Skip to main content

On reflection....

On reflection....

Joined
Apr 27, 2006
Messages
17,335
Location
Lurking in the shadows
A difficult September for North End with just two points from four home games.

1-2 v Derby H
1-1 v Bristol City H
1-2 v Brentford A
2-2 v Bournemouth H (lost 2-3 on Pens. Capital One Cup)
1-1 v Wolves H

We have played better than that but you are punished for your mistakes at this level.

October looks not too bad

Sheff Wed A
Cardiff H
Charlton A
Brighton A
Bolton H

We could do with 9 points......it`s a big month for us.


Brentford and Rotherham appear to be panicking already ....
 
Have to win your home games if you want to stay up or atleast some of them.

Not good enough so far.

+1

We've had some tough home games but 3 points from 15 so far at home is very poor.

Getting draws on the road in this division will do but we need to start getting wins on the board at home.
 
Sheff Wed and Brighton away look tough fixtures on paper - draws in each would be decent results, particularly Brighton, but the other games against Cardiff, Charlton and Bolton look winnable. Home form isn't great but we looked the part 11v11 on Saturday and did very well even 10v11 so something to build on there.
 
Its a big month for the club no doubt, I had no worries that we might be in a relegation scrap come May however the longer you are down there the harder it is to get out. Once the sacking season starts (Rotherham today) in earnest the pressure then mounts on the manager if your in a position where everyone else has made the change and you haven't.
 
I doubt we will sack Grayson even if we go down, no point getting on the sacking race game. With what he has achieved in nearly 3 years I think he should be afforded some time.

Many will argue that he has been backed to the high hilt, but it is still his responsibility to sign players that are good and will improve us, which I think he has done in abundance.
 
Many will argue that he has been backed to the high hilt, but it is still his responsibility to sign players that are good and will improve us, which I think he has done in abundance.

I'm not so sure many will argue that based on this summer. I certainly wouldn't.
 
A difficult September for North End with just two points from four home games.

1-2 v Derby H
1-1 v Bristol City H
1-2 v Brentford A
2-2 v Bournemouth H (lost 2-3 on Pens. Capital One Cup)
1-1 v Wolves H

We have played better than that but you are punished for your mistakes at this level.

October looks not too bad

Sheff Wed A
Cardiff H
Charlton A
Brighton A
Bolton H

We could do with 9 points......it`s a big month for us.


Brentford and Rotherham appear to be panicking already ....

Just shows how much you need to take your chances in this league, which we haven't done so far.

I had a similar feeling at the end of Saturday as I had at Chesterfield in the playoffs, nothing but pride for the efforts the players put in and a feeling that both players and supporters really are in it together. I really think Wolves game could galvanise the club for the rest of our season, got a feeling the players will have chip on their shoulder for the foreseeable.
 
Still confident and still building the team so im happy , if we had no cash to spend and we were not making signings then i would worry but its what footy is all about
 
I'm not so sure many will argue that based on this summer. I certainly wouldn't.

Im talking about over the course of his tenure. You can't expect every signing to be bang on the money otherwise he wouldn't be our manager he would be at a bigger club.

This summer he has signed, Beckford, Gallagher, Pickford, Reach, Cunningham, Doyle, Keane, Vermijl and May not exactly bad business as Doyle and May still need to get their feet under the carpet. The only one I wouldn't have here out of those lot is Vermijl and he doesn't seem interested.
 
I doubt we will sack Grayson even if we go down, no point getting on the sacking race game. With what he has achieved in nearly 3 years I think he should be afforded some time.

It's a tricky one.

If we were to go back down, Grayson would be without doubt the man to take us back up.

But would TH let us go down again, after it took us 4 long years to come back up ? Plus it's an extra 4 million a year at this level for TV money, so there is a lot of money at stake. I think if the threat of relegation becomes real we might make a change.

I'd have every confidence in Grayson to take us back up if we went down, but I think we need to aspire to be a solid championship team, not a yo-yo club.

Hopefully Grayson can prove to be the man to help us consolidate at this level, but we need to start picking up points pretty soon.
 
It's a tricky one.

If we were to go back down, Grayson would be without doubt the man to take us back up.

But would TH let us go down again, after it took us 4 long years to come back up ? Plus it's an extra 4 million a year at this level for TV money, so there is a lot of money at stake. I think if the threat of relegation becomes real we might make a change.

I'd have every confidence in Grayson to take us back up if we went down, but I think we need to aspire to be a solid championship team, not a yo-yo club.

Hopefully Grayson can prove to be the man to help us consolidate at this level, but we need to start picking up points pretty soon.

Whats more risky, changing manager in the hope we don't go down or going down and keeping a manager who has proven with this club and others he knows how to get out of the division?
 
This summer he has signed, Beckford, Gallagher, Pickford, Reach, Cunningham, Doyle, Keane, Vermijl and May not exactly bad business as Doyle and May still need to get their feet under the carpet. The only one I wouldn't have here out of those lot is Vermijl and he doesn't seem interested.

+1

Out of the others, I think Will Keane could've shown more in the decent amount of game time that he's had so far, but I'm confident he will come good.


Whats more risky, changing manager in the hope we don't go down or going down and keeping a manager who has proven with this club and others he knows how to get out of the division?

Not sure, that's why it's a tricky one to call !

A lot would depend on who was available, but I doubt we could attract many proven Championship managers at this moment in time.
 
Might be a coincidence but we have suffered results wise since Gallagher substained his injury.

Hurry up back Gally!
 
This summer he has signed, Beckford, Gallagher, Pickford, Reach, Cunningham, Doyle, Keane, Vermijl and May not exactly bad business as Doyle and May still need to get their feet under the carpet.

It helps if you play the players you've signed, particularly the ones signed to make a difference in the goals scored column!

Grayson's faith in Garner has been misplaced and backfired. I wonder how he would justify to Hemmings having a £1 million signing (massive fee for us) sat on the bench? Also Doyle, who is a great player and can make a difference. Against Derby he made the pathetic excuse that they weren't familiar with the way we play, and that was after 2 weeks training during the international break ?? Then he throws Reach straight into the team on Saturday and he's only been here 5 minutes??

I'm not interested in how Bristol and MKD are doing either. They are not the yardstick we should be judging our season against and neither is comparison with their poor season an excuse for our poor season.

In my opinion Grayson has made a lot of mistakes already this season, with his team selections, formations and tactics. You need to score more than the opposition to win games and build up points. Trying to sit on a 1-0 lead or squeeze out a draw in this league will not work - the opposition players, managers and tactics are too savvy for that.

On Saturday at least we had a go and attacked Wolves, playing with a back 4 instead of that negative back 5 (and yes it is a back 5, it's not a midfield 5!). But is the absence of Huntington the only reason he played 4 at the back on Saturday? Or was it out of choice rather than necessity?

No excuses and no sentiment. It's imperative that we stay up and we need results.
 
Last edited:
I think you're being on harsh on Garner.

He's not had any service all season like the rest of the strikers which is why none of them have scored in the league. He's had the most shots out of anyone in the league.

Yes, Saturdays incident was a bit daft but on another day that could been a yellow card and a strong warning.
 
It helps if you play the players you've signed, particularly the ones signed to make a difference in the goals scored column!

Grayson's faith in Garner has been misplaced and backfired. I wonder how he would justify to Hemmings having a £1 million signing (massive fee for us) sat on the bench? Also Doyle, who is a great player and can make a difference. Against Derby he made the pathetic excuse that they weren't familiar with the way we play, and that was after 2 weeks training during the international break ?? Then he throws Reach straight into the team on Saturday and he's only been here 5 minutes??

I'm not interested in how Bristol and MKD are doing either. They are not the yardstick we should be judging our season against and neither is comparison with their poor season an excuse for our poor season.

In my opinion Grayson has made a lot of mistakes already this season, with his team selections, formations and tactics. You need to score more than the opposition to win games and build up points. Trying to sit on a 1-0 lead or squeeze out a draw in this league will not work - the opposition players, managers and tactics are too savvy for that.

On Saturday at least we had a go and attacked Wolves, playing with a back 4 instead of that negative back 5 (and yes it is a back 5, it's not a midfield 5!). But is the absence of Huntington the only reason he played 4 at the back on Saturday? Or was it out of choice rather than necessity?

No excuses and no sentiment. It's imperative that we stay up and we need results.

It's definitely about time those new strikers were given a go.

Garner and Keane have had plenty of game time now without scoring. The service clearly hasn't been amazing, but how long do you wait for them to make an impact, when we have 2 new strikers(one who cost nearly 1 million) + young & hungry Hugill on the bench clearly desperate to play ?

As for the excuses after Derby, they were pathetic. Vermijl started at wing back vs Boro instead of Humphrey, having signed only 2 or 3 days before. Reach started vs Wolves with the deal only being agreed late last week. He knew he should've started them that day and imo he showed Derby too much respect.
 
Last edited:
more than happy for Doyle and May to be given a run out and then use Hugill as an impact sub as I don't think he could last a full game at the moment. Reckon those 2 could prove to a be a strong partnership, especially with May wanting to prove something to Sheff Wed
 
I'm not convinced we will get anything more than maybe a single point from those away games. However, the home games are winnable.

I think what we have learned so far is that in the games that on paper are winnable, we really have to go for it. Our approach to Rotherham away was a joke and I'm sure the management now regret playing for and getting a 0-0. To be fair, I think that message has got through and the approach against Wolves, a winnable game, was very positive. Had it not been for the madness of Kettle we would have won the game in a canter. We must continue with that mentality from now on in. In this league no team is going to gift you the points, you have to go and earn it by having a right go.
 
Back
Top