Skip to main content

More attacking iintent

More attacking iintent

Relax folks. Neil did get Norwich promoted to the Premier League (something the dour Grayson has never done) using similar tactics.

I would much rather win a game 4-2 than 1-0. At least next season it sounds like the games will be entertaining and I won't be falling asleep at Deepdale watching a cringeworthy 0-0 winning draw.

That's funny because we only had one 0-0 at home through the whole of last season. In fact we scored more goals than 3 of the play off sides at home.
 
That's funny because we only had one 0-0 at home through the whole of last season. In fact we scored more goals than 3 of the play off sides at home.

Quite - I think SG did start to become more adventurous in the second half of last season and would very likely have been more so this season. The acquisitions of Horgan, Barkhuizen, Harrop and Maguire all indicate as much. The slump at the end of last season was the result on injuries and SG's failure to sign the extra central midfielder it was obvious we needed in January. But it hardly matters now. Instead we have to see what AN will do with the squad he inherited and whether we will make the signings - another central defender and that central midfielder - that we still need.
 
I agree with everyone that says we need another/proper dcm in the mould of Kante. Having two ball winners provides the attackers with more scope to focus on using their pace and creativity.

I am concerned that if we press high, as I would ideally like us to, this will leave the likes of Boyle and Hunts exposed to pace on the counter.

Therefore we arguably need two quick centre halves...

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
 
II am concerned that if we press high, as I would ideally like us to, this will leave the likes of Boyle and Hunts exposed to pace on the counter.

Therefore we arguably need two quick centre halves...

Is Boyle particularly slow? Huntington is not quick but then neither if he were available would Clarke be. But, as you say, if we had a strong enough central midfield then we could stop the central defence being put under pressure in the first place.
 
Great post, I can't wait for the season to get going. Grayson was infuriating at times, yes he did wonders, but playing one up front against some weaker teams was a piss take at times! Neil likes to play attacking football with a 4-4-2 formation, I for one can't wait for the shackles to be lifted and see our talent take the next step.

Dave Seddon just said on his live chat that when speaking to Neil after his press conference, Neil said his preferred formations were 4-2-3-1 and 4-3-3.
 
Dave Seddon just said on his live chat that when speaking to Neil after his press conference, Neil said his preferred formations were 4-2-3-1 and 4-3-3.

I think 4-2-3-1 would suit us. Gallagher has moved further back in the past couple of years and has also seemingly added a bit of bite to his game. I wonder if he could be utilised as a holding midfielder much in the same way Alexander did when he went to Burnley later in his career? Sit him alongside Pearson with Pearson a bit more license to get forward when he can, also means we keep the benefit of his brilliant set piece deliveries on the pitch.

Harrop Johnson and Barkhuizen in front of them with Hugil or Maguire as the main striker.

Our options look brilliant if everyone is fit. We just need to keep hold of everyone and add another good centre half to it and I'm very optimistic.
 
Dave Seddon just said on his live chat that when speaking to Neil after his press conference, Neil said his preferred formations were 4-2-3-1 and 4-3-3.

I hope that is the case because with Hugill upfront the '3' in the first of those is probably ideal for any of Barkhuizen, Harrop, Johnson and Horgan. In the second the middle '3' would suit any of Pearson, Browne, Gallagher, Johnson and maybe Harrop, while again with Hugill at the spearhead the front '3' could also include Barkhuizen, Robinson, May, Horgan, Maguire and if not in midfield Harrop. On the other hand who have we got for the '2' in the first case other than Pearson and Browne - well just possibly Welsh - and whatever we are reliant on Hugill to lead the line unless Maguire can do that.
 
I think 4-2-3-1 would suit us. Gallagher has moved further back in the past couple of years and has also seemingly added a bit of bite to his game. I wonder if he could be utilised as a holding midfielder much in the same way Alexander did when he went to Burnley later in his career?

Maxwell

Woods, Huntington, Boyle/Davies, Cunningham

Pearson, Gallagher

Barkhuizen, Robinson/Maguire, Harrop

Hugill


It looks good but I think a bit more bite in midfield is needed - either Welsh or Browne or a new signing alongside Pearson would be a bit more robust but you never know Gallagher sitting back and pinging defence splitting through balls from deep might work.
 
Quite - I think SG did start to become more adventurous in the second half of last season and would very likely have been more so this season. The acquisitions of Horgan, Barkhuizen, Harrop and Maguire all indicate as much. The slump at the end of last season was the result on injuries and SG's failure to sign the extra central midfielder it was obvious we needed in January. But it hardly matters now. Instead we have to see what AN will do with the squad he inherited and whether we will make the signings - another central defender and that central midfielder - that we still need.

The change of tactics had a lot to do with Thompson's influence IMHO. Also, it's already been mentioned that the club as a whole conducts the signings of players who fit the club's plan/strategy, it's not a case of the manager just saying 'I want to sign xyz'.

I don't agree with the excuses for our poor finish to the season, either. We were only missing Cunningham and Clarke, plus Pearson for a few games. Big players, yes, but we have managed without them before. McGeady (who everyone credited when we won games) was still playing right to the end. Missing players was not, for instance, the reason we dropped 2 points from a winning position at home to Sheff Wed. Or why we played so poorly at home against Barnsley, Rotherham, Wigan, Burton etc. No, our poor finish was, for me, more a reflection of our manager. But I still supported, even if I didn't rate Grayson and didn't like his tactics or style of football.

Anyway, all water under the bridge now and we move onwards and upwards. We have a new manager to support now and I'm sure we all hope he does extremely well.
 
Last edited:
The change of tactics had a lot to do with Thompson's influence IMHO. Also, it's already been mentioned that the club as a whole conducts the signings of players who fit the club's plan/strategy, it's not a case of the manager just saying 'I want to sign xyz'.

Yes - I was told that one previous manager actually complained after his departure that 'his' signings were actually PR's. But I actually think that slightly more collegiate approach is a good thing and while AN will obviously have to have the freedom to make some input on his own account the more that PR can contribute on the signings side and Thommo and Kelly on the playing then the better things will be.
 
The change of tactics had a lot to do with Thompson's influence IMHO. Also, it's already been mentioned that the club as a whole conducts the signings of players who fit the club's plan/strategy, it's not a case of the manager just saying 'I want to sign xyz'.

And that took 18 months?

I'm sure he's a good coach, he seems well liked and popular at the club but let's not tag every good thing with all being down to Thompson as seems to have been done recently. He's also been tagged as being the man to sort out the defence under Neil as though he wasn't here last year when I'm sure many feel we should / could have been better.
 
And that took 18 months?

I'm sure he's a good coach, he seems well liked and popular at the club but let's not tag every good thing with all being down to Thompson as seems to have been done recently. He's also been tagged as being the man to sort out the defence under Neil as though he wasn't here last year when I'm sure many feel we should / could have been better.

Could easily have taken that long with someone who is stubborn 😉
 
Sunderland will have a much bigger budget,also will be considered one of the, as you say, Better teams, they also have Grayson as manager which kind of scuppers your whole theory ! I.M.O.

That's why IMO the appointment of SG is a poor decision. If you have one of the stronger squad in the league you want to go out and take the game to your opponents, we were in a similar situation in League 1 (i.e. we had one of the stronger squads in the league with SG in charge). How many games did we draw games that most on this message board thought we could and should have won with a more positive approach. Another good example is David Moyes who could have been considered to have had a safety first approach. His tactics were relatively successful with us and with Everton when he first took over, as they were considered one of the weaker teams in the league. However, as they improved and built a stronger squad with aspirations of breaking into the top 6, the tactic of seeing games out became more of a liability, with plenty of Everton fans not happy with the points thrown away from winning positions due to the cautious approach. The limitation of his safety first approach became even more stark when he was appointed Man Utd manager.

So no I don't think it scuppers my theory, yes we need to have cutting edge going forward, but if we try to take the game to the better teams in the league with one of the 'weaker squads' it's likely that we will lose more often than we'll win.
 
Last edited:
I think we all want to see winning football with some style.

What we don't know is if the set of players Neil has inherited were held back by Graysons preferred style or if Grayson was led to adopt it because of limitations of the players themselves. (FWIW I've never felt that thr football under Grayson was anywhere near as dull and defensive as the naysayers like to tell us).

I'm inclined to think that Grayson is/was a very good manager and made the most of what he had available but I could be wrong.

It'll be very interesting to see if Neil can get more out of them. It's not impossible but neither is it as simple as saying "attack more" as some like to think.

Good luck to him, let's wait and see!

I have to say I agree with just about all of that. I always thought that Grayson used what was available in a way which utilised their abilities. This was borne out when Barki and McGeady came into the equation and we started to play in a more attacking way.

I think we will see what his (SG) preferred style of football is when Sunderland play us both home and away. I say this because with the money available to him at Sunderland, he should be able to recruit players of the calibre he really wants, therefore able to play his preferred style.
 
Back
Top