Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

No, because I'm not blinkered. I'm saying it as I see it, I'm not glad we got beat, I thought the first should have been offside, I thought the 3rd should have been a penalty.


He went down on the second stride after the incident it was a dive , you might not be blinkered but you dont seem to see whats in front of you
 
I felt all 3 officials came out to favour the premiership team tonight and some of the pally backslapping styff with dowd was cringeworthy.

The first utd goal I screamed offside when I watched it live. Having seen the replay, I can see the argument for it not being so, but the linesman in front of the invincibles flagged for everything in the first half and yet kept it down for that. Very suspicious.

The second goal looked like a shove from fellaini watching it live. Sort of decision ref can either give or not give. Surprise surprise he didn't give a foul.

Third goal I blame the ref, not Wayne Rooney who I felt jumped over Stuckman but then stumbled and went down, not necessarily diving. It is clear from the replay that there was no contact, and it is also clear that Stuckmans intent was for the ball not the man. To me a red can only give a decision like that if he is certain he saw contact. Dowd went on a whim, and this was to me a very dishonest refereeing decision. Unless he saw contact, which he can't have done, he can't give a penalty.
 
The referee has come in for some fair criticism, but I don't think it has been mentioned, I found it a bit strange that Dowd & Rooney were having quite a chat/laugh together prior to kicking off for the second half. I'm not suggesting any collusion or anything, but I thought it would have been better for Dowd not to have engaged in a conversation with any one player.
 
Christ, there's some bitterness on here tonight. firstly, fat Dowd was shit for both sides, massively inconsistent. he gave fouls in favour of Davies and against the afro for the same things. Davies should have been off. The first goal stands for me, even Grayson thinks so, the 2nd I just see a big guy beating a smaller guy to a header, nothing more really. The dive is a dive end of, I honestly thought he'd booked Rooney at first. I thought he'd gone round the keeper (nobody seems to do that anymore). pne should be proud, they gave United a game and pushed them till the end. Shame Bailey didn't get the BBC motm, blind is excellent, keown is a massive bellend.
 
Christ, there's some bitterness on here tonight. firstly, fat Dowd was shit for both sides, massively inconsistent. he gave fouls in favour of Davies and against the afro for the same things. Davies should have been off. The first goal stands for me, even Grayson thinks so, the 2nd I just see a big guy beating a smaller guy to a header, nothing more really. The dive is a dive end of, I honestly thought he'd booked Rooney at first. I thought he'd gone round the keeper (nobody seems to do that anymore). pne should be proud, they gave United a game and pushed them till the end. Shame Bailey didn't get the BBC motm, blind is excellent, keown is a massive bellend.

I'm a football expert so I mean it when I say great post.

Well said.
 
ad51d4eb-bbdd-48c9-a09b-3aba72f4ca2b-620x372.jpeg


No pen.....cheating tw*t
 
He didn't though did he. He gave a dodgy pen, the other two are perfectly legitimate within the rules.

Well the first 'goal' is open to debate as to whether it was interfering with play. I'll respectfully disagree with you on it.
 
Christ, there's some bitterness on here tonight. firstly, fat Dowd was shit for both sides, massively inconsistent. he gave fouls in favour of Davies and against the afro for the same things. Davies should have been off. The first goal stands for me, even Grayson thinks so, the 2nd I just see a big guy beating a smaller guy to a header, nothing more really. The dive is a dive end of, I honestly thought he'd booked Rooney at first. I thought he'd gone round the keeper (nobody seems to do that anymore). pne should be proud, they gave United a game and pushed them till the end. Shame Bailey didn't get the BBC motm, blind is excellent, keown is a massive bellend.

I am not bitter at all, I am happy we gave them a game and were no pushovers but, come on, Davies should not have been sent off at all. The first goal was clearly offside, if Rooney is impairing the goalkeepers view then he is interfering with play. The second was a foul on Tom Clarke before the goal was scored, the penalty was a clear dive. These are the facts whether you like them or not. I am sick to death of lower league apologists, I'm not bitter I am cheesed off with the big decisions going for the big clubs and then people expecting us to accept it. No wonder this game is dying a slow death.
 
1. Rooney was not interfering with play as the ball went past him. It was an unstoppable finish, they have more class than us and can do things like that. End of.

Here is what should have happened. The linesman should have raised his flag for offside, as he was in no position to determine whether or not Rooney was interfering with Stuckmann's sight line.

Then the ref (I use that word loosely) would have been able to think about the decision, maybe even consult the linesman, and then determine if Rooney was indeed a)in an offside position (which we all know he was) and b) interfering with play.

The linesman had no right to leave both decisions to Dowd, and by not raising his flag, in effect he did not communicate with the referee that Rooney was in an offside position.

I knew we would be in trouble as soon as I saw Dowd was the referee, and true to form he put in yet another un-professional performance. TV replays clearly showed no contact between Stuckmann and Rooney.

Dowd is clueless, the linesman incompetent, we are out of the cup but made some dosh so it is what it is.
 
Back
Top