Skip to main content

Over Cautious Grayson

Over Cautious Grayson

Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
639
Location
Bamber Bridge
Right, I was going to post a thread titled this after the Ipswich game but I held off until tonight.

I like Grayson but is his negative style of play going to work in the championship?
We have no flair or any real tempo which is required to compete in this league. The system is wrong for me. Whole team sat far to deep. 4-4-2 AT HOME please Grayson. Constantly inviting pressure on us all the time.

Another team would have beat us 7-1 tonight if the chances were taken.

2 players with good attitudes who don't have the ability to compete in the championship unfortunately:
Huntington - needs dropping, dire distribution in fact none at all.
Humphrey - not much better than David Amoo. Always misses in front of goal.

Both good in league 1 though.

2 more oints dropped tonight due to negative formation. Bristol City looked good because we allowed them to be. Not good enough.
 
He is tactically inept ,

Are we playing 5 4 or 3 at the back ?

3 2 or 1 up front

Kilkenny and Welsh in a 3 man midfield is suicide

No good without Gallagher ! Where was the signings

No game plan, players are like strangers HOOF to garner is not good enough

We where bossed in midfield all game but he did nothing to change it
 
I thought he played a more attacking team tonight than Saturday against Derby. I think you right about Huntington, his distribution along with Bailey Wrights was awful from the back tonight. The other problem we have is we have no decent right back and no left winger. We've a long way to go to turn a good league one side into a Championship outfit and it won't happen overnight. Stevie May ran his socks off and put a shift in. I'd say it was a point gained tonight as they had several chances they should have scored and without pickfords saves we would have lost by 3 or 4.
 
Right, I was going to post a thread titled this after the Ipswich game but I held off until tonight.

I like Grayson but is his negative style of play going to work in the championship?
We have no flair or any real tempo which is required to compete in this league. The system is wrong for me. Whole team sat far to deep. 4-4-2 AT HOME please Grayson. Constantly inviting pressure on us all the time.

Another team would have beat us 7-1 tonight if the chances were taken.

2 players with good attitudes who don't have the ability to compete in the championship unfortunately:
Huntington - needs dropping, dire distribution in fact none at all.
Humphrey - not much better than David Amoo. Always misses in front of goal.

Both good in league 1 though.

2 more oints dropped tonight due to negative formation. Bristol City looked good because we allowed them to be. Not good enough.

You have to play with the available players and match the opposition. 352 was the better formation tonight since it allowed Humphrey and Cunningham to play the wing back role and they were amongst our more effective players. When we went 433 they found the spare man coming forward and exploited the space to create the goal and their chances.

Our problem up front is creating a new pairing and relying on Joe who's on a barren run. Gally for Kilkenny in that starting team and it gives us far more tactical flexibility to change it during games.
 
Right, I was going to post a thread titled this after the Ipswich game but I held off until tonight.

I like Grayson but is his negative style of play going to work in the championship?
We have no flair or any real tempo which is required to compete in this league. The system is wrong for me. Whole team sat far to deep. 4-4-2 AT HOME please Grayson. Constantly inviting pressure on us all the time.

Another team would have beat us 7-1 tonight if the chances were taken.

2 players with good attitudes who don't have the ability to compete in the championship unfortunately:
Huntington - needs dropping, dire distribution in fact none at all.
Humphrey - not much better than David Amoo. Always misses in front of goal.

Both good in league 1 though.

2 more oints dropped tonight due to negative formation. Bristol City looked good because we allowed them to be. Not good enough.

7-1? Fuckin hell. Grayson out.
 
Right, I was going to post a thread titled this after the Ipswich game but I held off until tonight.

I like Grayson but is his negative style of play going to work in the championship?
We have no flair or any real tempo which is required to compete in this league. The system is wrong for me. Whole team sat far to deep. 4-4-2 AT HOME please Grayson. Constantly inviting pressure on us all the time.

Another team would have beat us 7-1 tonight if the chances were taken.

2 players with good attitudes who don't have the ability to compete in the championship unfortunately:
Huntington - needs dropping, dire distribution in fact none at all.
Humphrey - not much better than David Amoo. Always misses in front of goal.

Both good in league 1 though.

2 more oints dropped tonight due to negative formation. Bristol City looked good because we allowed them to be. Not good enough.

Huntington yes, Humphrey are you mad? There left wing back Bryan had zero input on the game until Humphrey was taken off, within 10 minutes of Humphrey going off they score add to that the numerous crosses and dangerous balls the lad put in, before that Bryan was non-existent.

Clarke needs putting out of his misery at RB, he isn't good enough there either start Calum Woods or sign someone.

I forgot as well bringing on a striker is negative.
 
More than a tactical mistake I think,

New Right and left back any better than giving laird and wiseman decent contracts for 2 years ? They had the physical attributes for the championship and it's quite debatable if they have been improved on.

Is woods injured ?

Not signing a dominant ball playing midfielder maybe two in the summer, we have good enough strikers but are already seeing them cut of with a scarce supply as our midfield bless em bar Johnson and Welsh ain't up to this standard.

Going what appeared to be 4 3 3 with the subs when they were being kept at bay, probably could and should have cost us the game, Pickford should get a bonus for ensuring the one point.
 
More than a tactical mistake I think,

New Right and left back any better than giving laird and wiseman decent contracts for 2 years ? They had the physical attributes for the championship and it's quite debatable if they have been improved on.

Is woods injured ?

Not signing a dominant ball playing midfielder maybe two in the summer, we have good enough strikers but are already seeing them cut of with a scarce supply as our midfield bless em bar Johnson and Welsh ain't up to this standard.

Going what appeared to be 4 3 3 with the subs when they were being kept at bay, probably could and should have cost us the game, Pickford should get a bonus for ensuring the one point.

Interesting comment on DJ. After Saturday's MOM performance posters were selling him for millions. From hero to zero in 48 hours? I don't think so. He ran out of steam and had too much space to cover chasing the game.
 
You have to play with the available players and match the opposition. 352 was the better formation tonight since it allowed Humphrey and Cunningham to play the wing back role and they were amongst our more effective players. When we went 433 they found the spare man coming forward and exploited the space to create the goal and their chances.

Our problem up front is creating a new pairing and relying on Joe who's on a barren run. Gally for Kilkenny in that starting team and it gives us far more tactical flexibility to change it during games.
our problem is negative tactics, this comment from a Bristol Fan tonight:

=Kaiser-BCFC;2157569]after you went ahead, you then seemed to noticeably pull back 20 yards and play like the away side as if to preserve the 1-0?
You could see our goal coming because you seemed to let us play in your half?

Then you had a go again at 1-1?!
 
Right, I was going to post a thread titled this after the Ipswich game but I held off until tonight.

I like Grayson but is his negative style of play going to work in the championship?
We have no flair or any real tempo which is required to compete in this league. The system is wrong for me. Whole team sat far to deep. 4-4-2 AT HOME please Grayson. Constantly inviting pressure on us all the time.

Another team would have beat us 7-1 tonight if the chances were taken.

2 players with good attitudes who don't have the ability to compete in the championship unfortunately:
Huntington - needs dropping, dire distribution in fact none at all.
Humphrey - not much better than David Amoo. Always misses in front of goal.

Both good in league 1 though.

2 more oints dropped tonight due to negative formation. Bristol City looked good because we allowed them to be. Not good enough.

The trouble is that Grayson will see switching to 4-3-3 tonight as trying to put us on the footfront and it backfiring so his negative mindset will only be reinforced. It was a great strike from Kilkenny but other than a wonder effort like that we were never going to score in a month of Sundays. Cunningham and Humphrey as wing backs in a 3-5-2 like tonight is probably as good as it gets on the flanks for us at the moment with our lack of a decent right back and zero wingers of Championship standard. However, there's little end product from Humphrey despite his decent runs and effort, while Clarke, Huntington and Wright only seem to complete a pass when it's going sideways or backwards. We look so slow and pedestrian compared to other sides at this level. The midfield is just non-existent. Other teams only have to stop Johnson from getting on the ball and that's us pretty much spent as a creative unit. I'd like to see Browne or Brownhill given a run in the side instead of Kilkenny (despite the goal tonight) - we simply can't accommodate Welsh and Kilkenny alongside each other in a three man midfield and Brownhill impressed against Crewe and Watford. We need to try something different, we're going down playing as we did tonight and Saturday.

The lack of transfer business in the summer, coupled with the questionable use of the loan market (certainly Vermijl and to a lesser extent Keane, for whom the jury's still out, look like a waste of time) has me worried. Grayson's dour, negative tactics are bearable scraping wins in League 1 but the same approach against sides in the Championship, where we're only too willing to sit back, even at home, and invite pressure from players of decent quality, is asking for trouble and is absolutely dreadful to watch.

We look like a League 1 side with a League 1 manager. All concerned look out of their depth but I'm not sure even if you put someone like Eddie Howe in charge of this paper thin squad, offering such feeble width or creativity, that it would be possible to galvanise us into an attacking force capable of competing at this level. Whether the blame lies with Ridsdale, Hemmings, Grayson or all three, we look shockingly ill equipped for the demands of Championship football. It looks like it's going to be a long, hard slog and I really wonder where the wins we're likely to need to survive will come from if we can't beat Rotherham or Bristol City. And let's be honest, taking a point tonight was daylight robbery. If it had been PNE 1 Bristol City 5 we could have had no complaints. It was as bad as watching a Westley side in terms of entertainment value tonight - a complete waste of an evening and simply not good enough in almost every aspect of our play, excluding the goalkeeper.

On current evidence, we will need a miracle to stay up and Grayson will need a miracle to still be our manager come May.
 
Last edited:
The trouble is that Grayson will see switching to 4-3-3 tonight as trying to put us on the footfront and it backfiring so his negative mindset will only be reinforced. It was a great strike from Kilkenny but other than a wonder effort like that we were never going to score in a month of Sundays. Cunningham and Humphrey as wing backs in a 3-5-2 like tonight is probably as good as it gets on the flanks for us at the moment with our lack of a decent right back and zero wingers of Championship standard. However, there's little end product from Humphrey despite his decent runs and effort, while Clarke, Huntington and Wright only seem to complete a pass when it's going sideways or backwards. We look so slow and pedestrian compared to other sides at this level. The midfield is just non-existent. Other teams only have to stop Johnson from getting on the ball and that's us pretty much spent as a creative unit. I'd like to see Browne or Brownhill given a run in the side instead of Kilkenny (despite the goal tonight) - we simply can't accommodate Welsh and Kilkenny alongside each other in a three man midfield and Brownhill impressed against Crewe and Watford. We need to try something different.

The lack of transfer business in the summer, coupled with the questionable use of the loan market (certainly Vermijl and to a lesser extent Keane, for whom the jury's still out, look like a waste of time) has me worried. Grayson's dour, negative tactics are bearable scraping wins in League 1 but the same approach against sides in the Championship, where we're only too willing to sit back, even at home, and invite pressure from players of decent quality, is asking for trouble and is absolutely dreadful to watch.

We look like a League 1 side with a League 1 manager. All concerned look out of their depth but I'm not sure even if you put someone like Eddie Howe in charge of this paper thin squad, offering such feeble width or creativity, that it would be possible to galvanise us into an attacking force capable of competing at this level. Whether the blame lies with Ridsdale, Hemmings, Grayson or all three, we look shockingly ill equipped for the demands of Championship football. It looks like it's going to be a long, hard slog and I really wonder where the wins we're likely to need to survive will come from if we can't beat Rotherham or Bristol City. And let's be honest, taking a point tonight was daylight robbery. If it had been PNE 1 Bristol City 5 we could have had no complaints. It was as bad as watching a Westley side in terms of entertainment value tonight - a complete waste of an evening and simply not good enough in almost every aspect of our play, excluding the goalkeeper.

I agree with some of things you say, but Rome wasn't built in a day.

Grayson has identified the weaknesses in the squad from day 1 and gone around slowly building a better team/squad.

Hopefully he will identify our lack of pace and width in January with a quality of signing or two with the money that is supposedly available.

You cant expect him to go up a division with this squad and then suddenly start ripping it to pieces they have to be given the opportunity like Brentford, Wolves and Bournemouth have done in the past.

I trust in him to identify the very evident weaknesses in the squad going forward. If not and we find ourselves really struggling the foundations are there to be built on.
 
We finished the game playing 4-3-3, if anything we pushed too many players forward and paid for it because they exploited the space left behind them. The idea behind bringing the extra striker on was clearly to force them back and stop them from playing the ball out from the back. It didn't work and as a result the defence and midfield were pushed back as they came forward. They had too much pace in the side for us, similar to Rotherham in the play offs.

The lack of tempo is a problem, we don't move the ball quick enough because we have three players on the pitch, all at the back who aren't good enough on the ball at this level, Huntington lumps it too often, Clarke takes too long on the ball and goes long too often, Wright's passing isn't the most accurate and he goes long a lot himself. Once the ball goes to them everything slows down and we get forced backwards, doesn't help that those in front of them don't show for the ball often enough either, if we're going to play through midfield with them in the side they need easy passes available.

If we're going to play 4-4-2, who plays out wide? Who plays at right back? We have one wide player that if we're being honest is good enough for this level in Gallagher. Clarke isn't a full back, Vermijl has struggled so far this season and Grayson doesn't seem to want to play Woods either. We can't just say play 4-4-2 and quote Mike Bassett if we don't have the players available for it, the system has to fit the players we have and the game situation, if that's 3-5-2, 4-5-1, 4-3-3, 4-4-2 or whatever other formations you want to come up with so be it.

I don't think we were quite as bad tonight as people are making out, we finished the game terribly and panicked as they came on to us, but we had chances of our own earlier on and the first 70 minutes we played ok, then went to pieces for the last 20. Bristol City looked good because they're a good side, both sides were fighting for promotion last season, we edged them out at their place, then a hard fought draw at Deepdale in April, don't see why anyone would expect us to roll them over. It was always likely to be a close game, in the end they were the better side tonight and had chances to win it late on, but until then they didn't really open us up.

Clearly we aren't the finished article yet, we got promoted a few months ago, there's several players in the squad that need to be replaced by better versions of them and positions that need to be improved on. But that will take time, not just a single transfer window, because we don't have the money to do it and it would be dangerous too, there's only so many changes that can be made without risking a loss of unity within the squad and on the pitch. Rotherham tried it last season and almost got relegated, they were lucky that Blackpool were so shit that one of the three relegation places was taken up at the start of the season.

For now I would go 4-4-2 but we can't do it until Gallagher's fit again because we haven't got anyone to play wide left unless we bring Reid in out of the cold. But an injury in any of a few positions and we'll have to change it because we don't have enough depth in the squad to cover.

Pickford

Woods
Huntington
Wright
Cunningham

Humphrey
Welsh
Johnson
Gallagher

Garner
May

Looking at that side it's clear that there's a lot of work to do, we need a centre half that's comfortable on the ball, a right back and a right winger, none of whom are likely to come cheap, along with improving the depth of the squad in general and adding some pace into the side that we're badly missing. That will probably take a couple of seasons to do if we want to get it right, in the meantime the priority has to be to get to 50 points and make sure we're in this division next season, that will allow us to spend a bit more, contracts will come to an end freeing up space in the budget and we can continue to improve the squad. Improvement will come gradually, not overnight and it will require patience, this season is likely to be a long hard slog, it won't be pretty, we will lose games to better sides with bigger budgets than us and at times we will look out of our depth, but if come May we're 21st in the table it will do. The reality is that we aren't a big club at this level and if like tonight, we can only get 9,600 home fans through the gate, which is fairly pathetic to be honest, it's going to be very difficult for us to push on unless Hemmings invests a significant amount of money in the club.
 
I agree with some of things you say, but Rome wasn't built in a day.

Grayson has identified the weaknesses in the squad from day 1 and gone around slowly building a better team/squad.

Hopefully he will identify our lack of pace and width in January with a quality of signing or two with the money that is supposedly available.

You cant expect him to go up a division with this squad and then suddenly start ripping it to pieces they have to be given the opportunity like Brentford, Wolves and Bournemouth have done in the past.

I trust in him to identify the very evident weaknesses in the squad going forward. If not and we find ourselves really struggling the foundations are there to be built on.

He hasn't built a better team though has he really
 
Back
Top