Skip to main content

More attacking iintent

More attacking iintent

I reckon attack could well be strong point this year. Graysons formula was conservative and got results, albeit a tad boring. Maybe letting loose a bit could be the difference, high risk high reward and all that...

I suspect that if Grayson had still been with us he would have been a bit more adventurous in the coming season - otherwise what would have been the point of signing Harrop and Maguire or slightly earlier Horgan and Barkhuizen. But he has gone and the issue is now just a might-have-been.
 
Agree, wouldn't we all, but a more pertinent question is would you rather win a game 1-0 or lose it 4-3.

And maybe the most pertinent question of all is what is Neil's most effective formula in terms of coaching and game plans.

It would be ludicrous to expect someone who's effective at coaching attacking play and adopting an attacking formula to try to copy someone like Grayson and try to succeed with a very cautious defensive approach.

Let's be brave and take the game to the opposition and see some entertainment and wins in the process.

I think most would agree that our defence needs some strengthening too.
 
And maybe the most pertinent question of all is what is Neil's most effective formula in terms of coaching and game plans.

It would be ludicrous to expect someone who's effective at coaching attacking play and adopting an attacking formula to try to copy someone like Grayson and try to succeed with a very cautious defensive approach.

Let's be brave and take the game to the opposition and see some entertainment and wins in the process.

I think most would agree that our defence needs some strengthening too.

If Neil is going to play a attaching game the likes of Huntington are just not good enough we will need a top class CH organiser & leader to help the other young lads in a possible 2 or 3 at the back & a very good DM to sit just in front.
His defence record at Norwich last season wasn't the best.
 
If Neil is going to play a attaching game the likes of Huntington are just not good enough we will need a top class CH organiser & leader to help the other young lads in a possible 2 or 3 at the back & a very good DM to sit just in front.

We need those two players whatever.
 
Too many people playing Championship Manager. Trust in the manager to know what's needed and to get the best out of the team and produce the attacking winning football most of us want.
 
Agree, wouldn't we all, but a more pertinent question is would you rather win a game 1-0 or lose it 4-3.

Why is that more pertinent? Well maybe it's pertinent if you are always fearing the worst or looking for negatives all the time.

I keep seeing the word 'consistent' being used to describe results under Grayson. Well, yes, two 11th place finishes in the Championship and starting/finishing both seasons exactly the same way (even with an improved squad) is definitely consistent. The way we tailed off towards the end of last season did not reflect well on the manager, even allowing for injuries.

Time for a change and to see if we can push on and improve on those two 11th place finishes.
 
I think this sums Grayson up in his own words.
We are pretty pleased with how things have gone. It would’ve been nice to have won another game but if you don’t win we have to make sure you don’t lose.

“The players knew they were only going to get 45 minutes so whatever position they were going to be it was important they got something out of it.”

He continued: “If you are a full-back do your defensive work but if you can, are a joining in on the attacking front? If you are a wide player do your work up front but make sure you are helping your full-backs and other midfielders as well.

https://www.safc.com/news/team-news/2017/july/livingston/grayson-preview-livingston
 
Or get promoted with a negative goal difference like Huddersfield...
Newcastle top best goal difference Brighton 2nd second best goal difference Huddersfield 6th then promoted via play off think my analysis still stands. I agree not always the case but without checking back through the years I think statistics will prove me right more than wrong. I'm sure if that's not the fact some stato will delight in proving me wrong.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Too many people playing Championship Manager. Trust in the manager to know what's needed and to get the best out of the team and produce the attacking winning football most of us want.

Absolutely. Good post.

How do some people get through their daily lives with such doom-laden attitudes?

Lighten up guys, enjoy the ride - it's supposed to be fun!
 
The style of play should hopefully be more akin to what they did during the Arsenal game, in your face smashmouth with pace up top, that wasn't counter attacking football, that was domination in the first 60 minutes
 
And maybe the most pertinent question of all is what is Neil's most effective formula in terms of coaching and game plans.

It would be ludicrous to expect someone who's effective at coaching attacking play and adopting an attacking formula to try to copy someone like Grayson and try to succeed with a very cautious defensive approach.

Let's be brave and take the game to the opposition and see some entertainment and wins in the process.

I think most would agree that our defence needs some strengthening too.

It's not a matter of whether AN should change his approach. We need to play to our strengths. We already know that we have one of the lower budgets in the league and whilst lack of cash doesn't mean we can't build an attacking team that can win games, everyone needs to understand that by taking this approach we are playing the better teams on their preferred terms.
 
The style of play should hopefully be more akin to what they did during the Arsenal game, in your face smashmouth with pace up top, that wasn't counter attacking football, that was domination in the first 60 minutes

It was football as it should be played, bring it on!
 
It's not a matter of whether AN should change his approach.

You're absolutely correct.

He hasn't been appointed by TH and PR with that expectation has he?

They know what he's all about and won't be expecting him to change his approach but will be hoping that he's able to bring success to the club by his positive attacking formula.

Hopefully he'll get enough financial backing to make the required improvements to the squad too.

All good.
 
It's not a matter of whether AN should change his approach. We need to play to our strengths. We already know that we have one of the lower budgets in the league and whilst lack of cash doesn't mean we can't build an attacking team that can win games, everyone needs to understand that by taking this approach we are playing the better teams on their preferred terms.

Sunderland will have a much bigger budget,also will be considered one of the, as you say, Better teams, they also have Grayson as manager which kind of scuppers your whole theory ! I.M.O.
 
The style of play should hopefully be more akin to what they did during the Arsenal game, in your face smashmouth with pace up top, that wasn't counter attacking football, that was domination in the first 60 minutes

We did dominate yes but I lot of the attacks came from pinching the ball back and then hitting Arsenal with pace, drive and McGeady. Arsenal had nearly 70% of the ball that night.

More of that this season and it will be a good one!
 
I think we all want to see winning football with some style.

What we don't know is if the set of players Neil has inherited were held back by Graysons preferred style or if Grayson was led to adopt it because of limitations of the players themselves. (FWIW I've never felt that thr football under Grayson was anywhere near as dull and defensive as the naysayers like to tell us).

I'm inclined to think that Grayson is/was a very good manager and made the most of what he had available but I could be wrong.

It'll be very interesting to see if Neil can get more out of them. It's not impossible but neither is it as simple as saying "attack more" as some like to think.

Good luck to him, let's wait and see!
 
Every time I read this thread title I do so in the voice of the voiceover guy from the Game show Bullseye. Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiintent.
 
Back
Top