Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

Stuckmann had no need to give him that option though, what was he doing, he wasn't even heading towards goal.

He wasn't even heading towards goal...... Let's add that Stuckman never touched him...... Add that to Rooney dived on the floor......

Cheating.
 
I enjoyed the Di Maria dive most. Once play continued and he didn't get a free kick, his broken leg / ankle mysteriously vanished within 15 or 20 seconds and he was up chasing the ball and about 1 min later his leg / ankle had healed enough for him to have a shot at goal?

If you watch that moment again on the replay as he takes his third roll, clutching his leg, he looks to see where the ref is.

Brilliant, what a credit.
 
The 3 Man Utd goals:

1) Rooney is stood in an offside position and as the ball didn't touch him, the rules say the goal must stand. If Rooney has to move his body to avoid the ball hitting him, surely he has to be interfering with play.

2) Falaini gives Tom Clarke a nudge in order to get in his header. I think it was Phil Neville who said it was only a slight nudge and the goal should/ was allowed. That slight nudge was sufficient to stop TC from getting his head to the ball first.

3) the way Stuckmann came out, and the position of the referee, he was always going to give a penalty. However, replays showed quite clearly that there was no contact and that Rooney dived.


All in all, all 3 decisions went against us but I can see why the ref made those decisions. We were very unlucky, but the lads did us proud, and I'm quite content with that.

Didn't notice any foul for their 2nd goal but agree on the others. Anyway feeling more confident for the league campaign now.
 
Man of the match tonight should have been Dowd he had 3 assists , 200m of talent on the pitch and they resort to cheating , i hope Arsenal stuff em
 
One way we can hold our heads high tonight is apart from maybe Garner going down a bit easy from a shove we didn't dive, interfere or cheat our way through a football match.

We showed Man U how to play the game fairly, they gave a great example of how you can cheat to be victorious, the saying cheats never prosper has never been further from the truth tonight.
 
From the Telegraph report:

After 65 minutes, Young picked out Herrera, who drove his shot in off the post. Stuckmann was furious, rushing towards Dowd, arguing that Rooney was obstructing his vision which he clearly had been. The case for video technology was again enhanced.
 
One way we can hold our heads high tonight is apart from maybe Garner going down a bit easy from a shove we didn't dive, interfere or cheat our way through a football match.

We showed Man U how to play the game fairly, they gave a great example of how you can cheat to be victorious, the saying cheats never prosper has never been further from the truth tonight.
more money to be made by Sky having United in the latter rounds of the cup than North End.

Money talks.
 
Oh I can and will.....

But the first was interfering with play. The last was a cheating dive. There is no doubt at all, the officials got it wrong.

I would also say the two hands in Clarks back could've been given as a foul for the second, but can see how the officials missed that...... The first and last, anyone saying that's acceptable are simply wrong.

100%, iron clad, no argument, spot on Nobs!
 
IF the referee was so sure it was a foul, Stuckers would of been off, But the referee wasn't sure, so shouldn't of given the penalty. I wait for the day that the Premiershit starts having an Oscars style night for play acting, Diving, simulation.

There was an incident earlier in the game, Di Maria dived and rolled over several times, Referee was in a similar position as he was to the Rooney decision. He got that decision right by not giving a freekick, but failed to book the diving fucker for it. If that had been a PNE player he would of been booked.

Everything that is wrong with the Prem was on show tonight, If it wasn't for the Money it would earn the club then I wouldn't want PNE to go up there, its not football anymore.
 
Why not? Refs need to have more bottle to give fouls and penalties when no contact is made. The law is quite clear, they need to apply it more.
 
Back
Top