Nicky Wroe
Another poor performance from him on Monday, but this time Mousinho wasn't playing so he can't take the blame.
So if anyone can offer an explanation/reason then that would be greatly appreciated.
Cheers.
He was trying to emulate Carrick!
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 1,825
Seems to be playing a deeper role than under Westley, which gives him less opportunity to get forward and in and around the box like earlier in the season when he was scoring goals and creating chances. How many times are we getting the ball wide to Hayhust or Holmes and there's only 1 player in the middle to aim for?? Wroe's form has tailed off recently though and even in the home games, we don't seem to be able to get him on the ball as much.
When he does receive the ball though, I think we're too static and predictable, the movement isn't quite there and players aren't making the runs - nobody wants to pull up and spend the summer in the treatment room rather than the beach. The tempo in our play isn't quite there and the attacking players are looking poor as a result. The sooner we get the season over the better, when we have something to play for I think the urgency and the desire will soon come back, or at least I hope it will...
When he does receive the ball though, I think we're too static and predictable, the movement isn't quite there and players aren't making the runs - nobody wants to pull up and spend the summer in the treatment room rather than the beach. The tempo in our play isn't quite there and the attacking players are looking poor as a result. The sooner we get the season over the better, when we have something to play for I think the urgency and the desire will soon come back, or at least I hope it will...
i also think there is no more to wroe's game than a few forward runs and passes. When did you last see him commit to a tackle? put a foot in or really press an opposition player? I actually think he never has at all and doesnt have a lot to his game. We cannot in league 1 carry a player like him and we have done. We did the same last season with Alexander when he played in midfield because he couldnt get up and down the pitch but at least being 40 was his reason. Wroe doesnt have one.
Disagree if you want but whether its keane or welsh, they do all the hard work for him and in league one its just not possible to have to a midfielder just capable of playing pretty passes or the odd run forward.
Disagree if you want but whether its keane or welsh, they do all the hard work for him and in league one its just not possible to have to a midfielder just capable of playing pretty passes or the odd run forward.
Last edited:
H
Henry2705
I'll probably get slammed for saying this but I think the lad is a very average footballer at this level. He's 27 and has never commanded a regular first-team place for any club at this level (I may be mistaken though). In some cases, you can put it down to a lack of opportunity or simple bad luck but I don't think that applies to Wroe. I'd be very surprised if he ever helped a team get promoted out of this league but stranger things have happened. He may just be having a poor run after a fine start but I tend to believe that he excelled himself beyond his normal powers earlier in the season before reverting to type.
don't think he's so bad personally, not the best but not the worst. Might be going through a difficult period but to me he doesn't hide, which is always the sign of a player who has 'something'.
Hopefully he will come good again because he has had some games where he has been influential (IMO)
Hopefully he will come good again because he has had some games where he has been influential (IMO)
- Joined
- May 28, 2011
- Messages
- 144
I'll probably get slammed for saying this but I think the lad is a very average footballer at this level. He's 27 and has never commanded a regular first-team place for any club at this level (I may be mistaken though). In some cases, you can put it down to a lack of opportunity or simple bad luck but I don't think that applies to Wroe. I'd be very surprised if he ever helped a team get promoted out of this league but stranger things have happened. He may just be having a poor run after a fine start but I tend to believe that he excelled himself beyond his normal powers earlier in the season before reverting to type.
But then why was he playing so well at the beginning of the season? I'd do agree he has been poor recently but he obviously has some talent in there somewhere, its up to the coaching staff to get it out of him
H
Henry2705
But then why was he playing so well at the beginning of the season? I'd do agree he has been poor recently but he obviously has some talent in there somewhere, its up to the coaching staff to get it out of him
I think it was merely a side effect of the whole team appearing to get their act together; when the team started to nosedive, so did Wroe. That may sound obvious but look at John Welsh. We've played poorly since late Nov/early Dec but he's been very good throughout.
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 28, 2011
- Messages
- 144
I think it was merely a side effect of the whole team appearing to get their act together; when the team started to nosedive, so did Wroe. That may sound obvious but look at John Welsh. We've played poorly since late Nov/early Dec but he's been very good throughout.
But welsh is an easy player to love gets stuck in etc, unless your barca all players aren't like that. I think we should wait till next season when were hopefully creating chances again and see how he does......
Nicky's best when he's supporting the front men. I think his strengths are his shooting and running off the ball. When he plays further back[ it must be tactical], he hits long passes and doesn't run with the ball. He isn't a dynamic tackler like Keane and Welsh but is still someone who offers a different threat in midfield. He seems to have a good first half and then peters out as though he hasn't great stamina. Still a club asset and could do a job for us.
i also think there is no more to wroe's game than a few forward runs and passes. When did you last see him commit to a tackle? put a foot in or really press an opposition player? I actually think he never has at all and doesnt have a lot to his game. We cannot in league 1 carry a player like him and we have done. We did the same last season with Alexander when he played in midfield because he couldnt get up and down the pitch but at least being 40 was his reason. Wroe doesnt have one.
Disagree if you want but whether its keane or welsh, they do all the hard work for him and in league one its just not possible to have to a midfielder just capable of playing pretty passes or the odd run forward.
9 goals doesnt exactly say he is being carried?
Another poor performance from him on Monday, but this time Mousinho wasn't playing so he can't take the blame.
So if anyone can offer an explanation/reason then that would be greatly appreciated.
Cheers.
Agree...good finisher but lightweight in midfield...sometimes goes missing...confidence player...needs to up his game or Grayson will be looking elsewhere.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,346
Agree...good finisher but lightweight in midfield...sometimes goes missing...confidence player...needs to up his game or Grayson will be looking elsewhere.
I think we will keep him but his days of being first choice have probably come to an end if Welsh is fit for Saturday. I can see Keane and Welsh being 1st choice central midfielders for the rest of this season.
As you say, he is a confidence player and his confidence lately seems to diminish gradually as the game progresses.
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,596
I think we will keep him but his days of being first choice have probably come to an end if Welsh is fit for Saturday. I can see Keane and Welsh being 1st choice central midfielders for the rest of this season.
As you say, he is a confidence player and his confidence lately seems to diminish gradually as the game progresses.
Personally I'm absolutely sick the the back teeth of "confidence players." We've had so many of them over the past few years. Sounds to me that these confidence players need to grab themselves by the scruff of the neck and make things happen, rather than stumble along untill a bit of luck goes their way and they regain a bit of confidence. I can accept a player having a bad run of form, but with the "confidence players" we've had, the form never returns!
Personally I'm absolutely sick the the back teeth of "confidence players." We've had so many of them over the past few years. Sounds to me that these confidence players need to grab themselves by the scruff of the neck and make things happen, rather than stumble along untill a bit of luck goes their way and they regain a bit of confidence. I can accept a player having a bad run of form, but with the "confidence players" we've had, the form never returns!
Welcome to league 1
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,596
Welcome to league 1
Valid point. Still infuriates me though.
Wroe has played well when we have had Welsh alongside him to win the ball and a proper centre forward (Sodje) upfront to create space that he can exploit. Deprive him of those supports and he can become anonymous. This sort of thing isn't unusual - deprived of the presence Sean Gregan, for instance, Mark Rankine was always ineffective, though to be fair that didn't stop him trying. We need a much better player for next season to play alongside Welsh with King as first choice back-up. Wroe needs to up his act considerably if he is even to stay with us over the summer and he needs to be told that in no uncertain terms.
I think it's easy to read a bit too much into Wroe's recent performances. He's suffered a loss of form but I don't think there's anything more than that to it, really. It's perhaps been more noticeable because he was exceptional earlier in the season but most players will have ups and downs, particularly at this level.
For me, he's a decent player - far better than many of the midfielders we had when playing at a higher level such as Carter, Shumulikoski and Russell - and when we get the mix of defense and attack right I'm sure he'll hit some good form again. He's by no means the only player to suffer something of a dip in form.
For me, he's a decent player - far better than many of the midfielders we had when playing at a higher level such as Carter, Shumulikoski and Russell - and when we get the mix of defense and attack right I'm sure he'll hit some good form again. He's by no means the only player to suffer something of a dip in form.