Skip to main content

Observations

Observations

I'm a wankshaft BML? Fair enough, I only voiced an opinion based upon what I have viewed. Constructive criticism I believe it is called.

Next time, I will just announce that Player X is shit. Then you can be justified in having a thinly veiled pop at me.
Not at all JD, you are, in fact, a massive part of this forum and one of the few posters I respect the views of.

However, I'd suggest you watch the replays - Bennett's strike was a corker and Dorran's was hard, low, through three bodies and in the corner. In hindsight it also sounded like it took a deflection on the way.

Can't blame Maxwell for those.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
 
Not at all JD, you are, in fact, a massive part of this forum and one of the few posters I respect the views of.

However, I'd suggest you watch the replays - Bennett's strike was a corker and Dorran's was hard, low, through three bodies and in the corner. In hindsight it also sounded like it took a deflection on the way.

Can't blame Maxwell for those.

I agree with you on Dorran's shot and the criticism levied Maxwell's way.

However, I do think he should have done better with Bennett's shot against Rovers, he got to it and it went over his hands.
 
Not at all JD, you are, in fact, a massive part of this forum and one of the few posters I respect the views of.

However, I'd suggest you watch the replays - Bennett's strike was a corker and Dorran's was hard, low, through three bodies and in the corner. In hindsight it also sounded like it took a deflection on the way.

Can't blame Maxwell for those.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Fair enough. I apologise if I mistook your post the wrong way.
 
Agree entirely with your post BML other than gallys poor performances aren't just down to yesterday, he offers nothing in midfield. Once every blue moon he picks out a pass and some people then say he's our pirlo ����. freekicks & corners very poor, he used all his good freekicks in the Huddersfield home game. Corners either don't beat front man or drift out of play at back post. Operates in and around centre circle and never makes a tackle
 
I was disappointed with our application to the game yesterday, especially the first half where we just didn't seem to care. There was no fight or desire that first 45 minutes or so and it wasn't until Horgan came on that things changed. After we scored and the chances we had I thought that we were going to get the equaliser and their third goal, I thought there were two off-sides (only just) in the build up, flattered them.

It is a long way for me to come (500 miles plus round trip) and a long day (set off at 7:10 a.m. and got home at 11:30 p.m.) to watch a poor performance especially when I had 4 City fans in the car with me. I'd expected the lads to have wanted to get the points to end as high as possible this season, probably i expect too much and I know that with the injuries we have in the defence and Pearson being out as well have a big affect, but I found it very disappointing, my only high throughout the game was sitting next to Dazzler 😉
 
I was disappointed with our application to the game yesterday, especially the first half where we just didn't seem to care. There was no fight or desire that first 45 minutes or so and it wasn't until Horgan came on that things changed. After we scored and the chances we had I thought that we were going to get the equaliser and their third goal, I thought there were two off-sides (only just) in the build up, flattered them.

It is a long way for me to come (500 miles plus round trip) and a long day (set off at 7:10 a.m. and got home at 11:30 p.m.) to watch a poor performance especially when I had 4 City fans in the car with me. I'd expected the lads to have wanted to get the points to end as high as possible this season, probably i expect too much and I know that with the injuries we have in the defence and Pearson being out as well have a big affect, but I found it very disappointing, my only high throughout the game was sitting next to Dazzler 😉
Well done on your commitment mate, Jeeeez, I bet that was a shit journey home in a car full of canaries after an embarrassing defeat like that.
 
I heard that on RL too about someone wanting a clear out, and profesionals at the club. I think we do need a good look at certain players who clearly are not going to figure next season and move them on.. Clearing the way for the apointment of say more hungry replacements. Not gonna name names but sure we all know the weakest links at the moment. I think the professional bit meant players who played till the last game but maybe i misheard it as i was in the car at the time. We have done very well considering our budget and others who have tycoon investors willing to gamble on success. We are not too far away from being contenders but yesterday our defence was decimated so the result was always on the cards. Its just fans frustrations boiling over in the heat of defeat. UTW !
 
Well done on your commitment mate, Jeeeez, I bet that was a shit journey home in a car full of canaries after an embarrassing defeat like that.

I just agreed that Norwich probably desired the 3 points and said that Norwich have done well to be 2 points above us and they can be proud of their team especially when Pritchard, their young midfielder who had his one-on-one with Maxwell end of the first half saved, alone cost 20 times than our whole team that started yesterday and he wasn't anywhere near their most expensive player on the pitch yesterday. They didn't say that much after that had sunk in.
 
Think a decision on Gallagher needs to be made, he either has to be played out wide or in a midfield 3 there is no in-between.

In a midfield 2 he doesn't cover enough ground or win the ball back enough, he was bullied all day yesterday like he was against Forest.

Play him with Pearson and 1 more CM and he will run a game.
 
At last,some others have come to accept the Gallagher shortcomings,a complete waste at Huddersfield and appeared to be Norwichs best chance maker yesterday.Is fit for Div1 or 2 now,
cant build any meaning midfield around him in our div
 
Yesterday was as flat a performance and crowd as there has been for 2 seasons . I suspect the team just ran out of steam with the realisation that a play-off chance had gone . Little consolation for us lot who shelled out £20-odd each , but an explanation .
The depth of squad is better than last season , but not good enough for a genuine play-off campaign .
Next season we will need a second GK , centre-half , right back ( hopefully Baptiste ) , a central midfielder to regularly partner Pearson and a quality forward .
Not to mention getting McGeady back at ( nearly ) all costs .
Risdale did say they would be ruthless and some hard decisions will have to be made , eg Gally becoming more of a squad player .
 
Knee jerk bullshit on here.

We've performed absolutely admirably this season, playing our best football under Grayson by a mile, and we finally have some pace and flair in the team for the first time in years.

No keeper in our league would have stopped Bennett's thunderbolt for Rovers, and Dorrans' strike today was as true as an arrow. To start having a pop at a goalkeeper that has been consistently excellent shows what a bunch of fickle wank shafts we have as part of our fan base.

Cunningham, Clarke, Baptiste and Pearson make a big difference to our team and they were missed.

Regardless of final position, we have become a team that - for the first time in many seasons - are a joy to watch at times. Long may it continue despite some bad days at the office like today.

I have gone from someone bored of Grayson's attritional and ultra defensive outfits to a fan gappy to be entertained even if we finish a place or two below last term. The likes of McGeady, Barkhuizen, Horgan, Johnson, Gallagher (despite today's performance) and Robinson are all players worth paying for. A far cry from the Chris Humphrey days.

Hopefully we can jettison some high earning low performers and bring in some more genuine quality in the summer. If it works out that way, I'll be happy.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Bang on. I'd add that the summer recruitment needs to be built around finding a balance between the ultra-defensive hard to beat SG team of the past and the new look, creative but way too open PNE of today.
 
I don't think Maxwell did much wrong yesterday, a few stray kicks aside and maybe one cross that wasn't dealt with properly.

He's a good keeper, Pickford aside, he's the best we've had since Carlo Nash.
 
I agree with a lot of what has been said on here since my post and I do have fairly strong reservations about Gallagher or Johnson being played in a middle 2. Assist aside, Gallagher was poor yesterday and neither he or Johnson do enough defensively in a two man centre. Even the industry and aggression of Pearson can't make up for it. I think Robinson is better out wide than up top and vice versa for Barkhuizen. If we keep McGeady and bring in 2 or 3 quality players in the right positions we'll improve again next term. Let's be honest we've had quite a few passengers this season on very good money.

Delighted with the way we've developed as an attacking force this season, notwithstanding the fact that a great deal of it stems from the talismanic McGeady.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
 
Gallagher can't play in a middle 2, I've been saying it for over 18 months now. A strong CM who can play every week, probably alongside Pearson is an absolute must and a priority this summer.
 
Gallagher can't play in a middle 2, I've been saying it for over 18 months now. A strong CM who can play every week, probably alongside Pearson is an absolute must and a priority this summer.

We are often over-run when we play a middle 2 regardless of the pairing. I think that SG over-plays it.
 
Good thread and I agree totally. (I don't for one second think or indeed see that every player is on holiday already) but I do feel this was apparent 3 maybe 5 games past.

As for the nonscence regarding one of our best players yes again I find myself pointing out the obvious regarding maxwell. Beginning to think I am becoming an advisor on the keeper position.

10 shots on target (BBC sport) I can only recall one being a bit soft.

3 conceded -
1) Powerful deflected shot into the side netting
2) Absolutely free uninpeeded bags of time shot from the centre of the goal from 10/12 yards into the lower left corner. Maxwell was on his line at the start of the move covering the possible shot/cross
3) Yet another Unimpeded run into the box with the ball at his feet fairly central one on one

Distribution is as per SG style of play instruction and the boys at the back hiding from a pass.
He tries to give an advantage to the receiver every time. Maxwell very rairly smashes and hopes even under pressure on a back pass. Ffs some people need to open their eyes.

Let me repeat my very early posts regarding taking my grandkids to Fleetwood (they now get the bus in and we go to pne) maxwell can without question compete with any keeper you care to name regarding playing out from the back. The manager would kick off every time a long ball went out. Kamikaze stuff at times but it never went wrong from maxwell.

Some also seem to have not seen the 4-5 interceptions to stop further one on ones. This would even against your world wide selection of any keeper of choice would be definately 1 goal maybe even 3 goals. And most would not dare even bother to expose themselves.

Crosses the one referred to as not being completed is probably the second half. Ffs it was a free header in the making at the back post- I defy you to find many keepers that would even bother to go and challenge the ball.

I do however have concerns regarding signing Mcgeady long term - I don't want another quality player milking a living yes milking a living by taking it easy. Hope I am doing the lad a disservice here because I enjoy watching him when he puts a shift in.

I have the same feeling regarding Baptiste who took the piss during the game against Leeds. He yanked his GPS tracker off at the start of the sencond half and in my opinion created a deliberate sending off. Hope again I am doing this lad a disservice. I really rate this lad but please WTF!

I am shocked at how much Horgan (Blackburn game onwards) and Barkhuizen have gone completely off the boil. Come on lads don't let yourselves down after such a brilliant start in the pne shirt.

Robinson and Pearson are young lads who will no doubt blow a little hot and cold at times both excellent players but come on boys let's not let yourselves down with a poor Finnish to the season.
 
I agree with the points you make about Maxwell's proactivity and positivity and the impact has on the team. He's a true 'sweeper keeper' and it has become so familiar I think people take for granted how much an asset it is to the back four. All goalkeepers make mistakes, and they are brutally punished, however on the whole I have been tremendously impressed with his all round game. He isn't as good as Pickford, but that lad is different class.

I don't agree about Horgan, Barkhuizen and McGeady: they are all flair players and by definition will blow hot and cold and not marmalade players like Pearson. You have to take the rough with the smooth with them and I would argue that it's been far smoother than rough since they came!!!
 
Back
Top