Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

Show me were I've defended it? I commented that Garner would have done the same thing. At normal speed it looked a penalty all day long, only on the replay could you tell there was no contact.

Get the fuck off my case will you. I stopped posting on this site for months because of you. In fact you're going on igonore. I request you do the same to me.

Bye, and good riddance, oh i know you never went off the forum matey.
 
"Attempting to foul" is in the laws of the game. No referee would have the balls to give a penalty if he'd hurdled Stuckmann and stayed on his feet.

Why should a player be denied a goal scoring opportunity because he wants to avoid being injured?

Unfortunately until refs have the bottle to give a penalty for an "attempt to foul" then players take it into their own hands.

What about Smalling pushing Garner in the first half was that not an attempt at a foul?

Dowd had no bottle and these referee's don't like giving decisions against the top sides because the likes of Van Gaal don't give a shit about the fines and just focus everything on the referee when there teams don't perform up to the level they are paid to.

Dowd bottled quite a few things tonight.
 
"Attempting to foul" is in the laws of the game. No referee would have the balls to give a penalty if he'd hurdled Stuckmann and stayed on his feet.

Why should a player be denied a goal scoring opportunity because he wants to avoid being injured?

Unfortunately until refs have the bottle to give a penalty for an "attempt to foul" then players take it into their own hands.

So you think Stuckman deliberately attempted to foul Rooney?
I don't, I think he attempted to get a foot on the ball (which he didn't get to) but neither did he make contact with the player...
 
If he doesn't get out of the way he clatters him, so he does what, let's him take him out and potentially ends up getting injured or jumps him?

If he jumps him and stays on his feet and doesn't score he's been denied a straight shot at goal from 12 yards.

Why should the player have to make that decision? The law is wrong and encourages simulation when a player is trying to avoid injury.
 
If he doesn't get out of the way he clatters him, so he does what, let's him take him out and potentially ends up getting injured or jumps him?

If he jumps him and stays on his feet and doesn't score he's been denied a straight shot at goal from 12 yards.

Why should the player have to make that decision? The law is wrong and encourages simulation when a player is trying to avoid injury.
He dived. It's cheating.
 
The 3 Man Utd goals:

1) Rooney is stood in an offside position and as the ball didn't touch him, the rules say the goal must stand. If Rooney has to move his body to avoid the ball hitting him, surely he has to be interfering with play.

2) Falaini gives Tom Clarke a nudge in order to get in his header. I think it was Phil Neville who said it was only a slight nudge and the goal should/ was allowed. That slight nudge was sufficient to stop TC from getting his head to the ball first.

3) the way Stuckmann came out, and the position of the referee, he was always going to give a penalty. However, replays showed quite clearly that there was no contact and that Rooney dived.


All in all, all 3 decisions went against us but I can see why the ref made those decisions. We were very unlucky, but the lads did us proud, and I'm quite content with that.
 
What an absolute wanker Phil Neville is.

Climb out of Rooneys arse you long faced ugly cunt!!

Leg breaking challenge, he could have had his leg snapped, he's a fucking embarrassment.
 
Have you been taking angry juice. I said the offside decision was fucking pathetic before and you jumped down my throat thinking I was calling you......

Chill.

Hes a prat who doesnt come on PNE nowadays and takes great pleasure in mocking PNE fans. remember his "Im leaving, I dont like it here anymore, throwing his dummy out post?"
 
offside and a dive

Stuckmann had no need to give him that option though, what was he doing, he wasn't even heading towards goal.
 
Stuckmann had no need to give him that option though, what was he doing, he wasn't even heading towards goal.


Why are you knocking your own players you fuckwit , Rooney went down on his second stride after jumping to avoid the challenge , stuckmans job was to save or put him off job was done .
 
Stuckmann had no need to give him that option though, what was he doing, he wasn't even heading towards goal.

Stuckmann made exactly the correct decision to go out for that ball, rooney was through on goal, Stuckers coming out forced him away hed lost control of the ball and took a dive.
 
Back
Top