Skip to main content

Mr Grayson take note

Mr Grayson take note

Joe is either 1 or 2 bookings away from a 2 match ban for picking up 10 yellow cards & I wonder on how many of those bookings were for genuine fouls that Joe has made.
 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/26411295

Not because I want to see Joe Garner in trouble but I think it's counter productive, for every dive you take there's a genuine foul not given or a booking. The worse the reputation the less you get. Time to stamp down on this before it costs us in the long run & besides it's cheating and I just don't like it.

Garner already seems to have a bad reputation with opposition fans - Walsall boo'd him when he was substituted, which you might expect given he'd got one of their players sent off, but the message about him is getting around. It's unpleasant and is something I could see a a manager like Westley instructing players to do - it gives teams a bad name. It is not something that is suitable for doing whilst wearing the colours of the famous Preston North End.
 
He got booked for the keeper barging him out of the way.. seems Legit.... Kilkenny needs to stop being so soft... one of the walsall players flicked a hand out to say 'what for' caught kilkenny on the forhead and he went down like he had been shot.
 
Jesus Wept, some folk can't but help find reason to slag our own players off.

Take away Joe Garner's goals and we would be mid-table.

Yes he puts himself about and maybe sometimes he does go down a bit easily. However don't they all? I don't like cheating and would love to see it taken out of the game but to pick on Joe for this is pathetic.

"He got their lad sent off"!

No he didn't, he got fouled, he went down, the referee sent him off. He was hardly rolling around and from what I could see the Walsall players had an issue with the referee (who was poor) and not with Joey.

Garner's last two bookings where farcical.

Against Rotherham he was clean through, momentum sent him flying, he punched the ground and didn't even appeal for a penalty, it was clear he was frustrated he didn't make more of the chance.

On Saturday, their goalkeeper deliberately barged into him a couple of times. The referee booked Garner which anyone can see was a joke.

So lay off him and support the highest goalscorer we have had for bloody years.
 
Joe is either 1 or 2 bookings away from a 2 match ban for picking up 10 yellow cards & I wonder on how many of those bookings were for genuine fouls that Joe has made.

It's two away from another ban. I think he's getting a reputation for himself which contributed to at least the booking last Tuesday - totally unwarranted IMO but maybe his own fault?
 
Jesus Wept, some folk can't but help find reason to slag our own players off.

Take away Joe Garner's goals and we would be mid-table.

Yes he puts himself about and maybe sometimes he does go down a bit easily. However don't they all? I don't like cheating and would love to see it taken out of the game but to pick on Joe for this is pathetic.

"He got their lad sent off"!

No he didn't, he got fouled, he went down, the referee sent him off. He was hardly rolling around and from what I could see the Walsall players had an issue with the referee (who was poor) and not with Joey.

Garner's last two bookings where farcical.

Against Rotherham he was clean through, momentum sent him flying, he punched the ground and didn't even appeal for a penalty, it was clear he was frustrated he didn't make more of the chance.

On Saturday, their goalkeeper deliberately barged into him a couple of times. The referee booked Garner which anyone can see was a joke.

So lay off him and support the highest goalscorer we have had for bloody years.

If you're referring to my comments JK, I wasn't intimating that he'd got one of their players sent off through acting, I was merely pointing out that they boo'd him off, which you might expect any team's supporters to do in that situation. But seeing as he'd been correctly sent off, then they had no reason to boo him. I'm just saying that he is garnering a reputation. Garnering? Get it? 😉

I disagree about the booking of Garner. From where I was sat he seemed to be deliberately obstructing the keeper. And if he wasn't, then why was he booked? Reputation?

Yes he is our highest scorer for a long time which is great and one of the reasons we are up there. On Saturday his ability to win the ball in the air, for one thing, was amazing. That doesn't mean he is immune from criticism and it would be a shame if we didn't get the best from him due to some questionable behaviour. All players need to work on weaknesses so they get better and his, in my view, is that he spends too much time on the ground. 🙂
 
Garner has been great for us this season but you can't defend some of his diving without being completely biased.

I've never seen a PNE player go down as easy as he does before.
 
Jesus Wept, some folk can't but help find reason to slag our own players off.

Take away Joe Garner's goals and we would be mid-table.

Yes he puts himself about and maybe sometimes he does go down a bit easily. However don't they all? I don't like cheating and would love to see it taken out of the game but to pick on Joe for this is pathetic.

"He got their lad sent off"!

No he didn't, he got fouled, he went down, the referee sent him off. He was hardly rolling around and from what I could see the Walsall players had an issue with the referee (who was poor) and not with Joey.

Garner's last two bookings where farcical.

Against Rotherham he was clean through, momentum sent him flying, he punched the ground and didn't even appeal for a penalty, it was clear he was frustrated he didn't make more of the chance.

On Saturday, their goalkeeper deliberately barged into him a couple of times. The referee booked Garner which anyone can see was a joke.

So lay off him and support the highest goalscorer we have had for bloody years.

I think you're missing the point and ironically the bit in bold is why Grayson (or Joe) needs to get a grip - I don't think that other players would have got the bookings - I want Garner on the pitch doing what he does best & allowing him to continue down this path isn't going to serve his or the club's best interest.
 
Jesus Wept, some folk can't but help find reason to slag our own players off.

Take away Joe Garner's goals and we would be mid-table.

Yes he puts himself about and maybe sometimes he does go down a bit easily. However don't they all? I don't like cheating and would love to see it taken out of the game but to pick on Joe for this is pathetic.

"He got their lad sent off"!

No he didn't, he got fouled, he went down, the referee sent him off. He was hardly rolling around and from what I could see the Walsall players had an issue with the referee (who was poor) and not with Joey.

Garner's last two bookings where farcical.

Against Rotherham he was clean through, momentum sent him flying, he punched the ground and didn't even appeal for a penalty, it was clear he was frustrated he didn't make more of the chance.

On Saturday, their goalkeeper deliberately barged into him a couple of times. The referee booked Garner which anyone can see was a joke.

So lay off him and support the highest goalscorer we have had for bloody years.

I wasn't having a dig a Joe, just pointing out that he's either 1 or 2 yellow cards away from a 2 game ban.
 
Agree with the OP totally. Im totally exasperated with the amount of diving that Garner does. The frustrating thing, is hes proving he doesnt need to do that at all, hes turning into a damned good player for us.
 
A combative fiery player like Garner is always going to get bookings but agree that diving doesn't help. That said, he went from the Brentford to Orient games (11 in all) without picking up a single one so obviously isn't the antichrist.
 
Agree with the OP totally. Im totally exasperated with the amount of diving that Garner does. The frustrating thing, is hes proving he doesnt need to do that at all, hes turning into a damned good player for us.

I agree about Garner. It is embarrassing and I think Pulis' approach is refreshing. Because of Garner's diving he gets booked for diving and doesn't get genuine fouls and penalties awarded when he is genuinely fouled because the referees don't trust him.
 
A combative fiery player like Garner is always going to get bookings but agree that diving doesn't help. That said, he went from the Brentford to Orient games (11 in all) without picking up a single one so obviously isn't the antichrist.

Exatcly!

So far today I have see folk criticise Rudd and now Garner, I find it a bit strange.
 
Jesus Wept, some folk can't but help find reason to slag our own players off.

Take away Joe Garner's goals and we would be mid-table.

Yes he puts himself about and maybe sometimes he does go down a bit easily. However don't they all? I don't like cheating and would love to see it taken out of the game but to pick on Joe for this is pathetic.

"He got their lad sent off"!

No he didn't, he got fouled, he went down, the referee sent him off. He was hardly rolling around and from what I could see the Walsall players had an issue with the referee (who was poor) and not with Joey.

Garner's last two bookings where farcical.

Against Rotherham he was clean through, momentum sent him flying, he punched the ground and didn't even appeal for a penalty, it was clear he was frustrated he didn't make more of the chance.

On Saturday, their goalkeeper deliberately barged into him a couple of times. The referee booked Garner which anyone can see was a joke.

So lay off him and support the highest goalscorer we have had for bloody years.

Totally agree. Garners goals have won us points this season and if his style of play gets us the results needed then long may it continue. All players these days go down easily under a challenge and Garner is no different. Why ask him to change what works for him and PNE, it doesn't make sense. He is skillfull enough to win free kicks in dangerous positions and at times when time is needed to be used up. I say he is a clever footballer who runs himself into the ground, without him and his contribution we wouldn't be where we presently are.
 
Have to agree he is becoming an embarrassment. some of his diving is laughable.

However the word is going out as he is starting to not get free kicks when they are because refs are unsure if its a dive.

Fair play to Tony Pullis on his stance. Its time the FA made a stance on this blatant cheating and if Joe Garner ends up having the book thrown at him for Cheating then so be it.
 
He has been great for us this season, but his diving has been spoken about on here on several occasions.

We'd be complaining incessantly if we were conceding penalties due to this sort of behaviour.

He does it that often that it's only a matter of time before it costs us in some shape or form - a 2nd yellow resulting in him being sent off or a definite penalty which is denied due to his reputation.
 
His diving is embarrassing, he needs to cut it out. I don't see why he does it; it seldom works and he'd be better if he just stayed on his feet. I don't like the way he is representing our club at the moment. It's doubly disappointing when you consider the fact that he was a pall bearer at Sir Tom's funeral. I guess those words from Jimmy Armfield about how diving wasn't part of Tommy's game washed right over Joey.

I don't get people defending him by saying he's scoring a lot; he's scoring a lot in spite of his diving, not because of it.
 
I agree about Garner. It is embarrassing and I think Pulis' approach is refreshing. Because of Garner's diving he gets booked for diving and doesn't get genuine fouls and penalties awarded when he is genuinely fouled because the referees don't trust him.

Garner's done really well or us recently with all his goals and some excellent play as well.

And he'd be an even better player if he could curb the diving/cheating aspect of his game and concentrate on using his football talents.

I think the behaviour also rubs off on our other players in that referees do not trust them either, even though none of our other players dive/cheat as Garner does, and they too often therefore fail to award us genuine free kicks.

Sort yourself out Joe. You're far too good a player to have to resort to diving. And the refs have got the measure of it now so aren't going to be easily fooled.
 
Back
Top