Skip to main content

Maxwell

Maxwell

It might be useful for posters, particularly oldbutnotdone, to re-read my post which stated 'this year' rather than the period which Maxwell has been picked to play. Either way, I stand by what I say. I think Pickford may have saved one or both of Newcastles goals.

Hope this helps calm the hysteria.
 
Last edited:
It might be useful for posters, particularly oldbutnotdone, to re-read my post which stated 'this year' rather the period which Maxwell has been picked to play. Either way, I stand by what I say. I think Pickford may have saved one or both of Newcastles goals.

Hope this helps calm the hysteria.


oooh no he wouldnt
 
Rudd has never played for us at Championship level and Johnstone was here at this level for less than a month so it's impossible to compare them with Maxwell really.

I'm interested to see what they do when Lindegaard's deal expires. Promote Hudson? Bring in an experienced no.2? Bring in direct competition for Maxwell i.e. someone like Rudd?
 
It might be useful for posters, particularly oldbutnotdone, to re-read my post which stated 'this year' rather than the period which Maxwell has been picked to play. Either way, I stand by what I say. I think Pickford may have saved one or both of Newcastles goals.

Hope this helps calm the hysteria.

Pickford might, but Johnstone and rudd wouldn't, which you implied were better than Maxwell.
 
For me, Maxwell is the most exciting 'keeper we've had in ages. Love watching him play and he's brilliant at what he does.

The lad has balls, and shit-loads of confidence. That will definitely do for me.
 
It might be useful for posters, particularly oldbutnotdone, to re-read my post which stated 'this year' rather than the period which Maxwell has been picked to play. Either way, I stand by what I say. I think Pickford may have saved one or both of Newcastles goals.

Hope this helps calm the hysteria.

Whilst the years have stacked up behind me and my guns might be flagging one thing for certain is ...

You clearly described how maxwell being replaced by a previous loaner would have us in the play offs.
 
Whilst the years have stacked up behind me and my guns might be flagging one thing for certain is ...

You clearly described how maxwell being replaced by a previous loaner would have us in the play offs.

Here's what I said old timer "If any one of those three had been in the sticks this year, I think we'd be in a Play Off spot."
 
Here's what I said old timer "If any one of those three had been in the sticks this year, I think we'd be in a Play Off spot."

Yet Maxwell is better than two of them three so If Maxwell had been in the sticks this year we defiantly would be in a play off spot.
 
Yet Maxwell is better than two of them three so If Maxwell had been in the sticks this year we defiantly would be in a play off spot.

That's a subjective opinion and you may be right.

What I said in my original post can be verified objectively/factually, which is why I quoted it. There's a big difference between disagreeing on a subjective interpretation and getting angry because you've failed to read or understand something properly.
 
He always looks desperate to get involved. He's out like a shot at the first opportunity. He'll probably come unstuck at one point and get caught out but thats OK with me. Would rather he carry on like he is.

I totally agree with this. Sooner or later, Maxi will get caught out and it will cost us a goal, but how many has he prevented by his sweeper role. That is immeasurable and together with the confidence he gives the defenders has probably saved us a few goals already. He allows defenders to defend higher up the pitch, which also allows us to attack more freely than we did last season.
 
I totally agree with this. Sooner or later, Maxi will get caught out and it will cost us a goal, but how many has he prevented by his sweeper role. That is immeasurable and together with the confidence he gives the defenders has probably saved us a few goals already. He allows defenders to defend higher up the pitch, which also allows us to attack more freely than we did last season.

Paramount!! :thumbsup:
 
That's a subjective opinion and you may be right.

What I said in my original post can be verified objectively/factually, which is why I quoted it. There's a big difference between disagreeing on a subjective interpretation and getting angry because you've failed to read or understand something properly.

Who's angry pet? I'm just kindly pointing out what you said - The fact that rudd couldn't get a club in the championship and had to drop a division says it all really.
 
Back
Top