Skip to main content

Mousinho

Mousinho

Westley very nearly destroyed our club.

He is despised by players, managers, clubs and fans alike across the English game.

I used to cringe every time he opened his mouth, he brought shame and embarrassment on our club.

He has lost us 2000 of our attendance. He nearly killed my love for the club.

Thank the lord we have a proper, respected and well liked manager who unlike like Westley can actually get a team to win football matches.

As for comparing him to Craig Brown, absolute nonsense. Craig Brown whilst not really a success at PNE, signed some outstanding players and is one of the nicest blokes in football. Maybe too nice for his own good.

Why are we even having this debate? Westley needs to be consigned to history and back our current manager who in 12 months has made us promotion challengers.

BIG +1

Are people really giving him credit for letting players contracts expire? Or signing 3-6 good players out of 36?

People praise Westley then slag off Brown or Ferguson because Westley cut the wage bill? Westley had to cut a wage bill which was about £5m, when Ferguson took over our wage bill was around £12m. That's when the real cost cutting took place and when the real high earning players left - SSL, Lonergan, Carter, Chaplow, Nicholls, Jones, Brown etc. Westley cut it by about £2m the Brown and Ferguson cut it by about £7m.

Really the credit for the vast reduction in wages has to go to the board as it's been in action for 5 years or so.

Westley can only be judged on what his remit was. Which was to rebuild a squad and get us promoted. So in reality he was a failure in every aspect of his job. Praising him for a strategy that was in action years before he signed is farcical. I struggle to think of anyone (football manager or not) who could have made as big a fuck up as he did.
 
BIG +1

Are people really giving him credit for letting players contracts expire? Or signing 3-6 good players out of 36?

People praise Westley then slag off Brown or Ferguson because Westley cut the wage bill? Westley had to cut a wage bill which was about £5m, when Ferguson took over our wage bill was around £12m. That's when the real cost cutting took place and when the real high earning players left - SSL, Lonergan, Carter, Chaplow, Nicholls, Jones, Brown etc. Westley cut it by about £2m the Brown and Ferguson cut it by about £7m.

Really the credit for the vast reduction in wages has to go to the board as it's been in action for 5 years or so.

Westley can only be judged on what his remit was. Which was to rebuild a squad and get us promoted. So in reality he was a failure in every aspect of his job. Praising him for a strategy that was in action years before he signed is farcical. I struggle to think of anyone (football manager or not) who could have made as big a fuck up as he did.

SG had to do less and worry about finances less following GW than he would of had to do following PB though....

The majority of our squad in 3rd position is from GW signings and he was in a better position to sign key players than if inheriting PB's squad.....
 
SG had to do less and worry about finances less following GW than he would of had to do following PB though.....
Do less? He had to be a football manager, a tactician, a man manager. All things money can't buy. All things GW lacked in spades. We had won just once in 14 games when Westley got the boot. The club was in disarray. Morale at an all time low. I'm not sure why you want to give credit to GW for anything. Anybody... a body of water could of done what he acheived. A guy training kids on moor park could of pissed off all the inherited squad and brought in some old pals who would otherwise be playing lower league footy. He wasted chunks of cash bringing in the likes of robertson, cummins etc. And then got Hemmings to pay off a load of other players he couldn't / wouldn't work with. And we haven't even started on the brand of football he offered up or the piss weak excuses he gave every single week. Winning draws? Aaron Brown up front? Anthony Elding? I firmly believe Grayson could of inherited any squad in league one and acheive things with them. Thats why his three promotions from this league with three different clubs matter. And why Westley's conference medals add up to jack shit. Stop defending the guy. He was a walking disaster who scammed his way into a top league one job, and talked horseshit throughout his time here.
 
BIG +1

Are people really giving him credit for letting players contracts expire? Or signing 3-6 good players out of 36?

People praise Westley then slag off Brown or Ferguson because Westley cut the wage bill? Westley had to cut a wage bill which was about £5m, when Ferguson took over our wage bill was around £12m. That's when the real cost cutting took place and when the real high earning players left - SSL, Lonergan, Carter, Chaplow, Nicholls, Jones, Brown etc. Westley cut it by about £2m the Brown and Ferguson cut it by about £7m.

Really the credit for the vast reduction in wages has to go to the board as it's been in action for 5 years or so.

Westley can only be judged on what his remit was. Which was to rebuild a squad and get us promoted. So in reality he was a failure in every aspect of his job. Praising him for a strategy that was in action years before he signed is farcical. I struggle to think of anyone (football manager or not) who could have made as big a fuck up as he did.

Amen sir. Beautifully put.
 
If the board deserves credit for bringing the wage budget down from £12 million then surely it deserves blame for letting it get up that high in the first place?
 
Do less? He had to be a football manager, a tactician, a man manager. All things money can't buy. All things GW lacked in spades. We had won just once in 14 games when Westley got the boot. The club was in disarray. Morale at an all time low. I'm not sure why you want to give credit to GW for anything. Anybody... a body of water could of done what he acheived. A guy training kids on moor park could of pissed off all the inherited squad and brought in some old pals who would otherwise be playing lower league footy. He wasted chunks of cash bringing in the likes of robertson, cummins etc. And then got Hemmings to pay off a load of other players he couldn't / wouldn't work with. And we haven't even started on the brand of football he offered up or the piss weak excuses he gave every single week. Winning draws? Aaron Brown up front? Anthony Elding? I firmly believe Grayson could of inherited any squad in league one and acheive things with them. Thats why his three promotions from this league with three different clubs matter. And why Westley's conference medals add up to jack shit. Stop defending the guy. He was a walking disaster who scammed his way into a top league one job, and talked horseshit throughout his time here.

Westley was a cock and did talk shit I completely agree. SG has done all the things managers are suppose to do but he inherited a half decent squad and a club whose finances were in order. He would have taken much longer to build, required more players and had less of a budget to play with if came in after Brown....

Coming in to the likes of Rudd, Keane, Laird, Buchanan, Huntington, King, Holmes, Byrom, Welsh, Beavon and Garner and even the Robertsons, Monakanas, Wroes and Mousinhios will probably do well at other L1 clubs.

The fans this season has aimed most of their abuse at Davies and Humphreys. Garner is our leading scorer, Welsh our captain and the signings of King and Keane were very good and will be key players this season.

I wanted Westley out of the club, he was embarrassing he was tactically inept and he bought some real shit in the club. I even attended a meeting to rid the club of him however the club was financially and squad wise was in a better situation when he left than when he arrived.

SG has all those players I mentioned to work with along with the support of the owner (as the finances are in better order) than if he had come in after Brown and inherited Turner, McClean, Gray, Carlisle, Morgan, Alexander, Nicholson, Ashbee, Mayor, Procter, Mellor, Parry and Coutts.


Westley is a grade A tosser and I am so glad the club is rid of him. Yes someone else may have done the same job but he came in and did it and left the club in a better situation that where he found it.

SG inherited a good squad; ready made core throughout the team, captains, leading scorers and by actually being able to manage, motivate and now us being able to afford better players we will hopefully go up and the last few years will be a distant memory
 
Westley was a cock and did talk shit I completely agree. SG has done all the things managers are suppose to do but he inherited a half decent squad and a club whose finances were in order. He would have taken much longer to build, required more players and had less of a budget to play with if came in after Brown....

Coming in to the likes of Rudd, Keane, Laird, Buchanan, Huntington, King, Holmes, Byrom, Welsh, Beavon and Garner and even the Robertsons, Monakanas, Wroes and Mousinhios will probably do well at other L1 clubs.

The fans this season has aimed most of their abuse at Davies and Humphreys. Garner is our leading scorer, Welsh our captain and the signings of King and Keane were very good and will be key players this season.

I wanted Westley out of the club, he was embarrassing he was tactically inept and he bought some real shit in the club. I even attended a meeting to rid the club of him however the club was financially and squad wise was in a better situation when he left than when he arrived.

SG has all those players I mentioned to work with along with the support of the owner (as the finances are in better order) than if he had come in after Brown and inherited Turner, McClean, Gray, Carlisle, Morgan, Alexander, Nicholson, Ashbee, Mayor, Procter, Mellor, Parry and Coutts.


Westley is a grade A tosser and I am so glad the club is rid of him. Yes someone else may have done the same job but he came in and did it and left the club in a better situation that where he found it.

SG inherited a good squad; ready made core throughout the team, captains, leading scorers and by actually being able to manage, motivate and now us being able to afford better players we will hopefully go up and the last few years will be a distant memory

People say the squad was much stronger than Brown's but I wouldn't say there was a massive improvement. If we add Graysons signings to Westley's signings in Tuesday's starting 11. Would it be stronger/weaker than if we add Graysons signings to some of Brown's squad?

Take Tuesday's starting line up for example. Would a team of:

Rudd
Laird
Wright
King
Clarke
Humphrey
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Garner
Davies

Be stronger or weaker than:

Stuckman
Gray
Wright
Clarke
Parry
Humphrey
Coutts
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Hume/Mellor
Davies

I'd say there wouldn't be much in it but in terms of quality Brown's squad wins.
 
If the board deserves credit for bringing the wage budget down from £12 million then surely it deserves blame for letting it get up that high in the first place?

Yep. Kind of like taking a dump on the floor then cleaning it up. You get credit for cleaning it up but the mess you caused probably overshadows it.
 
People say the squad was much stronger than Brown's but I wouldn't say there was a massive improvement. If we add Graysons signings to Westley's signings in Tuesday's starting 11. Would it be stronger/weaker than if we add Graysons signings to some of Brown's squad?

Take Tuesday's starting line up for example. Would a team of:

Rudd
Laird
Wright
King
Clarke
Humphrey
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Garner
Davies

Be stronger or weaker than:

Stuckman
Gray
Wright
Clarke
Parry
Humphrey
Coutts
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Hume/Mellor
Davies

I'd say there wouldn't be much in it but in terms of quality Brown's squad wins.

I'd disagree completely in terms of those teams.

Laird better than Parry
Humphrey better than Gray
Coutts better than Welsh (he'd of gone whoever came in)
Garner better than Hume and Mellor

And then I guess the bench would be much stronger and I guess we could have bought Ashbee on when Garner got sent off not Keane.

The fact we got the wage bill down so much meant we could now afford Gallagher, Kilkenny, Clarke, Davies, Humphrey etc
 
the club was financially and squad wise was in a better situation when he left than when he arrived.
Anthony Elding, Luke Foster, Aaron Brown, Chris Robertson, John Mousinho, Graham Cummins, Chris Beardsley, Shane Cansdell-Sheriff, Chris Holroyd, Jamie McAllistair, David Amoo, Nicky Hunt, Lee Trundle, Andrew Procter... how many players did Westley sign who were garbage? How many of them would grayson touch with a bargepole?

We were in a decent financial position in this league when GW arrived as Westley was given carte-blanche to build a team from scratch. A luxury few managers ever get. We could offer the likes of Welsh, Buchanen, Wroe, Laird etc better wages than their current clubs could stump up. Thats why they signed in the first place. In league one we have muscle compared to most.

Yes our wage bill was too high and had to be trimmed. But any manager could of gone about releasing players (Parry etc), paying others off (Morgan etc), selling for peanuts (Coutts) or loaning them out to promotion rivals (Hume). It wasn't hard to do. Likewise sending a bunch of players to an east lancs gym for pre-season wasn't difficult - it was just a sign of a man possessed. A man quite clear that he was more important than the team itself. Those medals y'see told him so.

Of out current first team squad I'd argue Clarke (a Grayson signing) and Bailey Wright (a player westley wanted gone remember!) have been the pick of our defence this season. In midfield Gallagher seems a class above Westley's typical die hard warriors. Up front Davies has lead the line with help from Garner (who seemed utter shite under GW) and Hume (who Westley said we couldnt afford). Beavon the 300k Westley marquee signing is the one who has looked under par this season.

More important than signings or squad depth is what a manager can do with a set of players. Grayson has acheived his success without having a scatter gun approach to transfers nor falling out with players wholesale (Monakana aside) nor using any old excuse he could scratch from his arse to explain defeats.
 
Anthony Elding, Luke Foster, Aaron Brown, Chris Robertson, John Mousinho, Graham Cummins, Chris Beardsley, Shane Cansdell-Sheriff, Chris Holroyd, Jamie McAllistair, David Amoo, Nicky Hunt, Lee Trundle, Andrew Procter... how many players did Westley sign who were garbage? How many of them would grayson touch with a bargepole?

We were in a decent financial position in this league when GW arrived as Westley was given carte-blanche to build a team from scratch. A luxury few managers ever get. We could offer the likes of Welsh, Buchanen, Wroe, Laird etc better wages than their current clubs could stump up. Thats why they signed in the first place. In league one we have muscle compared to most.

Yes our wage bill was too high and had to be trimmed. But any manager could of gone about releasing players (Parry etc), paying others off (Morgan etc), selling for peanuts (Coutts) or loaning them out to promotion rivals (Hume). It wasn't hard to do. Likewise sending a bunch of players to an east lancs gym for pre-season wasn't difficult - it was just a sign of a man possessed. A man quite clear that he was more important than the team itself. Those medals y'see told him so.

Of out current first team squad I'd argue Clarke (a Grayson signing) and Bailey Wright (a player westley wanted gone remember!) have been the pick of our defence this season. In midfield Gallagher seems a class above Westley's typical die hard warriors. Up front Davies has lead the line with help from Garner (who seemed utter shite under GW) and Hume (who Westley said we couldnt afford). Beavon the 300k Westley marquee signing is the one who has looked under par this season.

More important than signings or squad depth is what a manager can do with a set of players. Grayson has acheived his success without having a scatter gun approach to transfers nor falling out with players wholesale (Monakana aside) nor using any old excuse he could scratch from his arse to explain defeats.

Totally agree he signed alot of shit on small contracts or on shitty loans. Most I am glad to see the back of. I'm not talking how he went about it I am merely stating SG has had it easier after Westley than he would of had after Brown. If he had come in after Brown I don't think he would have been able to turn it around so quickly. SG doesn't have to touch them the majority you mention played a few games between them. Yes we had to watch those few games unfortunately.

So Westley had it easy because we offered more wages than Tranmere, Stevenage etc and a luxury many managers don't get........?????? but SG has bought in international players, kept Hume, ex England internationals and championship players in. Others managers have spent far money on crap. At least Westley got crap for free......

Well how many managers wanted that job and wanted that on their CV knowing it was playing with fire and doing it so soon could result in poor performances and struggling in the league. Not many. Do you think SG would have come in with that remit? Would he fuck...!!

Fickle of the highest order. He didn't actually sell Wright though did he and played him. Garner was also shit under SG until about 2 months ago. Gallagher would seem a class above we pay a very small percentage of his wage.

I'm not comparing the 2 managers and I wouldn't. One is a clueless sad pathetic individual with little management skills and inept in PR and management and the other is on course to steer his 4th team out of L1. However my point stands. I believe that albeit for 1 horrible year under GW we have been able to move in to a promotion chasing team much quicker under SG than if he had inherited PB's squad
 
I'd disagree completely in terms of those teams.

Laird better than Parry
Humphrey better than Gray
Coutts better than Welsh (he'd of gone whoever came in)
Garner better than Hume and Mellor

And then I guess the bench would be much stronger and I guess we could have bought Ashbee on when Garner got sent off not Keane.

The fact we got the wage bill down so much meant we could now afford Gallagher, Kilkenny, Clarke, Davies, Humphrey etc

The reason we can afford Gallagher, Kilkenny, Clarke, Davies, Humphrey etc is because Grayson cleared out all Westley's shite. Soon he'll have had as big a clear out as Westley. He's just done it professionally and over a more reasonable period of time.

As for the teams:

On current form I'd have Garner over Hume/Mellor. But had you asked me any time other than in the last month I'd have had Hume or Mellor. He was awful before then.

I'd have Coutts over any of our midfield.

Laird over Parry. Not a world of difference but I'd have Laird too. But remember Parry was a strong contender for player of the year when he left. Westley even offered him a contract.

Can't compare Gray and Humphrey. He's a Grayson signing. In the starting 11's it would be a toss up between him and King. Don't really rate either but I'd stick with King.

All I was trying to say is was there a massive improvement in the squad Westley left in comparison to the one Brown left? Either way he would have inherited about 3-6 good players and the rest would have been average/dross.
 
Last edited:
At least Westley got crap for free......
If you think the likes of Robertson, Cummins and Procter were 'free' you are as mad as GW. They cost money. Probably over 200k for those three alone. Plus agent fees etc.

If Grayson had of come in after Brown we could be back in the championship already. He could of got rid of the dross, kept the nuggets and brought in his own quality signings. You believe what you want. But saying Westley did a great job reshaping this squad is fucking bullshit.
 
The reason we can afford Gallagher, Kilkenny, Clarke, Davies, Humphrey etc is because Grayson cleared out all Westley's shite. Soon he'll have had as big a clear out as Westley. He's just done it professionally and over a more reasonable period of time.

As for the teams:

On current form I'd have Garner over Hume/Mellor. But had you asked me any time other than in the last month I'd have had Hume or Mellor. He was awful before then.

I'd have Coutts over any of our midfield.

Laird over Parry. Not a world of difference but I'd have Laird too. But remember Parry was a strong contender for player of the year when he left. Westley even offered him a contract.

Can't compare Gray and Humphrey. He's a Grayson signing. In the starting 11's it would be a toss up between him and King. Don't really rate either but I'd stick with King.

All I was trying to say is was there a massive improvement in the squad Westley left in comparison to the one Brown left? Either way he would have inherited about 3-6 good players and the rest would have been average/dross.

11 good squad players I've mentioned who have or will make an impact this season. Hume can't get in ahead of Garner and Coutts would have wanted to go whoever came in so can't really blame GW on that one
 
If you think the likes of Robertson, Cummins and Procter were 'free' you are as mad as GW. They cost money. Probably over 200k for those three alone. Plus agent fees etc.

If Grayson had of come in after Brown we could be back in the championship already. He could of got rid of the dross, kept the nuggets and brought in his own quality signings. You believe what you want. But saying Westley did a great job reshaping this squad is fucking bullshit.

Yes we paid transfer fees for a few players I understand that but peanuts in comparison to money we spent on dross in the past.

Bollocks. If SG had inherited PB's squad it would have taken much longer than what it has taken him at GW.

Which nuggets of Browns squad? Coutts? Would have gone regardless of manager as was a Championship player and Mellor? retired.....!!

So which nuggets then? Ashbee, Carlisle, Alexander or Nicholson or one of the kids? Could have one of those that play for Stanley, Fleetwood or Bury as opposed to:

Rudd
Keane
King
Huntington
Laird
Buchanan
Welsh
Holmes
Byrom
Beavon
Garner

All have or will play some important part to this season.
 
11 good squad players I've mentioned who have or will make an impact this season. Hume can't get in ahead of Garner and Coutts would have wanted to go whoever came in so can't really blame GW on that one

Who says Coutts would have gone regardless? If Grayson had managed him I reckon he'd have stayed.

As for your supposed "good" 11 players:

Rudd - good signing. But only out of desperation because he fell out with both his goalies
Keane - average
King - average
Huntington - average
Laird - good signing
Buchanan - good signing
Welsh - good signing
Holmes - average
Byrom - absolutely gash! You should be ashamed putting him as a "good" signing
Beavon - average
Garner - good signing but only since Westley left.

I make that 5 good signings. Of those 5 I think only 2-3 would cut it in the championship, which was where we were meant to be aiming. So if I was being generous 1 in 7 of Westley's signings were good signings. Which is abysmal.
 
SG had to do less and worry about finances less following GW than he would of had to do following PB though....

The majority of our squad in 3rd position is from GW signings and he was in a better position to sign key players than if inheriting PB's squad.....

You dont half read some shit in here, GW was just the puppet with Ridsdale pulling his strings re getting players out of the club, Westley couldn't manage anyone with talent and ability as these types of players would just laugh at the fucker and his inability to manage them (Richard Wright fucked off after ONE training session with this clown).

Our squad is bound to have Westley signings still present as the cunt signed so many players, common sense and the law of averages would tell you this.

Laird despite his defensive misgivings, Buchanan, Welsh, King and Keane have done a decent job, Beavon has been a complete and utter failure as our "stellar" signing, Holmes spends too much time on his arse and only since SG teamed Garner up with Davies he (Garner) has he now started to show some form, the rest are average at best and fuckin rubbish at worst. I would say that so far this season Wright, Davies and Clarke have been our three best players none of whom were signed by Westley.

Kilkenney, Gallagher, Clarke, Wright and Davies would probably be the first 5 names on the team sheet, with Humphrey getting most games, and given that Rudd was brought here then presuaded to come back by SG this only leaves space for 4 Westley signings in the team, and I would start Hayhurst before Holmes these days too.

6 out of nearly two and a half dozen Westley signings are good enough to be in our matchday squad, so if you think for one minute that Westleys signings are the reason for our 3rd place you are deluded.
 
Who says Coutts would have gone regardless? If Grayson had managed him I reckon he'd have stayed.

As for your supposed "good" 11 players:

Rudd - good signing. But only out of desperation because he fell out with both his goalies
Keane - average
King - average
Huntington - average
Laird - good signing
Buchanan - good signing
Welsh - good signing
Holmes - average
Byrom - absolutely gash! You should be ashamed putting him as a "good" signing
Beavon - average
Garner - good signing but only since Westley left.

I make that 5 good signings. Of those 5 I think only 2-3 would cut it in the championship, which was where we were meant to be aiming. So if I was being generous 1 in 7 of Westley's signings were good signings. Which is abysmal.

I said players who have or will have an impact on this season. I didn't mention next season.
 
You dont half read some shit in here, GW was just the puppet with Ridsdale pulling his strings re getting players out of the club, Westley couldn't manage anyone with talent and ability as these types of players would just laugh at the fucker and his inability to manage them (Richard Wright fucked off after ONE training session with this clown).

Our squad is bound to have Westley signings still present as the cunt signed so many players, common sense and the law of averages would tell you this.

Laird despite his defensive misgivings, Buchanan, Welsh, King and Keane have done a decent job, Beavon has been a complete and utter failure as our "stellar" signing, Holmes spends too much time on his arse and only since SG teamed Garner up with Davies he (Garner) has he now started to show some form, the rest are average at best and fuckin rubbish at worst. I would say that so far this season Wright, Davies and Clarke have been our three best players none of whom were signed by Westley.

Kilkenney, Gallagher, Clarke, Wright and Davies would probably be the first 5 names on the team sheet, with Humphrey getting most games, and given that Rudd was brought here then presuaded to come back by SG this only leaves space for 4 Westley signings in the team, and I would start Hayhurst before Holmes these days too.

6 out of nearly two and a half dozen Westley signings are good enough to be in our matchday squad, so if you think for one minute that Westleys signings are the reason for our 3rd place you are deluded.

Westleys signings along with Graysons signings are yes. The difference being we can now add a good manager to work with them.

In my eyes our starting XI and subs would be:

Rudd
Humphrey
Clarke
King
Wright
Laird
Welsh
Kilkenny
Gallagher
Davies
Garner


Stuckmann
Huntington
Buchanan
Hayhurst
Keane
Beavon
Hume


This team will push for the top 2.

Starting XI contains 5 GW signings and the squad overall has 9.

It isn't about Westley being good at all. He was a tosser but we are in a stronger position SG inheriting GW's squad if say he had inherited PB's as I doubt any other than Coutts would be in there along with Wright, Hayhurst and Hume.

I am glad we have seen the back of several of the recent managers
 
Back
Top