Skip to main content

new defender

new defender

Always seems a bit agent instigated when the article links the player to 3 or 4 clubs at once in a "chase" for his signature etc etc etc.
 
Always seems a bit agent instigated when the article links the player to 3 or 4 clubs at once in a "chase" for his signature etc etc etc.
Especially when the player is dispassionately described as "in outstanding form... the powerful centre-back... a colossus... impressive displays..."
 
Stick to statistics because since you branched out you have just talked complete horse shit.

Smalling is a good centre back

"branched out"?

I agree with you, Smalling is a good centre back............at non-league level.

Unfortunately, England don't have what I would describe as a good INTERNATIONAL centre back.

I don't rate Smalling, Cahill or Stones..............and trust me, against top strikers, they will be found out, in fact they already have been.

Smalling relies on bear hugs too much, Cahill often doesn't appear to be in control of his legs, and Stones takes far too many chances with 'clever' short passes when he should just get rid.

They might get away with the above versus the likes of Lithuania, but not when it comes to the big boys, like Iceland for example 😛.
 
That is where Chris Smalling belongs..........non-league. (seriously).

Whether Chris Smalling is an international centre back is open to debate, but if you think Smalling is a non league standard player, it proves once and for all how very little you know about football.
 
Chris Smalling was one of the few players to actually improve and play consistently under Van Gaal in the games I saw.

Don't know how he's doing under Mourinho, few better options for the England team at the moment but this is probably the worst defence we've had in my lifetime.
 
Stick to statistics because since you branched out you have just talked complete horse shit.

Smalling is a good centre back

I agree with this. Smalling is that Shit, that he plays week in week out for Utd, did under Fergie, Moyes, Van Gaal and now Morihno. Hodgson and now Southgate also pick him but he's still shit. 🙄🙄
 
Smalling is a decent Prem defender but if United want to win titles again they need much better than him, and so do England.

Michael Keane made a good England debut the other night so Smalling's England place will be under pressure soon.
 
If Smalling is a non league defender then wtf is Paul Huntington!? You know absolutely nothing about football.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
"branched out"?

I agree with you, Smalling is a good centre back............at non-league level.

Unfortunately, England don't have what I would describe as a good INTERNATIONAL centre back.

I don't rate Smalling, Cahill or Stones..............and trust me, against top strikers, they will be found out, in fact they already have been.

Smalling relies on bear hugs too much, Cahill often doesn't appear to be in control of his legs, and Stones takes far too many chances with 'clever' short passes when he should just get rid.

They might get away with the above versus the likes of Lithuania, but not when it comes to the big boys, like Iceland for example 😛.

So it's either international centre half or non league....

Yes your stats at least had some kind of sense rather than this bullshit you post...

Is Smalling an International centre half.... yes.... Is Smalling a world class centre half.... no
 
Smalling is a decent Prem defender but if United want to win titles again they need much better than him, and so do England.

Michael Keane made a good England debut the other night so Smalling's England place will be under pressure soon.

They played a shit German side to be fair......and still got beat.
 
They played a shit German side to be fair......and still got beat.

England currently have an above average side that if left alone, will mature into a top side. Players like Ali, Kane, Sterling are the future and when given a chance may star at international level.

The main issue with England (and arguably why it pains most non-english people to watch a game on tv) is the portrayal of these 'superstars' by the media. The media believe and portray that England should be competing with Europe's best when in actual fact, they haven't been really that close in years. It took less than 1 minute into the game for the ITV commentator to make reference to 1966 the other night. Whilst no doubt winning the world cup is some achievement, it has been the only achievement in the past 50 years yet come every tournament, England are tipped to do well mainly by their own media.

An example of players that the media have bigged up and ruined careers: Townsend, Oxlaide-Chamberlain, Walcott, Rodwell, Sinclair to name but a few. A decent spell with their club side and the hopes of the nation are put on their shoulders. The team fails and with it that players confidence shot.

FWIW, I think Smalling and Jones are 2 of the weakest centre halves to represent both Utd let alone England in recent years.
 
England currently have an above average side that if left alone, will mature into a top side. Players like Ali, Kane, Sterling are the future and when given a chance may star at international level.

The main issue with England (and arguably why it pains most non-english people to watch a game on tv) is the portrayal of these 'superstars' by the media. The media believe and portray that England should be competing with Europe's best when in actual fact, they haven't been really that close in years. It took less than 1 minute into the game for the ITV commentator to make reference to 1966 the other night. Whilst no doubt winning the world cup is some achievement, it has been the only achievement in the past 50 years yet come every tournament, England are tipped to do well mainly by their own media.

An example of players that the media have bigged up and ruined careers: Townsend, Oxlaide-Chamberlain, Walcott, Rodwell, Sinclair to name but a few. A decent spell with their club side and the hopes of the nation are put on their shoulders. The team fails and with it that players confidence shot.

FWIW, I think Smalling and Jones are 2 of the weakest centre halves to represent both Utd let alone England in recent years.

I agree, I didn't think Smalling had a particularly bad game to be fair, but him and Jones are nowhere near some of the defenders Utd and England have had like you say. Liked Keane getting a place and definitely proved eh can cut it I think.
 
England currently have an above average side that if left alone, will mature into a top side. Players like Ali, Kane, Sterling are the future and when given a chance may star at international level.

The main issue with England (and arguably why it pains most non-english people to watch a game on tv) is the portrayal of these 'superstars' by the media. The media believe and portray that England should be competing with Europe's best when in actual fact, they haven't been really that close in years. It took less than 1 minute into the game for the ITV commentator to make reference to 1966 the other night. Whilst no doubt winning the world cup is some achievement, it has been the only achievement in the past 50 years yet come every tournament, England are tipped to do well mainly by their own media.

An example of players that the media have bigged up and ruined careers: Townsend, Oxlaide-Chamberlain, Walcott, Rodwell, Sinclair to name but a few. A decent spell with their club side and the hopes of the nation are put on their shoulders. The team fails and with it that players confidence shot.

FWIW, I think Smalling and Jones are 2 of the weakest centre halves to represent both Utd let alone England in recent years.

Yep good post. Hoddle said the other night the team should play relaxed like they do in friendly games when it comes to big tournaments and possibly the reason they dont is because as you say, the media hype which gives the nation an expectation when in reality, we are an average team. But again as you say, we have potential to become better.
 
Back
Top