Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

"Attempting to foul" is in the laws of the game. No referee would have the balls to give a penalty if he'd hurdled Stuckmann and stayed on his feet.

Why should a player be denied a goal scoring opportunity because he wants to avoid being injured?

Unfortunately until refs have the bottle to give a penalty for an "attempt to foul" then players take it into their own hands.

Unless you or Dowd are a mind reader, there is no way that either of you can say categorically that Stuckmann's intent was to foul. In fact if you view the photo somewhere on this thread Stuckmann's feet are both firmly on the ground with no studs even showing.

I have never liked any rule that is up for interpretation. This "new" offside rule is total BS and so is allowing a referee to determine what was in a player's mind.

If Rooney had to move away from the line of Herrera's shot, then for me, he is interfering with play, and it was just guesswork on the part of Dowd re the "penalty" decision.

The fact that the linesman did not raise his flag for the first goal to me is suspicious to say the least. How could he determine from the touchline that Rooney was not interfering with play?
 
3 dubious decisions but we did get away with one decision, where the ref chose not send off KD for a second yellow card. Had he got sent off with 20 minutes to go, Utd would probably still have gone on to win the game.

That was about the only decision that went for us all night.
 
If we had scored their three goals it would a public outrage - I though that wasn't helped by the linesman on the Invincible side who seemed frightened to give any decision against United. They were the better side and deserved to win in my opinion but the three goals were horrendous on the part of the officials.
 
Interesting editorial on the interfering with play aspect of the offsite rule

http://www.goal.com/en/news/1717/ed...ey-not-interfering-with-play-its-time-to-stop
Great read that. The rule states that the player is offside if gaining an advantage by being in that position. If anyone on the planet doesn't think that was the case, when Rooney jumped out of the way of the ball and the keeper hesitated, then you are simply wrong.

It goes on to say interfering with an opponent, he interfered with the keepers decision.
Gaining an advantage by standing in that position..... He gained a goal.

Anyone trying to defend that decision doesn't know the current offside rule, ref included.
 
offside and a dive

I struggle to see how anyone can think that if Rooney hadn't jumped out of the way he wouldn't have been taken out by Stuckmann and the penalty given.

So why does avoiding contact so you don't get injured became something to be penalised for?

He was perfectly entitled to a penalty because Stuckmann was late, missed the ball and but for Rooney jumping him would have taken him down.

Why is that difficult to admit?
 
I struggle to see how anyone can think that if Rooney hadn't jumped out of the way he wouldn't have been taken out by Stuckmann and the penalty given.

So why does avoiding contact so you don't get injured became something to be penalised for?

He was perfectly entitled to a penalty because Stuckmann was late, missed the ball and but for Rooney jumping him would have taken him down.

Why is that difficult to admit?

You sound as ridiculous as the fools on TV last night. KK had it right as did other "professionals". We deserved better than a bunch of moaning, softie premadonnas that threw themselves down every two minutes.
 
Nothing ridiculous in that analysis at all. I'll ask again:

"Why should you be penalised for avoiding contact and potential injury?"
 
North End fans in finding an excuse for the defeat shocker.

By no means did we disgrace ourselves, we were simply beaten by a better team.

Time to move in and concentrate on the real aim this season - promotion.

See you Saturday lads.
 
North End fans in finding an excuse for the defeat shocker.

By no means did we disgrace ourselves, we were simply beaten by a better team and the ref

Time to move in and concentrate on the real aim this season - promotion.

See you Saturday lads.
Edited for you
 
Nothing ridiculous in that analysis at all. I'll ask again:

"Why should you be penalised for avoiding contact and potential injury?"

He avoided contact he wasn't touched at all and, having done that, he dived to get a penalty. Had that penalty been given against them they would be screaming from the roof tops.
 
I am not bitter at all, I am happy we gave them a game and were no pushovers but, come on, Davies should not have been sent off at all. The first goal was clearly offside, if Rooney is impairing the goalkeepers view then he is interfering with play. The second was a foul on Tom Clarke before the goal was scored, the penalty was a clear dive. These are the facts whether you like them or not. I am sick to death of lower league apologists, I'm not bitter I am cheesed off with the big decisions going for the big clubs and then people expecting us to accept it. No wonder this game is dying a slow death.

Davies was lucky. He's made a career of stamping elbowing and going through the back of players. Last night when he wasn't being a dirty sod, he was throwing himself on the floor and Dowd gave him most of those 50/50 decisions. Rooneys not impairing anybody's vision, stuckman was slow to react, as he was indecisive with the cross for the second. I also don't think it was a push on Clarke, he was just stronger, its a contact sport, if you blow up every to.e somebody is touched then the game would never get going or finish. If this makes me an apologist then so be it.
 
Davies was lucky. He's made a career of stamping elbowing and going through the back of players. Last night when he wasn't being a dirty sod, he was throwing himself on the floor and Dowd gave him most of those 50/50 decisions. Rooneys not impairing anybody's vision, stuckman was slow to react, as he was indecisive with the cross for the second. I also don't think it was a push on Clarke, he was just stronger, its a contact sport, if you blow up every to.e somebody is touched then the game would never get going or finish. If this makes me an apologist then so be it.

We will have to agree to disagree, but I can honestly say that had those 3 goals been scored by us against them, they would be screaming all the way to London and that ref would not referee another premiership game.
 
Hi Joanpne Fair enough it was a dive. I must admit it looked a stonewall pen from the AKTE and their fans would have been screaming if it had not been given.

However we have a player who winds opposing fans up with the number of times he goes to ground when barely touched or not touched at all.
Joey Garner dives so often now he does not get free kicks and pens when he is fouled because he has got a reputation with refs for diving.
Same incident with DeGea flying out Joey would have hit the deck without a second thought.
He dived early on last night but that OK with you and the rest of us?

it is OK to dive if they play for us but they are the scum of the earth if the dive against us.
 
offside and a dive

He avoided contact he wasn't touched at all and, having done that, he dived to get a penalty. Had that penalty been given against them they would be screaming from the roof tops.

If he doesn't avoid contact its a penalty, if he does avoid contact he goes down and its a penalty.

The irony is it was his jump that stops it being a penalty a split second earlier.

The end result, it's a penalty whichever way you dice it.
 
Last edited:
offside and a dive

I think the fact the biggest protest from our players come after the first goal says a lot.

Tom Clarke didn't make a big deal of the slight push for the second and Stuckmann didn't make a big deal out of the third even though he knows he didn't touch him because he's well aware that if Rooney hadn't hurdled him he'd have caught him late anyway.

Personally I think the game swung on that first goal and that should NOT have been given in my opinion.
 
If he doesn't avoid contact its a penalty, if he does avoid contact he goes down and its a penalty.

The irony is it was his jump and subsequent dive that stop it being a penalty a split second earlier.

The end result, it's a penalty whichever way you dice it.

It was a dive .
He avoided the challenge like many players do week in week out then went down afterwards without contact .
 
offside and a dive

So, would you have been happier if he'd not jumped out of the way and got the penalty that way?

Either way it's a penalty
 
Back
Top