Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

If we had scored those goals you just know at least two would not have been allowed.

Just before the second half kicked off the camera caught Rooney talking to the ref.. he was making sure the camera didn't pick up what he was saying. We both commented that it looked very dodgy.
 
Hi Joanpne Fair enough it was a dive. I must admit it looked a stonewall pen from the AKTE and their fans would have been screaming if it had not been given.

However we have a player who winds opposing fans up with the number of times he goes to ground when barely touched or not touched at all.
Joey Garner dives so often now he does not get free kicks and pens when he is fouled because he has got a reputation with refs for diving.
Same incident with DeGea flying out Joey would have hit the deck without a second thought.
He dived early on last night but that OK with you and the rest of us?

it is OK to dive if they play for us but they are the scum of the earth if the dive against us.
If it had been DeGea and Garner, Joe would have made sure there was contact and gone down, penalty. Rooney was not touched but jumped over Stucks legs and dived because his touch on the ball was a poor one. Do you think that if this had happened outside of the area and a slide tackle had come in he would have gone down? Of course he wouldn't he would have stayed on his feet and gone in on goal. The only 'professionals' who say it was a penalty are either Ex Man Utd players or Rooney's England Manager, other ex players who have nothing to do with Man Utd are saying it is a dive!
 
If it had been DeGea and Garner, Joe would have made sure there was contact and gone down, penalty. Rooney was not touched but jumped over Stucks legs and dived because his touch on the ball was a poor one. Do you think that if this had happened outside of the area and a slide tackle had come in he would have gone down? Of course he wouldn't he would have stayed on his feet and gone in on goal. The only 'professionals' who say it was a penalty are either Ex Man Utd players or Rooney's England Manager, other ex players who have nothing to do with Man Utd are saying it is a dive!

Grayson is saying it wasn't a dive......
 
If we had scored those goals you just know at least two would not have been allowed.

Just before the second half kicked off the camera caught Rooney talking to the ref.. he was making sure the camera didn't pick up what he was saying. We both commented that it looked very dodgy.
I saw that also and I almost said to the chap next to me that the red was saying: 'if things remain tight get the ball into the area and go down and I'll point to the spot'
 
It wasn't a dive, it was a clear penalty. If he had not jumped Stuckers would have taken him out. It's what players do to avoid getting splattered.

As for the offside, well he was clearly interfering with play.
 
So, would you have been happier if he'd not jumped out of the way and got the penalty that way?

Either way it's a penalty
Have you been brought up on Premiership football? Where a sniper from the stands appears in every game and the 'clever' players win a decision?

What a crock of shite. He dived. No contact. Shit decision. Whats more worrying is the people that think this behavour is acceptable.
 
It wasn't a dive, it was a clear penalty. If he had not jumped Stuckers would have taken him out. It's what players do to avoid getting splattered.

As for the offside, well he was clearly interfering with play.
John, do you think that if this had happened outside of the area and a slide tackle had come in he would have gone down or stayed on his feet and ran on goal with the ball'. To me if no contact was made, which there wasn't, if Rooney could have stayed on his feet, which he could, if Stuckmann had intended to bring Rooney down, which he didn't he intended to get the ball, then yes it would have been a penalty bug to me Rooney cheated.
 
John, do you think that if this had happened outside of the area and a slide tackle had come in he would have gone down or stayed on his feet and ran on goal with the ball'. To me if no contact was made, which there wasn't, if Rooney could have stayed on his feet, which he could, if Stuckmann had intended to bring Rooney down, which he didn't he intended to get the ball, then yes it would have been a penalty bug to me Rooney cheated.

Could he have stayed on his feet if he hadn't jumped over Stuckmann? No...penalty
 
Have you been brought up on Premiership football? Where a sniper from the stands appears in every game and the 'clever' players win a decision?

What a crock of shite. He dived. No contact. Shit decision. Whats more worrying is the people that think this behavour is acceptable.

No, think I've only been to one Premiership game in my life and don't really watch that much on TV. The second Stuckmann misses the ball it was *always* going to be a penalty, how it came about is actually irrelevant. I'm glad Grayson sees it that way too.
 
No, think I've only been to one Premiership game in my life and don't really watch that much on TV. The second Stuckmann misses the ball it was *always* going to be a penalty, how it came about is actually irrelevant. I'm glad Grayson sees it that way too.

I'm glad that 90% of the reports and posts I am reading are saying it for what it is, a dive. He cheated.
 
Whilst we are talking stupid, poor decisions how about this one from our very own resident idiot posted first thing this morning....


Through to the last 8 of the FA Cup and third in the league.

LVG seems to be doing alright if you ask me.

Should Preston North End fans not be discussing the poor decisions? The wonderful team and individual performances. Fair enough having difference of opinions over dives, offside decisions etc..... but this?

Pathetic.
 
You're like a stuck record you know.

Would you have been happier if he'd have let Stuckmann clatter him? At least we wouldn't be having this nonsense debate now.
 
But he did jump didn't he that was his decision, therefore a dive, no penalty and a booking for Rooney.

It was his decision to avoid and his decision to dive. Either way it wasn't in our hands and either way it's a penalty. Same outcome.

Call it "karma", on one hand he stops a penalty on the other he wins one. Balance.
 
Well 90% of the reports are wrong then.

It was rash of Stuckman to go in like that but Rooney clearly leaves his leg in looking for contact which never came.. he already has it in is mind he is going down. There was absolutely nothing to prevent Rooney going for the ball. Mirror back page says "LUCKY DEVILS"
 
It was his decision to avoid and his decision to dive. Either way it wasn't in our hands and either way it's a penalty. Same outcome. Call it "karma"

there it is in black and white, highlighted for you.

He cheated. Modern day premiership, soft, cheating ponce.
 
Back
Top