed out the other day, Clive Smith coming through the ranks, who is supposedly highly-rated and has been training with the first team since pre-season. Even Clarke could fill in there if needs be, although he is far, far better in the middle.

The only risk in not bringing one is that Woods is quite injury prone.
 
Good point, it will be interesting to see if we do let Marnick go back without signing a RB.

As you say, we've got those 3 options next season, plus as Pilchard pointed out the other day, Clive Smith coming through the ranks, who is supposedly highly-rated and has been training with the first team since pre-season. Even Clarke could fill in there if needs be, although he is far, far better in the middle.

The only risk in not bringing one is that Woods is quite injury prone.

I agree, we might not sign another RB due to the other players who can play in that position, but is B. Davies enough cover for Cunningham at LB I don't think so , in that case I would like us to sign another CB & a new LB?
 
I agree, we might not sign another RB due to the other players who can play in that position, but is B. Davies enough cover for Cunningham at LB I don't think so , in that case I would like us to sign another CB & a new LB?

I agree on a CH Keith. I wouldn't mind the club looking to sign a left-sided/left footed centre half, that could comfortably play on the left of a back 3 of CHs, and also act as cover at LB. Also, an added bonus if we got Adam Reach permanently is that he can play LWB and could probably cover at LB in an emergency also.
 
Good point, it will be interesting to see if we do let Marnick go back without signing a RB.

As you say, we've got those 3 options next season, plus as Pilchard pointed out the other day, Clive Smith coming through the ranks, who is supposedly highly-rated and has been training with the first team since pre-season. Even Clarke could fill in there if needs be, although he is far, far better in the middle.

The only risk in not bringing one is that Woods is quite injury prone.

Clarke could certainly fill in there - in much the same way as a concrete fencepost i.e. fixed and immobile. A lot will depend on how SG views Humphrey's prospects. We are certainly shorter in resources on the left but Vermilj has made steady progress and is now a reliable member of the squad occasionally capable as last night of a flash of something more.
 
We do also need to remember that we might be having a much bigger & more versatile players on our books next season, due to no Emergency loans available.
 
I agree on a CH Keith. I wouldn't mind the club looking to sign a left-sided/left footed centre half, that could comfortably play on the left of a back 3 of CHs, and also act as cover at LB.

Basically a 2016 version of Ryan Kidd.

Would do for me.
 
I'd keep Vermijl, decent defensively and good offensively. Certainly looks more adept at taking on his man than Humphrey, the goal against Fulham was my vote for goal of the season- completely ruined two very experienced players in the space of a few touches
 
We wanted to sign Vermijl permanently last Summer. Sheffield Wednesday would only allow a years loan. Suggests they wanted to see how he progresses before deciding whether to sell him or not.

I have this thought on Grayson that he really rates Robinson. He knows Villa are coming down and imo Robbo is a decent player, i think Larry knows this therefore he is benching him so that he does not shine this season and Villa take him back or want millions. I feel that SG maybe keeping Robbo under the radar to get him on a perm and cheap, perhaps it's the same with Vermailj. Pure guesswork on my part, could be totally living in cuckoo land lol.
 
I have this thought on Grayson that he really rates Robinson. He knows Villa are coming down and imo Robbo is a decent player, i think Larry knows this therefore he is benching him so that he does not shine this season and Villa take him back or want millions. I feel that SG maybe keeping Robbo under the radar to get him on a perm and cheap, perhaps it's the same with Vermailj. Pure guesswork on my part, could be totally living in cuckoo land lol.

Robinson is out of contract at the end of this season so he'd be able to sign for us without the need of us paying a fee for him, unless it went to tribunal under the Bosman ruling.
 
Back
Top