Skip to main content

Negativity....

Negativity....

Sorry, I missed a few managers off my list didn't I..?! So in the interest of balance...

Gary Peters had no managerial experience

David Moyes had no managerial experience

Billy Davies had 18 months previous managerial experience until he was sacked

John Dreyer once managed Maidenhead Utd for a year

So CV's are pointless?

Why not pluck Tony Ellis then as he might be good?

And people call for Risdales head when it is purely a lottery
 
So CV's are pointless?

Why not pluck Tony Ellis then as he might be good?

And people call for Risdales head when it is purely a lottery

Tony Ellis isn't currently our caretaker boss. Tony Ellis doesn't know the current squad, what has gone on at the heart of the club in the last 13 months and doesn't have a good idea of what makes this squad tick. Tony Ellis didn't play a good chunk of his career at top flight, unfashionable clubs, playing as the captain and on pitch leader of these clubs.
Can you understand one iota the value in keeping Dreyer on til the end of the season? Do you see any sense in it and seeing what he can do with the team / squad, be it good, indifferent or shite?

Do you get it that getting Leeds up, after 2 seasons in the top 6 of this division, and Huddersfield up, after 2 and a half seasons of the same, both clubs being used to winning more than they lose on his takeoveer, is different to our current (skint) plight?

Graysons massive plus is the promotion he achieved at the tin pot, crook-run poor excuse for a club up the road. That is extremely impressive - he was younger and hungry then, with a lot less cash in the bank. I hope he is still as hungry, and can turn us round, on a shoestring - I will back him 100 percent if he gets it, same as I would any manager.
 
Tony Ellis isn't currently our caretaker boss. Tony Ellis doesn't know the current squad, what has gone on at the heart of the club in the last 13 months and doesn't have a good idea of what makes this squad tick. Tony Ellis didn't play a good chunk of his career at top flight, unfashionable clubs, playing as the captain and on pitch leader of these clubs.
Can you understand one iota the value in keeping Dreyer on til the end of the season? Do you see any sense in it and seeing what he can do with the team / squad, be it good, indifferent or shite?

Do you get it that getting Leeds up, after 2 seasons in the top 6 of this division, and Huddersfield up, after 2 and a half seasons of the same, both clubs being used to winning more than they lose on his takeoveer, is different to our current (skint) plight?

Graysons massive plus is the promotion he achieved at the tin pot, crook-run poor excuse for a club up the road. That is extremely impressive - he was younger and hungry then, with a lot less cash in the bank. I hope he is still as hungry, and can turn us round, on a shoestring - I will back him 100 percent if he gets it, same as I would any manager.

You are a joke. Moyes is the worse ever XI to play for Celtic and is one of the best managers
 
That's swung it for me then pal - have a happy half term, don't leave the literacy homework til Sunday now!!

We beat MK Dons last season between managers and also very Colchester 7-0 a couple I seasons ago. Saturday for me would of been the same outcome if Andy Fensome had been given the reigns
 
Because someone played at the top level does not make them a good manager and vice versa. A pedigree of taking 3 teams up in the league we are in makes for a decent appointment

3 promotions? Well that guarantees it then doesn't it! Darren Fergusson had only won consecutive promotions, as had Graham Westley. Phil Brown only had one as manager and one as an assistant so no wonder they all failed miserably if you need 3 promotions on your CV...

Makes you wonder how any of them got a job in the first place!
 
3 promotions? Well that guarantees it then doesn't it! Darren Fergusson had only won consecutive promotions, as had Graham Westley. Phil Brown only had one as manager and one as an assistant so no wonder they all failed miserably if you need 3 promotions on your CV...

Makes you wonder how any of them got a job in the first place!

No nothing guarantees it but its far more of reason to give a guy the job than giving it a guy who managed a team for two days. All those managers you mention did it at one club, Grayson did it at 3 seperate clubs
 
Didn't realise Grayson had a 50% win record out of 169 games at Leeds, that is good going.

I'm happy with him personally, i've said in another thread that my Huddersfield supporting mate has good things to say about him and he is pretty realistic and level headed when it comes to footy and his team so I'll take his opinion over the Lasher's.
 
Didn't realise Grayson had a 50% win record out of 169 games at Leeds, that is good going.

I'm happy with him personally, i've said in another thread that my Huddersfield supporting mate has good things to say about him and he is pretty realistic and level headed when it comes to footy and his team so I'll take his opinion over the Lasher's.

After all the hype surrounding Tangerine Brown and his half time antics, son of Fergie and Westley I'd look forward to a manager who comes with a good cv and won't create a media circus
 
Agree, lots of people calling Grayson boring yet they're are the same posters who criticised Westley for bringing unwanted attention to the club every week with his bullshit.

As delighted as I was when he left we could do with another Irvine, someone who does his job quietly and focuses his attention on the coaching side of things.

Every appointment is gamble but I think Grayson is a good bet.
 
I don't think its negativity so much as deep concern.

We've had our fingers burnt more times than we deserve over the past few years with a series of shocking appointments with only Irvine's being vaguely successful.

Personally, I rate the job Grayson did at Blackpool very very highly as anyone who can get that shower of shite promoted must have a decent idea what they're doing. But I think he made a meal of it at Leeds where he had massive resources for a League 1 club and at Huddersfield he was in the rare situation of inheriting a club and team that was decidedly NOT a basket case.

But, as I've said elsewhere, I don't see a realistic better candidate. I'd love Coyle but its never going to happen. Dreyer is not a credible candidate (yet, maybe he would be given time) and Ainsworth is unproven.

At this stage, the priority needs to be a relatively safe capable pair of hands. Like or not (I don't particularly but that's life) Grayson is the standout realistic candidate at the moment.
 
I don't think its negativity so much as deep concern.

We've had our fingers burnt more times than we deserve over the past few years with a series of shocking appointments with only Irvine's being vaguely successful.

Personally, I rate the job Grayson did at Blackpool very very highly as anyone who can get that shower of shite promoted must have a decent idea what they're doing. But I think he made a meal of it at Leeds where he had massive resources for a League 1 club and at Huddersfield he was in the rare situation of inheriting a club and team that was decidedly NOT a basket case.

But, as I've said elsewhere, I don't see a realistic better candidate. I'd love Coyle but its never going to happen. Dreyer is not a credible candidate (yet, maybe he would be given time) and Ainsworth is unproven.

At this stage, the priority needs to be a relatively safe capable pair of hands. Like or not (I don't particularly but that's life) Grayson is the standout realistic candidate at the moment.

It is negativity finding more reasons now to hire a guy and make excuses for why he succeeded at 3 separate clubs.....
 
I don't really get what you're saying.

Just my objective appraisal of the quality of job he did at each. Call it what you like.

I hope he can give us what he gave the lashers.
 
Back
Top