Skip to main content

Midfield

Midfield

Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
17,366
Location
The desert
I am a fan of Welsh and he changed the game against Fleetwood but having been to Rochdale and listened last night we seem to have gone a bit flat.

It was proven last season that a midfield of Kilkenny and Welsh was too static and created little. I am not sure but having scored in every game other than the last two (both started) may suggest Welsh' selection has stifled our attacking intent and there is a big gap between strikers and midfield.

I know it isn't solely this as we have also conceded goals for fun since Wright has been injured and players like Gallagher have again gone missing against the better teams in the league.

They were, on paper, 2 tough away games so onwards and Upwards....
 
I like Welsh and I am still optimistic about the season but other than injuries (Huntington stays in for Wright) I would go back to the team that started the 8 game winning run.
 
I thought Welsh was our only half-decent player at Rochdale.
He got booked just before they scored, and after that he couldn't really put in a decent tackle, like the rest of the midfield.

I'm not sure bringing Welsh back has been very successful - he fixed a problem against Fleetwood, and he's our best option for that sort of work, but I'd rather we started one of the youngsters in his place.
 
I thought Welsh was our only half-decent player at Rochdale.

I thought he looked unfit & way off the pace at Rochdale . I know he did well when he came on for the second half against Fleetwood but he hasn't got the energy or ability to go past opposing players which then opens up our attacking options . I think this is one of the reasons why the goals have dried up and why we don't look as much of a threat anymore !
 
Welsh was the only player attempting to combat the Rochdale midfield waltzing through to our goal.

He wasn't amazing don't get me wrong but it goes to show how shit everyone else was.

I like Alan Browne and i'd happily see him back in the team but I think Kilkenny is more worthy of a dropping than Welsh based on the last three games.. and i'm a big Kilkenny fan.
 
It would be great for Brownhill to pick up the challenge and a add bit of steel to his game. He has the football brain, just needs more strength and confidence. If he's not playing I'd like to see him go on loan for a month to a lower club in our league perhaps.
 
We cannot solve our midfield problems from existing resources. We need at least one experienced new player who can combine assertiveness and application with energy and running. Such a player plus any two out of Browne, Brownhill and Kilkenny might start to give us what we need.
 
Kilkenny....good when he has time on the ball ....little else
Browne...time to develop but very lightweight for a Irish midfielder !!!!
Brownhill...best position behind front player in number 10 role....lightweight and average defensively
Welsh.....has all the attributes except pace and goalscoring !!!!!!!!!!!!!.......League One player
King...you know what you get...commitment, endeavour....his passing is underrated
 
Kilkenny being Grayson's "pet" is lightweight for this division, same goes for Browne, Brownhill, Gallagher, Robinson and Reid leaving us sadly lacking in players who can "bully" the other team close them down and do the "hard yards" leaving Welsh to carry this duty out on his own.

We have some decent footballers who when given time can produce lovely attacking football, we also have some who would rather not get their kit dirty!!!!!

I didn't go last night (for the first time in years couldn't be arsed) so will not pass comment on the game but following it online it seemed to be a struggle, yet again against a decent side Grayson has come up short!!!!!

I don't buy into "look at this fabulous run we have been on" rubbish this as with last season has seen Grayson pick his favourites (at the expense of who can really do a job) and flounder against the top 6-7 teams in this division, do I think we can get auto maybe, top 6 yes however with the sqaud Grayson has been allowed to muster we should win this bloody terrible league.
 
Kilkenny being Grayson's "pet" is lightweight for this division, same goes for Browne, Brownhill, Gallagher, Robinson and Reid leaving us sadly lacking in players who can "bully" the other team close them down and do the "hard yards" leaving Welsh to carry this duty out on his own.

We have some decent footballers who when given time can produce lovely attacking football, we also have some who would rather not get their kit dirty!!!!!

I didn't go last night (for the first time in years couldn't be arsed) so will not pass comment on the game but following it online it seemed to be a struggle, yet again against a decent side Grayson has come up short!!!!!

I don't buy into "look at this fabulous run we have been on" rubbish this as with last season has seen Grayson pick his favourites (at the expense of who can really do a job) and flounder against the top 6-7 teams in this division, do I think we can get auto maybe, top 6 yes however with the sqaud Grayson has been allowed to muster we should win this bloody terrible league.

Agree with every thing you say Graysons & signings tactics this season have been piss poor and have said this since the start of the season. Garner is keeping him in a job.
 
Kilkenny....good when he has time on the ball ....little else
Browne...time to develop but very lightweight for a Irish midfielder !!!!
Brownhill...best position behind front player in number 10 role....lightweight and average defensively
Welsh.....has all the attributes except pace and goalscoring !!!!!!!!!!!!!.......League One player
King...you know what you get...commitment, endeavour....his passing is underrated

Pretty good assesment JR in my opinion,but if correct we then require two quality central midfielders!
 
Kilkenny being Grayson's "pet" is lightweight for this division, same goes for Browne, Brownhill, Gallagher, Robinson and Reid leaving us sadly lacking in players who can "bully" the other team close them down and do the "hard yards" leaving Welsh to carry this duty out on his own.

We have some decent footballers who when given time can produce lovely attacking football, we also have some who would rather not get their kit dirty!!!!!

I didn't go last night (for the first time in years couldn't be arsed) so will not pass comment on the game but following it online it seemed to be a struggle, yet again against a decent side Grayson has come up short!!!!!

I don't buy into "look at this fabulous run we have been on" rubbish this as with last season has seen Grayson pick his favourites (at the expense of who can really do a job) and flounder against the top 6-7 teams in this division, do I think we can get auto maybe, top 6 yes however with the sqaud Grayson has been allowed to muster we should win this bloody terrible league.

Do we have a God given right to win every game now?

Decent footballers who are given time to produce and produce every time like you expect play in the Premier League and the Championship on more money, its the players we can attract unfortunately.
 
Kilkenny being Grayson's "pet" is lightweight for this division, same goes for Browne, Brownhill, Gallagher, Robinson and Reid leaving us sadly lacking in players who can "bully" the other team close them down and do the "hard yards" leaving Welsh to carry this duty out on his own.

We have some decent footballers who when given time can produce lovely attacking football, we also have some who would rather not get their kit dirty!!!!!

I didn't go last night (for the first time in years couldn't be arsed) so will not pass comment on the game but following it online it seemed to be a struggle, yet again against a decent side Grayson has come up short!!!!!

I don't buy into "look at this fabulous run we have been on" rubbish this as with last season has seen Grayson pick his favourites (at the expense of who can really do a job) and flounder against the top 6-7 teams in this division, do I think we can get auto maybe, top 6 yes however with the sqaud Grayson has been allowed to muster we should win this bloody terrible league.

Agree with most of this but you mention 6 players who aren't hard enough yet say Grayson only picks his favourites..... who is he not picking instead of these players....?!? Being Byrom or Keane back or play King?? I am not sure how he can't not pick some of the names you mention.
 
Do we have a God given right to win every game now?

Decent footballers who are given time to produce and produce every time like you expect play in the Premier League and the Championship on more money, its the players we can attract unfortunately.

No, a point away from home will do, shut up shop and hit them on the break with pace, Just like Moyes did 🙂 that's if we have what Grayson said we needed pace🙄
 
Back
Top