Skip to main content

need for speed?

need for speed?

I think Hugill might end up in front of Garner in the pecking order next season.

I think he already is, it's clear that Garner is not good enough for this division. 6 goals in 40 odd games is dire. In fact Garner currently scores one goal every seven games in this division. I reckon Hugill would have scored double that if he had played as many minutes!
 
I think he already is, it's clear that Garner is not good enough for this division. 6 goals in 40 odd games is dire. In fact Garner currently scores one goal every seven games in this division. I reckon Hugill would have scored double that if he had played as many minutes!

Garner has been a one man battering ran this season, played up front on his own in a team that for half of the season wasn't creating a lot and was low on confidence.

With better service and someone else to occupy Championship quality defenders lets see what Garner can do.
 
I've got a feeling that we may not see Joey here next season, with Sheffield United being his ultimate destination. This will push Hugill up the pecking order & we will need a new striker. Bradshaw anybody? I actually feel we have enough pace throughout the squad & expect our attacking play to be a bit more refined next season
 
I think he already is, it's clear that Garner is not good enough for this division. 6 goals in 40 odd games is dire. In fact Garner currently scores one goal every seven games in this division. I reckon Hugill would have scored double that if he had played as many minutes!
I am not writing Garner off at all, I hope he proves me wrong next season. If Thompson works with Hugill to improve the weaknesses in his game and Hugill gets a decent run in pre season I have an inkling he could prove a few folk wrong next season.
 
We want to start next season with Beckford, Garner, Hugill and one other - whether permanent or loan is another matter. Keeping Garner is not a matter of sentiment - I have no doubts that if played with a partner he will score goals in this division.
 
Last edited:
We want to start next season with Beckford, Garner, Hugill and one other - whether permanent or loan is another matter. Keeping Garner is not a matter of sentiment - I have no doubts that if played with a partner he will score goals in this division.

Watching Garner in the warm up, he's usually the poorest of our strikers when it comes to converting goal scoring opportunities. While the warm up doesn't really mean much, the same is reflected when he gets chances in actual games. I think you're right in that as part of a front two there are more chances, but he hasn't been taking enough of them, and that isn't acceptable. He needs to be less wasteful or he'll lose his starting place.
 
Chris Humphrey



Watching the last season review DVD I was struck by just how many of our goals came from Humphrey. I think this might be a little unfair.

According to the pne website Reach has only assisted one more goal than Humphrey this season. Bearing in mind some would throw all sorts of money at reach let's have a think about his season.

4goals 3assists in 36 games (Humphrey 10). He does get the ball out on his own a lot and has often found himself with a lot of grass to run into but his end product is often terrible. Bearing down on goal on Saturday just the keeper to beat he passed the ball behind Beckford. He had numerous other crosses that did not lead to a chance.

I suspect the tactics and system help him find room to run with the ball, which is always exciting but it has more to do with Gallaghers passing and him making himself available.

He is undoubtably a talented player but I think Humphrey should not be written off so easily.

I wouldn't want either of them tbh.
 
Garner has been a one man battering ran this season, played up front on his own in a team that for half of the season wasn't creating a lot and was low on confidence.

With better service and someone else to occupy Championship quality defenders lets see what Garner can do.

Is of course the right answer.
 
Garner has been a one man battering ran this season, played up front on his own in a team that for half of the season wasn't creating a lot and was low on confidence.

With better service and someone else to occupy Championship quality defenders lets see what Garner can do.

I'm a Garner fan but he has certainly missed some sitters this season, there was even one on Saturday in the first half which if it was Hugill some would want him driven out of town!! He's also been trying shots from stupid distances, probably over eager to bag.

Maybe a goal early in the season would have made him kick on and getting his first in late November won't have helped, but 3 goals in 4 games end of Nov / early December then to go 11 without one was disappointing.
 
I'm a Garner fan but he has certainly missed some sitters this season, there was even one on Saturday in the first half which if it was Hugill some would want him driven out of town!! He's also been trying shots from stupid distances, probably over eager to bag.

Maybe a goal early in the season would have made him kick on and getting his first in late November won't have helped, but 3 goals in 4 games end of Nov / early December then to go 11 without one was disappointing.

If memory serves me right richard cresswell had a full season only scoring 1 goal and fans asked the same question do we keep him or sell him, we kept him and the following season he scored over 25 goals! So i say keep joey and look to next season and how he gets on.
 
If memory serves me right richard cresswell had a full season only scoring 1 goal and fans asked the same question do we keep him or sell him, we kept him and the following season he scored over 25 goals! So i say keep joey and look to next season and how he gets on.

This is of course correct. Well Cresswell got 2. But he'd got 16 the season before and 12 the season before that, Garner has never really done it at this level with his best chance of having a good 'un coming this season - based on the run he had with us the previous 2 seasons and that he wasn't a new transfer here.

Oh and the season Cresswell got 2 he was really playing a supporting role to Fuller and Healy who both got 15+.
 
Modern game has become more and more dependent on pace. As we stand I see us as a well organised, resilient side with a good team spirit and work ethic. Add some quality and pace in the final third and we might have a chance.
 
I know Tugg, I think we both need to go and see a professional, something isn't quite right.

Yes a loan could be productive if he's not going to be given more game time. Although if Garner is the only alternative to partner Beckford next season (whilst May is still out injured), then I think Hugill should be getting a chance ahead of Garner because he deserves it.

We're agreeing with each other too much these days Ron. 😀

Christ sakes, get a room you two.🙂
 
Back
Top