Skip to main content

May?

May?

Totally agree with the above. Service and speed of movement of the ball through the midfield is the issue for me, till the bullets are supplied regularly to the strikers they are going to struggle to score.

Steve Bruce figured it out before Hull played us, isolate garner, close down our midfield and put the ball diagonally over between midfield and our defence to two pacey players in the hole and you can turn our "three tower" defence with a little pace.

Ipswich, Derby, and Bristol City had all worked that one out as well.

For me, one of the three centre backs has got to go back to the bench and with what we have woods and Cunningham left and right of them.

In the middle Kilkenny, nice goal as it was last night gives the ball away to much, John Welsh is having too work too hard to cover this and is picking up yellows for the team.

Stick an experienced head and passer next to Welsh and Johnson a Kevin Nolan type perhaps and it might stabilise the team and tempo a bit.

The current Nick a goal on the counter attack system is not going to be enough, flowing on the ground football, retaining possession of the ball and maintaining pressure on the opponents-appears to the minimum requirement. The sooner that's learnt the better the chance we have of staying up.

I do not want to be going to Scunthorpe and fleetwood again next year !


Great post!
Perfectly sums up how I see it. Unfortunately Kilkenny just doesn't cut it in this league, I don't think he's a bad player, just not the right player we need at this level. Someone like Nolan would be ideal (I'm aware his wages would be out of our budget).
Any lower league suggestions?! Or Prem loan ideas?

I think a CM is more a priority than CB currently, we are getting over run in midfield (as we did a lot in league 1 too).
We will get by with decent CB's - we have 3 steady ones already! It is the 2 in front of them that need to do a better job. Welsh is capable, but needs more help & a better possession player next to him.

I'd like us to go with a back 4, meaning we have a little cover in the CB department if all 3 aren't played. Personally would like to see BW & TC build a defensive pairing. Harsh on Huntington as he has stuck at it & looked solid enough (more so L1 level in my opinion). I think he's a decent back up though.
 
Great post!
Perfectly sums up how I see it. Unfortunately Kilkenny just doesn't cut it in this league, I don't think he's a bad player, just not the right player we need at this level. Someone like Nolan would be ideal (I'm aware his wages would be out of our budget).
Any lower league suggestions?! Or Prem loan ideas?

I think a CM is more a priority than CB currently, we are getting over run in midfield (as we did a lot in league 1 too).
We will get by with decent CB's - we have 3 steady ones already! It is the 2 in front of them that need to do a better job. Welsh is capable, but needs more help & a better possession player next to him.

I'd like us to go with a back 4, meaning we have a little cover in the CB department if all 3 aren't played. Personally would like to see BW & TC build a defensive pairing. Harsh on Huntington as he has stuck at it & looked solid enough (more so L1 level in my opinion). I think he's a decent back up though.

Hourihane from Barnsley would be ideal.
 
great post!
Perfectly sums up how i see it. Unfortunately kilkenny just doesn't cut it in this league, i don't think he's a bad player, just not the right player we need at this level. Someone like nolan would be ideal (i'm aware his wages would be out of our budget).
Any lower league suggestions?! Or prem loan ideas?

I think a cm is more a priority than cb currently, we are getting over run in midfield (as we did a lot in league 1 too).
We will get by with decent cb's - we have 3 steady ones already! It is the 2 in front of them that need to do a better job. Welsh is capable, but needs more help & a better possession player next to him.

I'd like us to go with a back 4, meaning we have a little cover in the cb department if all 3 aren't played. Personally would like to see bw & tc build a defensive pairing. Harsh on huntington as he has stuck at it & looked solid enough (more so l1 level in my opinion). I think he's a decent back up though.
tom clarke isnt good enough i`m afraid...we need a centre half urgently plus grayson to drop his 3 at the back tactic................it isnt going to cut it in this league (well not with huntingdon and clarke as part of it)
 
tom clarke isnt good enough i`m afraid...we need a centre half urgently plus grayson to drop his 3 at the back tactic................it isnt going to cut it in this league (well not with huntingdon and clarke as part of it)

This is where opinions differ.
He doesn't set the world alight, but he is perfectly capable in this league. He's currently been played out of position (and was a lot last season). He's doing Vermijl's job as well as his own. This season and some of last exposes his biggest weakness - pace.

Can you suggest a better CB within our budget? (that's a genuine question by the way)
 
This is where opinions differ.
He doesn't set the world alight, but he is perfectly capable in this league. He's currently been played out of position (and was a lot last season). He's doing Vermijl's job as well as his own. This season and some of last exposes his biggest weakness - pace.

Can you suggest a better CB within our budget? (that's a genuine question by the way)

Clarke will be fine in this league if played in the centre, I agree.
 
But players have been outstanding against us in the past then shite for us. No point reading too much into it. On the whole he's done well for them.

Think we need better than him personally, don't think he has any of the qualities we need in terms of presence, tackling ability and pace.
 
He's playing as a 3rd centre back.

Maybe when we're on the backfoot and defending set pieces but he's been very much a right back in the past two games, as shown by the positions he takes up when we're on the attack and when Pickford plays it short. Derby's first goal, a prime example when he stood off Russell on the half way line. Grayson is asking too much of him as he's not exactly pacey.

Flat back four please.
 
Still very early days but not overly impressed with May at this stage.

As Grayson said though, it will take time for him and Doyle to get used to our system and become accustomed with each other and Garner.
 
Maybe when we're on the backfoot and defending set pieces but he's been very much a right back in the past two games, as shown by the positions he takes up when we're on the attack and when Pickford plays it short. Derby's first goal, a prime example when he stood off Russell on the half way line. Grayson is asking too much of him as he's not exactly pacey.

Flat back four please.

I doubt we'll see the end of 3-5-2 any time soon though. I'd like to see a flat back four as it seemed to work well against Derby, although not so well against the Bristols.

I have a couple of reservations against a flat back four however - do Grayson and Snodin have weeks of work at Springfields to 'perfect' it, and does it match up well against other teams in the Championship?

It's a tricky one. Woods at right back? Wright at left back? Hunts and Clarke as the two centre backs?
 
I doubt we'll see the end of 3-5-2 any time soon though. I'd like to see a flat back four as it seemed to work well against Derby, although not so well against the Bristols.

I have a couple of reservations against a flat back four however - do Grayson and Snodin have weeks of work at Springfields to 'perfect' it, and does it match up well against other teams in the Championship?

It's a tricky one. Woods at right back? Wright at left back? Hunts and Clarke as the two centre backs?

Forgot about Cunningham? Wright at left back would be embarrassing. I'd drop Huntington for now and give Vermijl another chance at right back.
 
Forgot about Cunningham? Wright at left back would be embarrassing. I'd drop Huntington for now and give Vermijl another chance at right back.

No, I thought he looked better going forward as a left sided midfielder than an out and out defender. It's still tricky 🙂!
 
Great post!
Perfectly sums up how I see it. Unfortunately Kilkenny just doesn't cut it in this league, I don't think he's a bad player, just not the right player we need at this level. Someone like Nolan would be ideal (I'm aware his wages would be out of our budget).
Any lower league suggestions?! Or Prem loan ideas?

I think a CM is more a priority than CB currently, we are getting over run in midfield (as we did a lot in league 1 too).
We will get by with decent CB's - we have 3 steady ones already! It is the 2 in front of them that need to do a better job. Welsh is capable, but needs more help & a better possession player next to him.

I'd like us to go with a back 4, meaning we have a little cover in the CB department if all 3 aren't played. Personally would like to see BW & TC build a defensive pairing. Harsh on Huntington as he has stuck at it & looked solid enough (more so L1 level in my opinion). I think he's a decent back up though.

I think someone like Romaine Sawyers fits the bill perfectly. Creates for the strikers, scores goals, box to box, good tackler and a strong lad.

Still only 23 and fits the " trader concept "
 
I think Grayson has enough at his disposal to improve results

If he persists with three at the back we have to get some cover and longer term need at least one centre half better than those we already have.

Pickford Clarke Wright Cunningham Johnson Gallagher and Garner are all starters for me whatever formation we play. From the squad we need to find 4 more.

The other 4 would come from May Doyle Welsh Browne Brownhill Kilkenny Woods Humphrey and Vermijl

Garner will get a rest soon after his fifth booking but for now I would like to see him and May or Doyle up top.

I like the look of May and think he will be fine.
 
I think Grayson has enough at his disposal to improve results

If he persists with three at the back we have to get some cover and longer term need at least one centre half better than those we already have.

Pickford Clarke Wright Cunningham Johnson Gallagher and Garner are all starters for me whatever formation we play. From the squad we need to find 4 more.

The other 4 would come from May Doyle Welsh Browne Brownhill Kilkenny Woods Humphrey and Vermijl

Garner will get a rest soon after his fifth booking but for now I would like to see him and May or Doyle up top.

I like the look of May and think he will be fine.

Good to see a balanced post. The new season has seen the absence or loss of form of 3 of our 4 creative players. Garner and Beckford's goals were key last season and Gallagher's quality in open play and from set pieces has been made more apparent by his absence over the past week.

The positive aspect is that Grayson (and those above him) are not drama queens and won't be panicking. We have a strong core as you say and the strengthening will continue steadily. The art of management and leadership is making the best of what you have whilst trying to strengthen. As we know, strengthening is much easier to demand from a bulletin board than it is to achieve in practice.
 
I'll reserve judgement until I've seen around half a dozen or so games, unlike some of the usual suspects on this thread who appear to have made their minds up.
 
Good to see a balanced post. The new season has seen the absence or loss of form of 3 of our 4 creative players. Garner and Beckford's goals were key last season and Gallagher's quality in open play and from set pieces has been made more apparent by his absence over the past week.

The positive aspect is that Grayson (and those above him) are not drama queens and won't be panicking. We have a strong core as you say and the strengthening will continue steadily. The art of management and leadership is making the best of what you have whilst trying to strengthen. As we know, strengthening is much easier to demand from a bulletin board than it is to achieve in practice.

Excellent post, big +1.
 
Although i appreciate his work ethic, tracking back isn't really a quality im looking for in a striker. We have enough players sitting and taking up defensive positions. We need our strikers playing in the opposition's half. To be fair to the lad he's had hardly any service, if any. Regarding the price tag, he's relatively a cheap purchase. A top end championship player cost 5+ million nowadays.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top