Skip to main content

Pearson V Welsh....

Pearson V Welsh....

Using the Crawley thing to beat him up over is out of order as well really, everyone was shocking in that game and didn't we then go on a 25 game unbeaten run or something which he was a part of? Good servant, but coming to the end of his time now, to say that time was 6-9 months ago is completely incorrect.

I agree the whole team was shocking in that match but the point is that there was a time when Welsh would have driven himself on to try to rouse the rest of the team out of their torpor but he simply couldn't do it on that occasion and, frankly, since then he has only been able to do so in fits and starts. A fine player for us in the past but one whose useful time with us is now, frankly, at an end.
 
Was this the game that Johnson started on the bench as well? Can't remember what game it was when Welsh came on which seemed a odd sub at the time but he allowed pretty much both full backs and the other midfielders to bomb on and it changed the game.

Points relating to stuff you haven't quoted...

There's very few saying Welsh should be in, and basically he shouldn't. We're not scrapping around for points or trying to make games ugly, we're looking to build a squad that will improve next season and this really is the main reason why Pearson should be in over Welsh right now.

Using the Crawley thing to beat him up over is out of order as well really, everyone was shocking in that game and didn't we then go on a 25 game unbeaten run or something which he was a part of? Good servant, but coming to the end of his time now, to say that time was 6-9 months ago is completely incorrect.

Think Johnson was on the bench against Huddersfield and he came on with Welsh.

I agree Welsh was great for us last season and wasn't on the decline then. As I've said a few times in the past few posts he's been a top servant for PNE and was one of the star performers in our unbeaten run + play off victory last season.

However, as Ron Burgundy said, he is pretty much obsolete at Championship level, and we now have younger, more talented options.
 
Pearson was signed to replace Welsh, eventually. One is 21, the other is 32. At this exact point Welsh is probably better than Pearson yes, but Grayson signed him with the next few years in mind, Welsh has been a brilliant servant for us and I'll be gutted when he leaves, but the transition was put in place for this very reason
 
I agree the whole team was shocking in that match but the point is that there was a time when Welsh would have driven himself on to try to rouse the rest of the team out of their torpor but he simply couldn't do it on that occasion and, frankly, since then he has only been able to do so in fits and starts. A fine player for us in the past but one whose useful time with us is now, frankly, at an end.

I was at Crawley. The entire team were unacceptably poor. Even Jesus couldn't have raised that lot out of their torpor. I think your assessment of Welsh in the context of that game is completely and utterly wrong.
 
I was at Crawley. The entire team were unacceptably poor. Even Jesus couldn't have raised that lot out of their torpor. I think your assessment of Welsh in the context of that game is completely and utterly wrong.

For what it's worth Kilkenny did bring some composure and purpose to the side after he came on and we started to play a bit better. Gallagher also began to try to impose himself a bit more. But it was an awful experience - one that I would prefer to forget.
 
Welsh is solid but pearson for me now. Pearson has it technically whereas welsh is just abit of a hard man in midfield. We need players who can play passing football in the middle of the park if we want to go anywhere, especially with the defensive formations we play.
 
Welsh is solid but pearson for me now. Pearson has it technically whereas welsh is just abit of a hard man in midfield. We need players who can play passing football in the middle of the park if we want to go anywhere, especially with the defensive formations we play.
Seriously interesting username 🙂 🙂 🙂
 
Sorry but John Welsh for me every time. Ben has the knack of looking busy, but he cant break play up, and his distribution is average at best. JW is getting a raw deal IMHO. We look very lightweight in the middle and where the fcuk was Browne all night. Now the play offs are well and truly buried, SG needs to sort the middle out. Boro away give JW a start, lets get stuck in from the start.... don't waste these last few games, lets try and dominate the key areas of the pitch.

The past is yours but the futures mine...
 
John Welsh has been a fantastic servant to our club, and an ultimate professional. But like a similar top professional in Scott Laird last Summer, if we make Welsh available, I seriously doubt anyone in our league would sign him. Welsh is fine coming on for the last 15 minutes if you need a bit more physical presence in the middle at this level. But if he wants regular 90 minutes every week, he will need to drop a league. I'm sure he knows it as well.

I can see a lot of potential in Pearson. He's far from the finished article, but he's only 21. And this is his first crack at playing in this league, and also at a new club. He needs time to settle. Let's judge him next season when he's had a full pre season with us, and he feels more settled.
 
John Welsh has been a fantastic servant to our club, and an ultimate professional. But like a similar top professional in Scott Laird last Summer, if we make Welsh available, I seriously doubt anyone in our league would sign him. Welsh is fine coming on for the last 15 minutes if you need a bit more physical presence in the middle at this level. But if he wants regular 90 minutes every week, he will need to drop a league. I'm sure he knows it as well.

I can see a lot of potential in Pearson. He's far from the finished article, but he's only 21. And this is his first crack at playing in this league, and also at a new club. He needs time to settle. Let's judge him next season when he's had a full pre season with us, and he feels more settled.

I'm sure he'd jump at the chance of joining Bury / Rochdale / Oldham (if they stay up) and he deserves to have that final chance of 2-3 years of regular starting football.

Didn't realise he'd played 8 times for England U21's...
 
I'm sure he'd jump at the chance of joining Bury / Rochdale / Oldham (if they stay up) and he deserves to have that final chance of 2-3 years of regular starting football.

Didn't realise he'd played 8 times for England U21's...

I could see Welsh at Sheff United. Massive underachievers.

Just the type of player that they require.
 
They were interested in him prior to him signing a new deal. Bury or Rochdale would be decent moves for him given where he lives.

Has he moved recently, because he keeps saying that he lives in Merseyside from what I've read on his Twitter page & in his interviews?
 
Now the play offs are well and truly buried

Correct, we aren't, barring a miracle, getting into the play-offs.

We are also mathematically safe, so we can start planning for next season....

...which is exactly why we should be giving young lads such as Pearson even more game time with a view to next season, not dropping him for a 32 year old.
 
Correct, we aren't, barring a miracle, getting into the play-offs.

We are also mathematically safe, so we can start planning for next season....

...which is exactly why we should be giving young lads such as Pearson even more game time with a view to next season, not dropping him for a 32 year old.

Spot on mate, and if we're seriously interested in signing the likes of Vermaijl, Doyle & Robinson we should also be giving them more game time as well.
 
Back
Top