Skip to main content

Pearson V Welsh....

Pearson V Welsh....

Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
5,655
Location
sherwood
Sorry but John Welsh for me every time. Ben has the knack of looking busy, but he cant break play up, and his distribution is average at best. JW is getting a raw deal IMHO. We look very lightweight in the middle and where the fcuk was Browne all night. Now the play offs are well and truly buried, SG needs to sort the middle out. Boro away give JW a start, lets get stuck in from the start.... don't waste these last few games, lets try and dominate the key areas of the pitch.
 
Last edited:
Sorry but John Welsh for me every time. Ben has the knack of looking busy, but he cant break play up, and his distribution is average at best. JW is getting a raw deal IMHO. We look very lightweight in the middle and where the fcuk was Browne all night. Know the play offs are well buried, SG needs to sort the middle out. Boro away give JW a start, lets get stuck in from the start.... don't waste these last few games, lets try and dominate the key areas of the pitch.
i think we need Welsh on bench if he not starting
 
John Welsh can tackle and... Now I'm struggling. I've seen people ask "what must he do to get a game?" - well, the simple answer is to drop down a league. That's where he belongs im afraid. He's been a good servant for us, but for me it's probably time for his exit this summer.
 
John Welsh can tackle and... Now I'm struggling. I've seen people ask "what must he do to get a game?" - well, the simple answer is to drop down a league. That's where he belongs im afraid. He's been a good servant for us, but for me it's probably time for his exit this summer.

+1
 
Of the two, Pearson is the far superior technical footballer.

John Welsh gives you a lot of sliding around, hacking and a guaranteed yellow card, Pearson gives you some ball playing ability and offers something at both ends of the pitch, as a central midfielder should do.

Welsh is far nearer the end of his career than the beginning, has tried the Championship before, and dropped out and has virtually no sell on value which will only depreciate as each game passes by. He'll most likely be moved on in the summer. Contrast that with Pearson who is at the beginning of his career, has eye-catching potential, and some considerable sell on value.

Pearson V Welsh? Pearson every time.
 
John Welsh can tackle and... Now I'm struggling. I've seen people ask "what must he do to get a game?" - well, the simple answer is to drop down a league. That's where he belongs im afraid. He's been a good servant for us, but for me it's probably time for his exit this summer.

How quick we forget...JW won the 50/50 ball that got us the first goal at Wembley, he wanted it, and he won it....he's a fighter. We lack that fighter spirit in our lightweight midfield set up at this present time.. Just my opinion, but I would put him before Ben at this present time. We need to have some steel in the midfield on Sat at Boro.
 
Pearson was excellent second half tonight, yet he's bemoaned by those who miss the subtlety of his game. Moves the ball quickly, comitted and positionally aware. Welsh, whilst a superb professional and great PNE player who will be fondly remembered, has offered little other than a crunching tackle on Danny Batth this season. Still rate the guy but he's not the player we need in the long run
 
John Welsh is shite

Each to their own, but I just can't help thinking about that tackle/pass at Wembley where he set up our 2nd. Proper 'body on the line' stuff. Yeah, I know you can't live in the past, but that is a definitive moment in that game for me. Was brave and exceptionally skillful and after seeing that happen, I will never criticise him.

Unless I really have to, and at the moment, I don't think it's valid.
 
How quick we forget...JW won the 50/50 ball that got us the first goal at Wembley, he wanted it, and he won it....he's a fighter. We lack that fighter spirit in our lightweight midfield set up at this present time.. Just my opinion, but I would put him before Ben at this present time. We need to have some steel in the midfield on Sat at Boro.

I'd certainly have Welsh in on Saturday but in place of Browne rather than Pearson. Welsh may be nearing the end of his shelf life as a Championship player, certainly as a regular, but there are still games when his inclusion can be useful. He is still by far the best tackler in the squad.
 
Each to their own, but I just can't help thinking about that tackle/pass at Wembley where he set up our 2nd. Proper 'body on the line' stuff. Yeah, I know you can't live in the past, but that is a definitive moment in that game for me. Was brave and exceptionally skillful and after seeing that happen, I will never criticise him.

Unless I really have to, and at the moment, I don't think it's valid.

Fair enough, and there have been examples like you've mentioned. But I've never bought into this tackling stuff he's renowned for - for every tackle there's 4 or 5 mistimed attempts, often leaving him 2 seconds behind the game. He's not good enough, like Kilkenny, and Grayson has realised this hence bringing in Pearson and Grimshaw.

Been a good servant etc, but if we want to be competitive then we can't carry league one players, just because they're likeable.
 
How quick we forget...JW won the 50/50 ball that got us the first goal at Wembley, he wanted it, and he won it....he's a fighter. We lack that fighter spirit in our lightweight midfield set up at this present time.. Just my opinion, but I would put him before Ben at this present time. We need to have some steel in the midfield on Sat at Boro.

In what you're saying haven't you just proved Kingy's point? 'Welsh won a tackle against Nathan Byrne once,' - whoopee.

Our Midfield has stood up to be counted plenty of times this season against the likes of Sheffield Wednesday, Bolton, Blackburn, Burnely etc. and yet people seem more concerned with pouring derision on the (younger) players who have actually stepped up this year (IE, Browne, Johnson, an to a lesser extent Robinson and Pearson) and clamour to have a player who at times looked out of place in L1 reinstated in the team.

Welsh has served his purpose in doing an 'unfashionable' job in L1 - but it's time to move him on in the summer.
 
Look guys Fulham won the physical battles all over the pitch....our midfield is very lightweight, we don't have a Gregan any more, our own version is JW, we need his presence and workrate in centre mid if we are to win these crunch games. We have lost a game tonight that has now finished off any hope of the play offs.....hindsight is a wonderful thing, but we have to think ahead to next season and a powerful centre mid is a must in this league. I would play JW on Sat along side AB and see if it gives us more control linking back to front.
 
Pearson every time. He has a football brain ( sadly lacking in a number of our other players ) and he can pick a good pass to a white shirt. Not a bad skill though still not grasped by
several of his collegues.
A decent 1st half following by a very good second which should have told SG who to pick next game.
Welsh is a great bloke but his time is past here. He can run on for a short sub appearance and lunge into a few last ditch tackles ,get a booking and then having won the ball it will finish :-
1 in the stands
2 with the opposition
3 passed back to the cb or goalie
 
In what you're saying haven't you just proved Kingy's point? 'Welsh won a tackle against Nathan Byrne once,' - whoopee.

Our Midfield has stood up to be counted plenty of times this season against the likes of Sheffield Wednesday, Bolton, Blackburn, Burnely etc. and yet people seem more concerned with pouring derision on the (younger) players who have actually stepped up this year (IE, Browne, Johnson, an to a lesser extent Robinson and Pearson) and clamour to have a player who at times looked out of place in L1 reinstated in the team.

Welsh has served his purpose in doing an 'unfashionable' job in L1 - but it's time to move him on in the summer.

Bang on the money.

Fans are going to have to accept that some of our Wembley winners are going to be phased out over time as we look to improve the squad and develop our young players.

Welsh did a job in the third tier, but like Kilkenny, he has served his purpose for PNE and it's time to move on in the summer.
 
Sorry but John Welsh for me every time. Ben has the knack of looking busy, but he cant break play up, and his distribution is average at best. JW is getting a raw deal IMHO. We look very lightweight in the middle and where the fcuk was Browne all night. Now the play offs are well and truly buried, SG needs to sort the middle out. Boro away give JW a start, lets get stuck in from the start.... don't waste these last few games, lets try and dominate the key areas of the pitch.

You're a bloody good photographer.
 
I won't criticise either. John Welsh has always given his all in a white shirt and his 100% effort has often made up for what he lacks in other parts of his game. Pearson is still a boy who is leaning the game ...has bags of potential and had his best game last night.
 
Back
Top