Skip to main content

Paddy Mcarthy?

Paddy Mcarthy?

Send him back, the bloke has played about 15 games in three years, crock.
I don't normally criticise the signing of players as I know it can't always be easy to locate and then be able to afford good players, but all one has to do is look up McArthy's record of injuries and the writing is clearly on the wall.

Leicester City..........."dislocated shoulder whilst training".

Charlton Ath............."terrible series of shoulder injuries".........that kept him out for the best part of two seasons.

2011-2012..............."suffered groin injuries".................again severely restricted his appearances for a further two seasons.

Bolton on loan.........."just 5 appearances and then had to return (to parent club Crystal Palace) after injury".

PNE on loan............."10 minutes, and then injured".

Seriously, whoever it was that made this loan decision should put more effort into researching the player's past history, especially a 32 years old player.
 
Last edited:
I don't normally criticise the signing of players as I know it can't always be easy to locate and then be able to afford good players, but all one has to do is look up McArthy's record of injuries and the writing is clearly on the wall.

Leicester City..........."dislocated shoulder whilst training".

Charlton Ath............."terrible series of shoulder injuries".........that kept him out for the best part of two seasons.

2011-2012..............."suffered groin injuries".................again severely restricted his appearances for a further two seasons.

Bolton on loan.........."just 5 appearances and then had to return (to parent club Crystal Palace) after injury".

PNE on loan............."10 minutes, and then injured".

Seriously, whoever it was that made this loan decision should put more effort into researching the player's past history, especially a 32 years old player.


🙂 Just for a bit of balance could you tell us what he achieved in between injuries?
 
He wasn't a pointless signing. We needed a centre half ideally in the summer, and then for the Wednesday game we had only 1 available centre half so it was a priority, we needed him.

However, I would now try and send him back and bring in someone else if possible. He's a decent, experienced defender but he's been very injury prone at his last few clubs and that's now proving to be the case with us as well. He musn't have played more than 6/7 games in a row in recent years without picking up an injury which keeps him out for a while.
 
I don't normally criticise the signing of players as I know it can't always be easy to locate and then be able to afford good players, but all one has to do is look up McArthy's record of injuries and the writing is clearly on the wall.

Leicester City..........."dislocated shoulder whilst training".

Charlton Ath............."terrible series of shoulder injuries".........that kept him out for the best part of two seasons.

2011-2012..............."suffered groin injuries".................again severely restricted his appearances for a further two seasons.

Bolton on loan.........."just 5 appearances and then had to return (to parent club Crystal Palace) after injury".

PNE on loan............."10 minutes, and then injured".

Seriously, whoever it was that made this loan decision should put more effort into researching the player's past history, especially a 32 years old player.

I understand that Wikipedia is widely available throughout our scouting network too.

I suppose that's about as near as you ever get to a potential new signing though.
 
Still waiting for that list of 10 consecutive defeats under Craig Brown's managership........it is taking you quite some time isn't it?
Probably thinking of the 1 win in 10 run (including 6 defeats in a row) in the middle of 2002/03?

Or the 1 win in 13 at the end of 2003/04?
 
Johnny Cochran, defence lawyer, OJ Simpson trial.
Yes, ironically, you're using a famous travesty of justice to defend a famous travesty of a managerial "reputation"... 😉 😀
 
Back
Top