Skip to main content

Paddy Mcarthy?

Paddy Mcarthy?

Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
17,283
Location
Cheshire
Palace are willing to Send paddy out on loan, So Is he the type of CB that we could do with Signing? ( I Know he's been injured for a While & I suspect that he wont drop to L1 anyway) I just thought that I would throw a name into the ring as a suggestion.
 
Good suggestion Keith, I'd be very happy if we signed him.
 
someone like him would be a good signing at this level but unless Palace pay all his wages there is no chance of us loaning him as i suspect we, perhaps more than any other team who should be challenging in L1, are following FFP rules the closest and we simply can't afford to bring in any more real quality players unless our income suddenly increases through something like bigger crowds or TH gifts money to the club (as i understand FFP rules allow) like owners of Bristol City, Peterborough, etc have done.
 
someone like him would be a good signing at this level but unless Palace pay all his wages there is no chance of us loaning him as i suspect we, perhaps more than any other team who should be challenging in L1, are following FFP rules the closest and we simply can't afford to bring in any more real quality players unless our income suddenly increases through something like bigger crowds or TH gifts money to the club (as i understand FFP rules allow) like owners of Bristol City, Peterborough, etc have done.

Gift would be nice!
 
Palace are willing to Send paddy out on loan, So Is he the type of CB that we could do with Signing? ( I Know he's been injured for a While & I suspect that he wont drop to L1 anyway) I just thought that I would throw a name into the ring as a suggestion.

If he hasn't played for Grayson in the past, I guess we won't be interested.......now David Fox is a different kettle of fish, and I'll be more surprised if he doesn't sign this week than if he does!
 
Dave Seddon has tweeted below a injury update on Paddy's injured knee

Dave Seddon ‏@Sedds_lep · 2 mins2 minutes ago
Paddy McCarthy's injury - has hurt his medial ligament, Simon Grayson says out for a few weeks but likely be back before loan ends
 
Sounds like were getting him fit in time to return him , we should send him back and sign someone else its a position that desperately needs attention
 
Another pointless signing. The reason we got him in was for urgent cover, now he's out for a few weeks what's the point?
 
Another pointless signing. The reason we got him in was for urgent cover, now he's out for a few weeks what's the point?

It wasn't a pointless signing, but it's pointless that we keep him and not replace him - if indeed we can I have no idea on the rules....
 
It wasn't a pointless signing, but it's pointless that we keep him and not replace him - if indeed we can I have no idea on the rules....
Of course we can.

McCarthy wasn't a "pointless signing" at all, unless people are blaming Grayson for the injury he picked up while playing for us.
 
This isn't really anyone's fault. Probably won't be needed now Wright is back and can't see Hunts being too far away. Still need cover here so expect him to come back and then keep for the remainder of the season
 
Obviously a big 'if' given his career injury record, but if we can get Paddy fit I think he is the experienced leader we have been crying out for.

We are a weak team at this level. Physically we are way off most teams and I suspect mentally as well. This lad is more imposing than those we have and he has been there and done it at this level. Captain of Palace in the past so I suspect he was brought in by Grayson to fill the absence of leader role.
 
Back
Top