Skip to main content

Phil Brown

Phil Brown

Joined
Jun 14, 2004
Messages
4,260
Location
London/Buckinghamshire
A dig at Uncle Trev...?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/39382271

Southend United manager Phil Brown will reach four years at the club when his side visit AFC Wimbledon on Saturday.

Former Derby County, Hull City and Preston boss Brown, 57, took the job at Roots Hall on 25 March 2013.

He took over with the Shrimpers in League Two, but guided them to promotion via the play-offs in 2015 and his side are now sixth in League One.

"I started off a job four years ago to prove the world of football wrong," Brown told BBC Essex.

The ex-Bolton and Hartlepool defender said he had had "to go down into the second division to get a job".

Brown had been out of management since December 2011, when he was fired by Preston, before being appointed by Southend in 2013.

He said many chairmen these days are "trigger happy", leading to "good men ending up losing their jobs".

"I'm so happy the chairman [Ron Martin] isn't influenced by the outside world as much as other chairmen are," Brown continued.

"I think if you have a good relationship with the guy up top, that is the most important thing. I firmly believe that, given time, most managers will get it right."

Brown is the 11th longest-serving manager in England's top four divisions, with under-pressure Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger top of the list having been in charge of the Gunners for more than 20 years.

"I'm hoping Arsene hangs on to his job," Brown added. "If that crumbles, unfortunately the whole mentality of the world of football will change."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A dig at Uncle Trev...?
I don't think so.

I think he's just referring to the fact he's been at Southend for four years while some other clubs have had umpteen managers in that time.
 
The problem for Brown was that he came to the club when it was hardly going well on the pitch, whilst off the pitch was in a sort of turmoil under Maurice Lindsay's tenure and that for me was a bigger issue. Not sure many managers would have fared well at PNE when he was with us giving the state the club was in.
 
If he's actually having a dig, Brown Phil has no leg to stand on. Yes he wasn't exactly helped by those above him (the sale of Keith Treacy) or lady luck (our main striking options for getting injured in quick succession), but let's just recount some of the things he did here:

He was in charge for our relegation - could argue it was too little too late, but that doesn't excuse some of the performances that season under him (such as Hull away where he seemed more intent on waving at the opposition fans than getting our players into their half of the pitch).

He gave Ian fucking Ashbee a huge wage which he could have spent making us a much better outfit by, for example, signing a proper leftback and not sticking Paul Parry there. On top of this transfer, he also signed Eddie Johnson, Leon Clarke, Steven Smith, Brian McLean, Juvhel Tsoumou, Keammar Daley, Clarke Carlisle and Jonathan Forte.

He gave the vast majority of our youth squad professional terms - of all the players brought through, only Bailey Wright has gone on to play regularly at any level above L1. They weren't good enough and he should have known better.

His tactical genius - rather than getting us to defend in L1, relying on 3 strikers to outscore the opposition. Also includes his decision to play Adam Barton as a bloody targetman in some games.

Maybe something went on behind the scenes, but that doesn't change the fact that he was one of the several managerial appointments in succession that turned out to be not good enough. Looking back through all of this has made me realise and appreciate just how good Grayson has been for the club.
 
Last edited:
If he's actually having a dig, Brown Phil has no leg to stand on. Yes he wasn't exactly helped by those above him (the sale of Keith Treacy) or lady luck (our main striking options for getting injured in quick succession), but let's just recount some of the things he did here:

He was in charge for our relegation - could argue it was too little too late, but that doesn't excuse some of the performances that season under him (such as Hull away where he seemed more intent on waving at the opposition fans than getting our players into their half of the pitch).

He gave Ian fucking Ashbee a huge wage which he could have spent making us a much better outfit by, for example, signing a proper leftback and not sticking Paul Parry there. On top of this transfer, he also signed Eddie Johnson, Leon Clarke, Steven Smith, Brian McLean, Juvhel Tsoumou, Keammar Daley, Clarke Carlisle and Jonathan Forte.

He gave the vast majority of our youth squad professional terms - of all the players brought through, only Bailey Wright has gone on to play regularly at any level above L1. They weren't good enough and he should have known better.

His tactical genius - rather than getting us to defend in L1, relying on 3 strikers to outscore the opposition. Also includes his decision to play Adam Barton as a bloody targetman in some games.

Maybe something went on behind the scenes, but that doesn't change the fact that he was one of the several managerial appointments in succession that turned out to be not good enough. Looking back through all of this has made me realise and appreciate just how good Grayson has been for the club.

I think I'm right in saying we didn't win in his first 12 games in charge. Even 3 wins in that spell and we could well have stayed up. However maybe it was deeper than that, and with his replacing that idiot Ferguson it probably was.

Then Lindsay selling our best player (Treacy) to a local rival right before the new season started certainly didn't help, meaning we almost fell into the 3 up front formation...
 
Didn't like him and it was the correct choice by PR to get rid, but there's no doubt Brown was shafted by Lindsay the summer after relegation.

We sold our best player and were forced into really desperate, bargain basement signings.

Brown asked for 100 grand to sign Vardy but Lindsay said no and he had to settle for Tsoumou……
 
If he's actually having a dig, Brown Phil has no leg to stand on. Yes he wasn't exactly helped by those above him (the sale of Keith Treacy) or lady luck (our main striking options for getting injured in quick succession), but let's just recount some of the things he did here:

He was in charge for our relegation - could argue it was too little too late, but that doesn't excuse some of the performances that season under him (such as Hull away where he seemed more intent on waving at the opposition fans than getting our players into their half of the pitch).

He gave Ian fucking Ashbee a huge wage which he could have spent making us a much better outfit by, for example, signing a proper leftback and not sticking Paul Parry there. On top of this transfer, he also signed Eddie Johnson, Leon Clarke, Steven Smith, Brian McLean, Juvhel Tsoumou, Keammar Daley, Clarke Carlisle and Jonathan Forte.

He gave the vast majority of our youth squad professional terms - of all the players brought through, only Bailey Wright has gone on to play regularly at any level above L1. They weren't good enough and he should have known better.

His tactical genius - rather than getting us to defend in L1, relying on 3 strikers to outscore the opposition. Also includes his decision to play Adam Barton as a bloody targetman in some games.

Maybe something went on behind the scenes, but that doesn't change the fact that he was one of the several managerial appointments in succession that turned out to be not good enough. Looking back through all of this has made me realise and appreciate just how good Grayson has been for the club.

Brown's far from the worst manager we've ever had - his ego has got the better of him at times of course.

He's been good for Southend and vice versa.

Seems to be a decent enough sort for a footballer, a bit of a character and was a decent player too.

Good luck to him.
 
If he's actually having a dig, Brown Phil has no leg to stand on. Yes he wasn't exactly helped by those above him (the sale of Keith Treacy) or lady luck (our main striking options for getting injured in quick succession), but let's just recount some of the things he did here:

He was in charge for our relegation - could argue it was too little too late, but that doesn't excuse some of the performances that season under him (such as Hull away where he seemed more intent on waving at the opposition fans than getting our players into their half of the pitch).

He gave Ian fucking Ashbee a huge wage which he could have spent making us a much better outfit by, for example, signing a proper leftback and not sticking Paul Parry there. On top of this transfer, he also signed Eddie Johnson, Leon Clarke, Steven Smith, Brian McLean, Juvhel Tsoumou, Keammar Daley, Clarke Carlisle and Jonathan Forte.

He gave the vast majority of our youth squad professional terms - of all the players brought through, only Bailey Wright has gone on to play regularly at any level above L1. They weren't good enough and he should have known better.

His tactical genius - rather than getting us to defend in L1, relying on 3 strikers to outscore the opposition. Also includes his decision to play Adam Barton as a bloody targetman in some games.

Maybe something went on behind the scenes, but that doesn't change the fact that he was one of the several managerial appointments in succession that turned out to be not good enough. Looking back through all of this has made me realise and appreciate just how good Grayson has been for the club.

Maybe those signings were the best available due to budgetary constraints.
 
Don't think he is having a go at our club or our owner. He is just commenting on the state of the game in general. Any direct criticism of PNE from him could be counteracted in just two words.. IAN ASHBEE !
 
I certainly don't think PB is having a pop at all. In the summer of 2013 I had the opportunity to have a long chat with him at a preseason friendly at Chelmsford City (oh the glamour....my excuse is that we were sponsors of CC at the time). He was very personable and when we talked about PNE he seemed to bear no grudges. He seems to have become quite popular at Southend and has done ok for them. His signings can be a bit flaky still - Nile Ranger anyone
 
Had Mellor and Hume stayed fit we would have won promotion under Brown in my opinion. We were unstoppable in those first 10 games back in this division.

We lost Hume and Mellor to bad injuries and it fell on Jamie Proctor's shoulders to lead the line.
 
Budgetary constraints or not, spending a reported 15k a week on Ian Ashbee is hardly the best use of any clubs resources.

I find it hard to believe that Ashbee was on anything like that but if he was, someone higher than Brown sanctioned those wages.
 
Had Mellor and Hume stayed fit we would have won promotion under Brown in my opinion. We were unstoppable in those first 10 games back in this division.

We lost Hume and Mellor to bad injuries and it fell on Jamie Proctor's shoulders to lead the line.


What a load of bollocks........ Unstoppable?......I remember those games and we got away with murder at times. It was obvious to a blind man that it was going to go pear shaped sooner rather than later.......................... Oh yeah,I'd have sacked him just for signing Ashbee........

Made a good speech when we went down though........ 🙂
 
Had Mellor and Hume stayed fit we would have won promotion under Brown in my opinion. We were unstoppable in those first 10 games back in this division.

We lost Hume and Mellor to bad injuries and it fell on Jamie Proctor's shoulders to lead the line.

We simply couldn't defend. It's the reason the wheels came off for Brown when our forward trio got injured. It's no good consistently trying to outscore teams and win games 4-3 - it's just not sustainable, particularly in League One where a solid back line is always the foundation for success, as Grayson has proved.
 
I find it hard to believe that Ashbee was on anything like that but if he was, someone higher than Brown sanctioned those wages.

Either way, the signing of that fat waster, who was handed a contract without having completed a medical, was an absolute disgrace. Especially considering our predicament at the time.
 
Had Mellor and Hume stayed fit we would have won promotion under Brown in my opinion. We were unstoppable in those first 10 games back in this division.

We lost Hume and Mellor to bad injuries and it fell on Jamie Proctor's shoulders to lead the line.

Absolute garbage this is! His only tactic was to hope Mellor/hume did something every game - in other words we didn't have any. We had paul parry playing at left back with steven smith as back up (The worst performance I have seen from a north end player was him against shef united.) You can't blame 8 losses in 9 on losing two key strikers - because unlike grayson brown couldn't sort out a defence and unfortunately if you can't do that for a football team you are going to struggle. He was clueless!
 
A dig at Uncle Trev...?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/39382271

Southend United manager Phil Brown will reach four years at the club when his side visit AFC Wimbledon on Saturday.

Former Derby County, Hull City and Preston boss Brown, 57, took the job at Roots Hall on 25 March 2013.

He took over with the Shrimpers in League Two, but guided them to promotion via the play-offs in 2015 and his side are now sixth in League One.

"I started off a job four years ago to prove the world of football wrong," Brown told BBC Essex.

The ex-Bolton and Hartlepool defender said he had had "to go down into the second division to get a job".

Brown had been out of management since December 2011, when he was fired by Preston, before being appointed by Southend in 2013.

He said many chairmen these days are "trigger happy", leading to "good men ending up losing their jobs".

"I'm so happy the chairman [Ron Martin] isn't influenced by the outside world as much as other chairmen are," Brown continued.

"I think if you have a good relationship with the guy up top, that is the most important thing. I firmly believe that, given time, most managers will get it right."

Brown is the 11th longest-serving manager in England's top four divisions, with under-pressure Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger top of the list having been in charge of the Gunners for more than 20 years.

"I'm hoping Arsene hangs on to his job," Brown added. "If that crumbles, unfortunately the whole mentality of the world of football will change."

I don't think PNE was trigger happy, Brown had clearly lost it, we was struggling after he took us down already, his tactics baffled everyone. St Ledger passing the ball cross the back under Browns instructions, when he could of played it up field and it led to Scunthorpe scoring should of been the day he left. He lost it with the fans, arguing back and he's found his level, but trust me not all Southend fans like him.
 
Back
Top