The criticism of Pearson doesn't surprise me, unfortunately. We've had this type of thing before. Fans loathe to see their favourites be replaced. Understandable, but it shouldn't affect their judgements on the replacement in question and unfortunately it does every now and then.
Despite proving to be average and quite limited at the level, some supporters don't want to see Welsh replaced, and therefore are very quick to criticise Pearson, who is 11 years younger and evidently much more technically gifted.
One fairly recent example of this was criticism on social media when Hume, a fans favourite, was loaned out to Fleetwood and subsequently released, despite the fact that he was way past his best and we had far superior strikers such as Joe Garner.
Another, very recent example is the signing of Sam Johnstone on loan in January 2015. Folk were very quick to see him as a pointless signing and criticise, because he was replacing a popular figure among the fans in Stuckmann, who was actually nothing special at all. Grayson was proven right in the following months as SJ was excellent for us, and I'm confident SG will be right again by persisting with Pearson because imho he's done quite well thus far and will only get better by playing more games and subsequently further adjusting to Championship football, which he is new to(something people are forgetting).
Welsh and Kilkenny couldn't even make the 18 today. With the prospect of Brownhill signing a new contract, and Grimshaw getting fit, it's becoming obvious that Welsh and Kilkenny will probably be surplus to requirements in the summer. They have been good pros and top servants but they aren't the future.