Skip to main content

Overrated players!

Overrated players!

Joined
Oct 26, 2012
Messages
10,068
Huntington - only any good when the game is in front of him, can be very poor once play is out wide. Lacks awareness of what is going on behind him.

Laird - too slow and one-footed. Not a great defender and not quick enough to play wingback. Good delivery but usually only from a stationary ball. takes too long to get h ball out from under his feet.

Humphrey, once he is stationary up against the defender then he might as well just hand him the ball. Fine when running at people but give him the ball when he is stood still and he is a complete waste of time.

Where is Hayhurst?
 
In my opinion Welsh and Buchanan are our most over rated players. They are also rightly not playing.
 
hayhurst is currently holidaying in the canary islands. Centre midfield is not good enough. No creativity in there. For me all our centre midfielders can shag off because they are useless. No desire today for me. No desire to close shots and crosses down etc. Wake up call for all you fans out there!
 
In my opinion Welsh and Buchanan are our most over rated players. They are also rightly not playing.

Though Welsh is down to final 3 for North West L1 player of the season, an award won by Buchanan. But of course we always win when Welsh doesn't start!
 
Though Welsh is down to final 3 for North West L1 player of the season, an award won by Buchanan. But of course we always win when Welsh doesn't start!

That doesn't change the fact that they are both footballers with very limited ability. That is of course only my opinion though.
 
Huntington - only any good when the game is in front of him, can be very poor once play is out wide. Lacks awareness of what is going on behind him.

Laird - too slow and one-footed. Not a great defender and not quick enough to play wingback. Good delivery but usually only from a stationary ball. takes too long to get h ball out from under his feet.

Humphrey, once he is stationary up against the defender then he might as well just hand him the ball. Fine when running at people but give him the ball when he is stood still and he is a complete waste of time.

Where is Hayhurst?

Hayhurst is on international duty.

You mention the above yet fail to mention Bryom.....
 
That doesn't change the fact that they are both footballers with very limited ability. That is of course only my opinion though.

It does maybe suggest that there are more limited players in the league though. I know football is about opinions but I genuinely can't get my head around the notion that we have better central midfielders than Welsh.
 
Hayhurst is on international duty.

You mention the above yet fail to mention Bryom.....

Because I didn't think many people rated Byrom, whereas these players all have their fans. I'm not saying they are crap, I just think they are overrated.
 
What are you banging on about over rated players for, we are in the 3rd division and struggling with what Westley has left us with, average players and from what I have seen an average manager.

You would like to think that by now the manager knows who is the best player for each position and have an alternative plan if things are not going well, nope we have some how forgotten about our second top scorer from last season and turned him into a bit player, we have also turned last years player of the year into a bit part player, our recent record signing into someone who cannot pass to a player in his own team and our English international into someone who seems to carry the whole attack on his broad shoulders with nobody able to read his flicks and passes, it is a puzzle.

We huffed and puffed today and I think Davies should have had two at the very least, there was little or no support from Humphrey, Byrom or Holmes and I just didn't understand why Holmes was played wide right when he uses his right foot for standing where either Hume or Beavon should have gone and Holmes on the left!!!

This 343 is just pish, we have no cover and little or no pace at the back, play with a man short when Byrom is on the pitch and waste the skills of both Hume and Beavon playing with 3 up front, square pegs in round holes Mr. Grayson and we know what happened to Brown Phil and his 343 or something like that!!

Grayson has been found out big time with this stupid back 3 and the lack of support they get from Byrom and Keane but seems hell bent on continuing with it, oh well it will be a bloody long drive back next week if we get humped.

Rudd

Keane
Clarke
Wright
Buchanan

Beavon
Welsh
Wroe
Holmes

Davies
Hume

Stuckmann, Humphrey, Huntington, Laird, Garner, Brownhill, Hayhurst.
 
Last edited:
Been saying it for weeks CM is a big problem.

Byrom nowhere near good enough & Keane is never a midfielder in a million month of Sundays.
 
Been saying it for weeks CM is a big problem.

Byrom nowhere near good enough & Keane is never a midfielder in a million month of Sundays.

Keane had an off day, but having said that he's not been on top form for the past couple of weeks and Byrom seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. However, I don't think Keane reverting to right-back is the answer just yet as it means switching the entire system we play.

If Keane plays right-back then which centre back do we drop? Does Buchanan or Holmes come into the team on the left or do we play Hume there, which isn't one of his strongest positions.

I'd stick with Keane and Byrom for another couple of games as we won five in a row with that partnership.
 
Keane had an off day, but having said that he's not been on top form for the past couple of weeks and Byrom seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. However, I don't think Keane reverting to right-back is the answer just yet as it means switching the entire system we play.

If Keane plays right-back then which centre back do we drop? Does Buchanan or Holmes come into the team on the left or do we play Hume there, which isn't one of his strongest positions.

I'd stick with Keane and Byrom for another couple of games as we won five in a row with that partnership.


Jesus wept, Byrom is a passenger each and every bloody game, Keane is a flat footed right back at best and NEVER a captain.
 
Keane had an off day, but having said that he's not been on top form for the past couple of weeks and Byrom seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. However, I don't think Keane reverting to right-back is the answer just yet as it means switching the entire system we play.

If Keane plays right-back then which centre back do we drop? Does Buchanan or Holmes come into the team on the left or do we play Hume there, which isn't one of his strongest positions.

I'd stick with Keane and Byrom for another couple of games as we won five in a row with that partnership.

Byrom? Wrong place ? Wrong time ?

Yeah , it's called Deepdale at 3:00 pm
 
Teams are out passing us and keeping possession far too easily against us. The problem is that the managers hands are tied with the midfield players he's inherited having long contracts. He has to make do with Byrom,Mousinho,Welsh, Wroe and Keane. These were all signed by the previous manager and would probably not have been his choice. I was really impressed with Crewe's Grant who they have picked up on a free from Stevenage. Glimmer of hope on the horizon- Josh Brownhill.
 
Keane had an off day, but having said that he's not been on top form for the past couple of weeks and Byrom seemed to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. However, I don't think Keane reverting to right-back is the answer just yet as it means switching the entire system we play.

If Keane plays right-back then which centre back do we drop? Does Buchanan or Holmes come into the team on the left or do we play Hume there, which isn't one of his strongest positions.

I'd stick with Keane and Byrom for another couple of games as we won five in a row with that partnership.

Byrom is shite. End of.

In all honesty not sure what I'd do with Keano but he can't continue there. It's killing us.
 
Hayhurst is on international duty.

You mention the above yet fail to mention Bryom.....

Correct JK

3 weak links in todays line up

Byrom 2nd to everything no creation, no desire no feckin good he is living on past displays which might have been good in his eyes but to the average fan they where just OK needs dropping to at least get him back to an OK standard

Keane sorry he might be a good stopper and bust a gut but he is a liability with the ball at his feet gave it away far to often and no support for the centre backs to win that 2nd ball hence the 2nd goal.

Hunts I;ve said before he can't play football I think he only gets a start because of his height.

So 3 weak links the big worry is they are the spine of the team in our current prefered set up of 5-3-2.

The manager needs to have a good think about this in my opinion , and rather than a massive knee jerk I would drop Byrom and play Brownhill and have a word in keanes ear!
 
What are you banging on about over rated players for, we are in the 3rd division and struggling with what Westley has left us with, average players and from what I have seen an average manager.

You would like to think that by now the manager knows who is the best player for each position and have an alternative plan if things are not going well, nope we have some how forgotten about our second top scorer from last season and turned him into a bit player, we have also turned last years player of the year into a bit part player, our recent record signing into someone who cannot pass to a player in his own team and our English international into someone who seems to carry the whole attack on his broad shoulders with nobody able to read his flicks and passes, it is a puzzle.

We huffed and puffed today and I think Davies should have had two at the very least, there was little or no support from Humphrey, Byrom or Holmes and I just didn't understand why Holmes was played wide right when he uses his right foot for standing where either Hume or Beavon should have gone and Holmes on the left!!!

This 343 is just pish, we have no cover and little or no pace at the back, play with a man short when Byrom is on the pitch and waste the skills of both Hume and Beavon playing with 3 up front, square pegs in round holes Mr. Grayson and we know what happened to Brown Phil and his 343 or something like that!!

Grayson has been found out big time with this stupid back 3 and the lack of support they get from Byrom and Keane but seems hell bent on continuing with it, oh well it will be a bloody long drive back next week if we get humped.

Rudd

Keane
Clarke
Wright
Buchanan

Beavon
Welsh
Wroe
Holmes

Davies
Hume

Stuckmann, Humphrey, Huntington, Laird, Garner, Brownhill, Hayhurst.
Sorry but Simons record shows he is an above average manager in l1
 
Sorry but Simons record shows he is an above average manager in l1

Correct, I'm I'm pretty sure the 3 teams he got promoted weren't exactly runaway league champions. Whilst finishing in the top two this season might be beyond us, the play-offs certainly aren't but to hear everyone's reaction from the past 3 games we're heading for a relegation battle.
 
Back
Top