Skip to main content

Perspective

Perspective

It hasn't been the flying start to the season we might have hoped for - the defeat at Walsall was dismal and the last minute goals conceded against Doncaster and Chesterfield were uncomfortably reminiscent of last season. How close this division is, though, is underlined by the fact that if we had scraped a draw at Walsall and held on for another minute or two against Chesterfield we would have been in second place when we started the Crawley game. But teams that start off like a train often fall away badly once they lose a match - not just Leyton Orient last season and Tranmere before that but remember Stoke did the same thing before we got promoted with David Moyes - and every team will have poor run of some sort before the season is out.

Hopefully the Walsall and Chesterfield games will prove to be our blip. The key question is what lessons did we learn?

In the case of the Walsall game there seems to be a consensus that the Kilkenny-King duo in central midfield was too slow and SG seems to have recognised this by restoring the Kilkenny-Browne duo and sticking with it. That is a potentially massive step because there simply is no such thing as a successful team without a core, consistent central midfield. Browne looks like he is the player who is likely to make the difference to our midfield this season rather than Brownhill though the latter's time will come.

As for Chesterfield well even though the opposition were spirited you get the impression that the team had developed an expectation that they would concede in the last few minutes, so the importance of two clean sheets - even if the opposition didn't put us under any particular pressure - is that it may help restore some self-belief to the side.

Is SG also now recognising that Garner needs a partner and telling Gallagher to stick a bit closer? I hope so.

But we have got back-to-back league wins for the first time and another one this Saturday would give us a sense of momentum. With no league match for two weeks after we need that. I wonder if Sky are eyeing up the match against Bristol City - if we keep improving game-by-game that could be a stupendous clash.

I don't see the current obsession with a midfield pairing in a 4-4-2? We are the only team to score in every league game and are currently 3 points of second

The defence is showing signs of real solidarity, maybe that is because Buchanan has forced his way back into contention.

Garner is on 7 goals, why does he need a partner?

Lessons learned from Walsall? For me it has to be either 3 or 5 in midfield not 2.

Lessons learned from Chesterfield? Don't hand ball it in the box, Wiseman over Woods every day of the week.
 
I don't see the current obsession with a midfield pairing in a 4-4-2? We are the only team to score in every league game and are currently 3 points of second

The defence is showing signs of real solidarity, maybe that is because Buchanan has forced his way back into contention.

Garner is on 7 goals, why does he need a partner?

Lessons learned from Walsall? For me it has to be either 3 or 5 in midfield not 2.

Lessons learned from Chesterfield? Don't hand ball it in the box, Wiseman over Woods every day of the week.

Midfield - whatever the formation you need a mix of energy and guile, the Kilkenny-Browne duo seems our best bet for that.

Buchanan - solid and reliable yes, but lacking in ability going forward. We can only wait to see if Laird gets a run of a few games and makes an even greater difference.

Garner - might score even more with a partner and a centre forward who could hold the ball up would be useful for easing pressure on us late on.

Wiseman - yes agreed.
 
Great thread

On paper a front 3 of Garner, Gally and Reid wins the league. I think that is what we are working towards.

Defence looking much more settled. Ben Davies is a good youngster but his inclusion in the starting XI was too early. I also think Wiseman has to play ahead of Woods.

Performances are getting there and the players look to be grasping the 'game management' nettle. Grayson has tinkered but is gettng towards finding his best XI now.

Are we the best team in the league right now? No. But things are improving, they were never that bad to begin with, and so theres lots to be positive about.
 
Personally I feel things are looking up and we are beginning to gain some momentum after an indifferent start to the season. Bristol City will be the ones to watch for the title but I fully expect us to be in the mix come May. Coventry may have been very average but we still had to go to their stadium and get a result. I am delighted with the result as my lad is a match day mascot this Saturday. There should be a few extra on the crowd and we will hopefully see a confident team in white take the 3 points
 
Great thread

On paper a front 3 of Garner, Gally and Reid wins the league. I think that is what we are working towards.

Defence looking much more settled. Ben Davies is a good youngster but his inclusion in the starting XI was too early. I also think Wiseman has to play ahead of Woods.

Performances are getting there and the players look to be grasping the 'game management' nettle. Grayson has tinkered but is gettng towards finding his best XI now.

Are we the best team in the league right now? No. But things are improving, they were never that bad to begin with, and so theres lots to be positive about.

The whole Ben Davies situation I think has been handled well, if he had proven to be a world beater at LB then credit to Grayson, but he found it tough going so instead of destroying the lads confidence and having him sat in the stands he has sent him to a league where last year he was brilliant (apparently).

The big tests come against Bristol City, Peterborough and MK Dons. We havent hit top gear yet but are slowly going up through the gears.

Midfield - whatever the formation you need a mix of energy and guile, the Kilkenny-Browne duo seems our best bet for that.

Buchanan - solid and reliable yes, but lacking in ability going forward. We can only wait to see if Laird gets a run of a few games and makes an even greater difference.

Garner - might score even more with a partner and a centre forward who could hold the ball up would be useful for easing pressure on us late on.

Wiseman - yes agreed.

And creativity which Brownhill seems to have.

Buchanan is solid and reliable whilst Laird isn't at the back, there both chalk and cheese, Buchanan has earn the shirt and given no reasons to lose it.

Garner is scoring goals and if it isn't broke don't fix it, neither of us know whether he will score more goals with a partner, so if he is banging them in whilst playing up front on his own then fair play to him. However, the last 2 have come from the penalty spot, he did earn one of them though.
 
I myself would rather start of steady and build momentum rather than peak too soon , our problem isn't scoring goals its preventing them and now were beginning to tighten up . Buchanan were told is weak going forward but we seem to be stronger with him in the side . Wiseman could well be the missing link at the back and the goals are still going in despite all the fuss about Garner being a loan striker . Coventry were poor but did we not play our part in making them look ineffective ? were only just finding our feet after the play off disappointment hangover might be worth watching how we go on in the next 6 games before suggesting were not good enough or were playing the wrong players .
 
I don't think our for or against column looks worrying. Yes we have dropped some points and we'd be further up the league if we hadn't bla bla bla. The teams around us have also dropped points it's football.

Strong positive start to the season without setting the world alight
 
Buchanan is solid and reliable whilst Laird isn't at the back, there both chalk and cheese, Buchanan has earn the shirt and given no reasons to lose it.

This whole "Laird can't defend" theory is absolute bullshit!

He's much better than Buchanan in both departments for me.
 
This whole "Laird can't defend" theory is absolute bullshit!

He's much better than Buchanan in both departments for me.

Yup .
And he is a leader and organiser as well .
Laird should be given a good run in the side to see if he can rediscover the form that made him the best LB in the league.
 
Laird should be given a good run in the side to see if he can rediscover the form that made him the best LB in the league.
I see this suggestion a lot on the forum, and yet SG picks Buchanan when available just the same.

Isn't it possible that Laird isn't getting a run in the side because SG has already decided Laird can't rediscover that form?
 
This whole "Laird can't defend" theory is absolute bullshit!

He's much better than Buchanan in both departments for me.

Buchanan never gets beaten for me, whilst Laird can be a bit shaky and tends to over commit. Laird came unstuck a bit against Crawleys tricky number 7, Buchanan didn't before he was subbed.

I like Laird and wouldn't mind either way if was given his chance.

However, Buchanan doesn't deserve to be dropped based on the last 2 times he has played we have kept a clean sheet.
 
Buchanan never gets beaten for me, whilst Laird can be a bit shaky and tends to over commit. Laird came unstuck a bit against Crawleys tricky number 7, Buchanan didn't before he was subbed.

I like Laird and wouldn't mind either way if was given his chance.

However, Buchanan doesn't deserve to be dropped based on the last 2 times he has played we have kept a clean sheet.

Buchanan never gets beaten, come on mate, he certainly wouldn't be in league one if that was the case.
 
Buchanan never gets beaten for me, whilst Laird can be a bit shaky and tends to over commit. Laird came unstuck a bit against Crawleys tricky number 7, Buchanan didn't before he was subbed.

I like Laird and wouldn't mind either way if was given his chance.

However, Buchanan doesn't deserve to be dropped based on the last 2 times he has played we have kept a clean sheet.

I've seen Buchanan beaten numerous times, usually by anyone with an ounce of pace.

His performance at Coventry last season remains one of the worst i've seen by a PNE full back and Agard/ Tavernier absolutely destroyed him in the play-offs.

If you want promotion then you need to spread the goals and assists all over the team, Woods and Buchanan will contribute nothing to that.

That said, based on the last two games then I agree he deserves to keep his place. No point chopping and changing when you don't need to.
 
I've seen Buchanan beaten numerous times, usually by anyone with an ounce of pace.

His performance at Coventry last season remains one of the worst i've seen by a PNE full back and Agard/ Tavernier absolutely destroyed him in the play-offs.

If you want promotion then you need to spread the goals and assists all over the team, Woods and Buchanan will contribute nothing to that.

That said, based on the last two games then I agree he deserves to keep his place. No point chopping and changing when you don't need to.

Pretty much what I'd have written if I could have been arsed!

Good post.
 
we are playing a back 4, why do people want the left back to be playing left wing and scoring goals,who is mean't to be covering and marking the right winger while he his all over the pitch doing other players jobs.
 
we are playing a back 4, why do people want the left back to be playing left wing and scoring goals,who is mean't to be covering and marking the right winger while he his all over the pitch doing other players jobs.

Because a system that has overlapping attacking full backs goes a long way towards winning divisions.
 
Back
Top