Skip to main content

Norwich

Norwich

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
I think Simon Grayson has a bit of a dilemma with Saturdays game against Norwich. Do you leave the team as it is? Do you bring in some fringe players and give them a run out?

Winning is a habit and is something that we will want to continue. However, we have to concede that the ONLY interest for us this season has to be automatic promotion from this god awful division.

If I was in charge for this weekends game, my starting eleven would probably be as follows: -

Stuckmann

Wiseman - Clarke - Hunts - Buchs

Humph - Killa - Welsh - Gally

Davies - Beckford
 
I think Simon Grayson has a bit of a dilemma with Saturdays game against Norwich. Do you leave the team as it is? Do you bring in some fringe players and give them a run out?

Winning is a habit and is something that we will want to continue. However, we have to concede that the ONLY interest for us this season has to be automatic promotion from this god awful division.

If I was in charge for this weekends game, my starting eleven would probably be as follows: -

Stuckmann

Wiseman - Clarke - Hunts - Buchs

Humph - Killa - Welsh - Gally

Davies - Beckford

Why no Laird?
 
Stick with the winning team for me. Wins breed confidence and it's a great habit to get into plus it's the fa cup and players and staff alike love it and want to go as far as you can.

Rotation in jpt for sure a lesser competition with more chance of going to wembley I admit. Walsall gave us a game down there abs are coming off the back of beating mk dons.

Tough week ahead for sure.

Look forward to some signings
 
Quite rightly, Laird has been one of our most attacking players in recent weeks. However, I would personally go with Buchanan for his defensive qualities against Norwich.

The problem with that team is that square of the central midfield on the right Humphrey would pose no attacking threat, whilst on the left Gallagher is not a winger and so would drift inside but then with Buchanan who is not a great attacker at fullback we would have no attacking width on that flank either. Laird gives us an attacking edge that Buchanan cannot provide and must start. My team might be:

Stuckmann

Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Laird

Kilkenny, Welsh, Browne

Gallagher

Beckford, Davies

Alternatively bench Gallagher and use Humphrey right upfront alongside the the strikers.

Having said that I think we might see your side but with Laird at left-back and if he and Wiseman can get upfield enough that might be good enough for us to give an account of ourselves.
 
The problem with that team is that square of the central midfield on the right Humphrey would pose no attacking threat, whilst on the left Gallagher is not a winger and so would drift inside but then with Buchanan who is not a great attacker at fullback we would have no attacking width on that flank either. Laird gives us an attacking edge that Buchanan cannot provide and must start. My team might be:

Stuckmann

Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Laird

Kilkenny, Welsh, Browne

Gallagher

Beckford, Davies

Alternatively bench Gallagher and use Humphrey right upfront alongside the the strikers.

Having said that I think we might see your side but with Laird at left-back and if he and Wiseman can get upfield enough that might be good enough for us to give an account of ourselves.

The trouble with that lineup is that there is no width, except from the full backs and so even less attacking threat. Gallagher played well on the left against Barnsley. He is tackling back more and generally working harder. He is good on the ball and puts some intelligent balls in. He isn't a typical winger as he has no real pace but can do an effective job there in much the same way as Paul Raynor used to do.
 
Stick with the winning team for me. Wins breed confidence and it's a great habit to get into plus it's the fa cup and players and staff alike love it and want to go as far as you can.

Rotation in jpt for sure a lesser competition with more chance of going to wembley I admit. Walsall gave us a game down there abs are coming off the back of beating mk dons.

Tough week ahead for sure.

Look forward to some signings

Grayson has said that the JPT game is more important to the club than the FA Cup tie, so I expect more experimentation v Norwich and a different more usual set up for the Walsall match. Maybe see Wright at the back in a 3 5 2?
 
The trouble with that lineup is that there is no width, except from the full backs and so even less attacking threat. Gallagher played well on the left against Barnsley. He is tackling back more and generally working harder. He is good on the ball and puts some intelligent balls in. He isn't a typical winger as he has no real pace but can do an effective job there in much the same way as Paul Raynor used to do.

Fair points and I don't necesssarily disagree - basically SG has worked out how to make us a tough side very good at containing the opposition in away games and snatching the points but not all that proficient at attacking sides at our place. If we do play with Humphrey and Gallagher then the degree to which Gallagher can get into more central positions, which is where he can be really dangerous, and the corresponding extent to which Laird can exploit whatever space that creates on the left could be crucial. I've been saying for months that if Laird could get back to something like the attacking force he was before his injury then that would add a dimension to our play that we have simply not had with SG. There seem to be some indications that that might now be happening - it is potentially hugely significant for us.
 
Grayson has said that the JPT game is more important to the club than the FA Cup tie, so I expect more experimentation v Norwich and a different more usual set up for the Walsall match. Maybe see Wright at the back in a 3 5 2?
I agree. However, if SG wants to beat Norwich and progress to the next round we are probably going to have to deal with two very fast wingers in Redman and Murphy or Murphy and Murphy. But as McGrath said 'they might be able to run fast but they cannot hobble fast' 😉

If we do want to beat Norwich we need to be in their faces hassling them and go in hard right from the start. Their main priority is to try and get automatic promotion so will not be up to the rough stuff and risk getting any injuries. What we do not want is to be on the other side of a thrashing like Norwich have recently handed out to a few Championship sides.
 
Last edited:
If our opponents on Saturday have some fast wingers then we probably need to play with fullbacks and wide midfelders who can get back and help out. Defensively Woods and Buchanan might not be much different to Wiseman and Laird but they are realistically not the same force going forward. Humphrey, obviously, works very hard defensively on the right but we don't really have an equivalent for the left. Maybe if SG wants to rest a few players we might even go out like this:

Stuckmann

King, Huntington, Wright

Humphrey, Welsh, Kilkenny or Browne, Laird

Brownhill

Davies or Little (just possibly Ebanks-Blake if has signed), Beckford
 
If our opponents on Saturday have some fast wingers then we probably need to play with fullbacks and wide midfelders who can get back and help out. Defensively Woods and Buchanan might not be much different to Wiseman and Laird but they are realistically not the same force going forward. Humphrey, obviously, works very hard defensively on the right but we don't really have an equivalent for the left. Maybe if SG wants to rest a few players we might even go out like this:

Stuckmann

King, Huntington, Wright

Humphrey, Welsh, Kilkenny or Browne, Laird

Brownhill

Davies or Little (just possibly Ebanks-Blake if has signed), Beckford

Is Clarke injured?
 
Is Clarke injured?

No I was just suggesting a team SG might pick if he wants to rest a few players, not what I might prefer. The 'wing-back' formation with Humphrey and Laird in the wide positions works well as a defensive counter-attacking line-up away from home but has rarely delivered at our place against teams that pack their defence. But against opponents from a division higher it might provide us with the means to stifle the oppostion and then hit them on the break.

The absolute all-out attacking option might be:

Stuckmann

Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Laird

Humphrey, Welsh, Kilkenny, Reid

Ebanks-Blake, Beckford
 
We can fall between 2 stools here. We have a realistic chance of a Wembley final in the JPT but no chance of a FA Cup final. Do we forfeit Saturday v Norwich and save everyone for Tues v Walsall ? Knowing Simon, I think he'll go as strong as he can for both. Best team possible for 1st match, then assess injuries, tiredness etc for next match.
 
Back
Top