Skip to main content

Penalties

Penalties

Joined
Jan 6, 2011
Messages
2,032
Hugill missed fair enough it happens. And to be fair surely your striker should always step up. But who is our designated penalty taker?

As soon as Jordan had the ball I was worried. McGeady would have simply Rabona'd it into the top corner. Horgan would have hidden behind the ball so the keeper couldn't see him and pelly-wanged it into the bottom corner and Huntington the Cumbrian Cannavaro would have hammered it down the middle. So why did Hugill take it?

Nice One.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Lack of thinking re the penalty as well, surely they realised it was Gilks debut? No keeper will stand still for a penalty on their debut, should of hammered it straight down the middle as he was always going to dive. Same rule for penalty 5 in a shoot out. Keepers want the headlines.
 
Hugill missed fair enough it happens. And to be fair surely your striker should always step up. But who is our designated penalty taker?

As soon as Jordan had the ball I was worried. McGeady would have simply Rabona'd it into the top corner. Horgan would have hidden behind the ball so the keeper couldn't see him and pelly-wanged it into the bottom corner and Huntington the Cumbrian Cannavaro would have hammered it down the middle. So why did Hugill take it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I've not seen it,did Jordan look nervous,seems to be a lot of fuss on other threads,it's a pen,it should go in,but it's not guaranteed,nothing ever is.
 
I've not seen it,did Jordan look nervous,seems to be a lot of fuss on other threads,it's a pen,it should go in,but it's not guaranteed,nothing ever is.

No. He didn't look nervous. It was just dreadful. Especially as he got 2 bites at it.

Nice One.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I'm sure Gallagher is our penalty taker. Hugill had been practising all week according to Grayson. Should have been McGeady for me.
 
2 penalty misses in the space of 15 minutes has seriously dented our chances of reaching the play offs.

Penalty 1. Hugill missed penalty on 10 mins. If it is scored it's a completely different game and one that we'd probably have won. The miss ultimately has cost us 2 points.

Penalty 2. Ross McCormack misses a penalty for Notts Forest v Sheffield Wednesday. SW then go up the other end and score. Again, McCormack scores it's a completely different game. The miss allowed Wednesday to take all 3 points.

A win for us and Forest would have put us 4 points behind SW as opposed to 9.
 
All players miss penalties - I believe the great Sir Tom once did as well. Gallagher is our designated penalty taker. But in his absence and from the players we started with today I would hazard a guess that Cunningham and then Horgan would be our best bet from the spot.
 
Maybe we should have kept Grezza on indefinitely....put him on the bench and just bring him on to take penalties🙂
 
Last edited:
2 penalty misses in the space of 15 minutes has seriously dented our chances of reaching the play offs.

Penalty 1. Hugill missed penalty on 10 mins. If it is scored it's a completely different game and one that we'd probably have won. The miss ultimately has cost us 2 points.

Penalty 2. Ross McCormack misses a penalty for Notts Forest v Sheffield Wednesday. SW then go up the other end and score. Again, McCormack scores it's a completely different game. The miss allowed Wednesday to take all 3 points.

A win for us and Forest would have put us 4 points behind SW as opposed to 9.

So a penalty in another game ends our season....!...?
 
Ffs,we get a hard won point,away at pie munchers,off our game,you all start crying,GROW upp,we are ok.
 
Lack of thinking re the penalty as well, surely they realised it was Gilks debut? No keeper will stand still for a penalty on their debut, should of hammered it straight down the middle as he was always going to dive. Same rule for penalty 5 in a shoot out. Keepers want the headlines.

Two points here, first being, if anyone was thinking Hugill would not have taken it, second is all the thinking about keeper on debut, keepers wanting the headlines, do you really think Hugill is such a deep thinker because he strikes me as just the opposite. No disrespect, young fellah at the peak of his career so far, bagged a few goals so give it me I will have a bash,no analysis no weighing the job up bish bosh,job done or undone in this case.
Hugill is at his best when he has no time to think about it !!
I will finish by saying, he runs his socks off, he has had a great season, but looked jaded in the last few games.
 
Two points here, first being, if anyone was thinking Hugill would not have taken it, second is all the thinking about keeper on debut, keepers wanting the headlines, do you really think Hugill is such a deep thinker because he strikes me as just the opposite. No disrespect, young fellah at the peak of his career so far, bagged a few goals so give it me I will have a bash,no analysis no weighing the job up bish bosh,job done or undone in this case.
Hugill is at his best when he has no time to think about it !!
I will finish by saying, he runs his socks off, he has had a great season, but looked jaded in the last few games.

Looked very tired Tuesday night , was surprised he wasn't subbed much earlier Tuesday . As regards the penalty today deserves tons of slack , he hasn't hit somebody doing his job . Does it week in week out without the slightest emotional eruption . And he gives his all . He isn't no messi , but he's our Jordan hugill , so support him
 
Was a very poor penalty, but matched the overall performance of most of the team. I have always believed that pens should be taken by the more technical type of player. With Gally and Johnson not on the pitch and Robinson out of form, i would have expected McGeady, Horgan or Pearson to take it.
 
If there isn't a regular penalty taker on the pitch, I would expect someone to step up and absolutely leather it. Even if it is hammered straight at the keeper it would take some stopping.
 
Penalties

As you probably know I'm not his biggest fan, but I accept that everyone misses penalties. Gallagher has done before. It's the follow up that bothered me - he had all the bloody Goal to aim at! None of this "it was slightly behind him"; he connected with it well, he just hit it straight at the keeper, which seems to be his speciality.
 
As you probably know I'm not his biggest fan, but I accept that everyone misses penalties. Gallagher has done before. It's the follow up that bothered me - he had all the bloody Goal to aim at! None of this "it was slightly behind him"; he connected with it well, he just hit it straight at the keeper, which seems to be his speciality.
I said earlier, that miss from the rebound was a worse miss than the penalty- another one v one that he has fluffed. I thought he was going to leave the rebound for Horgan, who was actually in a better position because he was running onto the ball, while hugill had to kind of scoop it from slightly behind himself. Possibly inexperience, eagerness, over exuberance or just lack of composure. Either way, he is our top scorer and my view is, unless you have a penalty specialist in the side, which we didn't, always give the pen to your main man. Who at the moment is hugill.
 
I'm not a great fan of penalty takers that place their half-hit penalties to the left or right of the keeper.

There is nothing wrong in putting your head down and blasting it as long as it's on target it will go in.

If the keeper gets in the way he will probably finish up in the net with the ball.

Old timers (me included) remember Sir Alex.

If there isn't a regular penalty taker on the pitch, I would expect someone to step up and absolutely leather it. Even if it is hammered straight at the keeper it would take some stopping.
 
Back
Top