Skip to main content

Player loyalty?

Player loyalty?

Joined
Aug 5, 2009
Messages
1,150
How do you feel about player loyalty? And I don't mean that in terms of the expectation that most fans seem to have that a successful player should never dream to go on to something bigger and better than Preston North End, I mean the loyalty that we as a fanbase show to our players. It seems for some loyalty should only work one way.

This group of players (or vast majority) took us out of the third tier, via a win at Wembley breaking the playoff hoodoo, and finished in a very comfortable 11th place. Let's be clear here, these players have worked their socks off for us in the last couple of years. They are not the lazy wasters we have seen in previous set ups.

So why is it, after two incredibly successful years, I keep reading things like sell Garner, Huntington is not good enough, Clarke is too slow, Welsh is past it, etc. Yes this (or other online formats) are a place for fans to discuss subjects and give opinion, but I think some of you lot need to give your heads a shake. We are not Real Madrid, or even Derby bloody County. We are Preston North End and the only way we have ever achieved success, and ever will in the modern game, is with a group of players that go on to that pitch to represent us give us their all, and this lot do that.

I am not saying we should never sell X, Y and Z because they took us up. Players will come and go, that's the nature of the game. That's what the manager gets paid for, to make those decisions. But whilst those players are here, they deserve a little bit more respect than some people have shown in recent weeks.

clarke-tomblackpool4x349-1574009_478x359.jpg
 
I think some people expect perfection because they have handed over their hard earned money to watch a professional sport.

For me when I hand over my hard earned Burgundy dollars I simply expect that PNE players give their all for the shirt and leave everything on the pitch, thats what has made PNE successful in the past not paying our way to success and have Leicester have proven money doesn't always buy success.

Our club identity has never been high spenders but a team that is hard working and plays the game the right way, thats why I love PNE and like rubbing it in the Dingles faces that they are becoming part of what is wrong with the modern game.
 
How do you feel about player loyalty? And I don't mean that in terms of the expectation that most fans seem to have that a successful player should never dream to go on to something bigger and better than Preston North End, I mean the loyalty that we as a fanbase show to our players. It seems for some loyalty should only work one way.

This group of players (or vast majority) took us out of the third tier, via a win at Wembley breaking the playoff hoodoo, and finished in a very comfortable 11th place. Let's be clear here, these players have worked their socks off for us in the last couple of years. They are not the lazy wasters we have seen in previous set ups.

So why is it, after two incredibly successful years, I keep reading things like sell Garner, Huntington is not good enough, Clarke is too slow, Welsh is past it, etc. Yes this (or other online formats) are a place for fans to discuss subjects and give opinion, but I think some of you lot need to give your heads a shake. We are not Real Madrid, or even Derby bloody County. We are Preston North End and the only way we have ever achieved success, and ever will in the modern game, is with a group of players that go on to that pitch to represent us give us their all, and this lot do that.

I am not saying we should never sell X, Y and Z because they took us up. Players will come and go, that's the nature of the game. That's what the manager gets paid for, to make those decisions. But whilst those players are here, they deserve a little bit more respect than some people have shown in recent weeks.

clarke-tomblackpool4x349-1574009_478x359.jpg

Agree to an extent but to move forwards you have to make changes. It's not about moving players on because they can't do a job but to improve the squad it may be feasible to sell players, move players on etc. Kilkenny was one of the key players in the past and has been moved on by Grayson and I am sure he will have no qualms to do the same again with other players if we strengthen the squad.

The question is... do you think the same squad of players would get us to 11th again next season? If so, is 11th enough next season? I would answer 'no' to the first question and personally I'd take 11th again next season to be honest as I think next year will be tougher unless we invest quite a bit.

No one expects us to be Real Madrid but I am sure Grayson himself would like to sign players to make the likes of Garner, Huntington, Clarke etc to squad players. Every club in the land would like to strengthen and make every position competitive.

I'd not sell any of the retained players but I'd love us to sign numerous players who will fight for the club like the lads we have but also add more quality.
 
Agree to an extent but to move forwards you have to make changes. It's not about moving players on because they can't do a job but to improve the squad it may be feasible to sell players, move players on etc. Kilkenny was one of the key players in the past and has been moved on by Grayson and I am sure he will have no qualms to do the same again with other players if we strengthen the squad.

The question is... do you think the same squad of players would get us to 11th again next season? If so, is 11th enough next season? I would answer 'no' to the first question and personally I'd take 11th again next season to be honest as I think next year will be tougher unless we invest quite a bit.

No one expects us to be Real Madrid but I am sure Grayson himself would like to sign players to make the likes of Garner, Huntington, Clarke etc to squad players. Every club in the land would like to strengthen and make every position competitive.

I'd not sell any of the retained players but I'd love us to sign numerous players who will fight for the club like the lads we have but also add more quality.

A good response to a good question. I agree with the response as you have to move forwards and some players' peaks are probably in the past. I think that you have to ask how many of our players have the capacity to improve over last season's level.
I also would not sell any of the retained players but we need to bring in better quality players to raise the overall standard of the squad.
 
Last edited:
How do you feel about player loyalty? And I don't mean that in terms of the expectation that most fans seem to have that a successful player should never dream to go on to something bigger and better than Preston North End, I mean the loyalty that we as a fanbase show to our players. It seems for some loyalty should only work one way.

This group of players (or vast majority) took us out of the third tier, via a win at Wembley breaking the playoff hoodoo, and finished in a very comfortable 11th place. Let's be clear here, these players have worked their socks off for us in the last couple of years. They are not the lazy wasters we have seen in previous set ups.

So why is it, after two incredibly successful years, I keep reading things like sell Garner, Huntington is not good enough, Clarke is too slow, Welsh is past it, etc. Yes this (or other online formats) are a place for fans to discuss subjects and give opinion, but I think some of you lot need to give your heads a shake. We are not Real Madrid, or even Derby bloody County. We are Preston North End and the only way we have ever achieved success, and ever will in the modern game, is with a group of players that go on to that pitch to represent us give us their all, and this lot do that.

I am not saying we should never sell X, Y and Z because they took us up. Players will come and go, that's the nature of the game. That's what the manager gets paid for, to make those decisions. But whilst those players are here, they deserve a little bit more respect than some people have shown in recent weeks.

clarke-tomblackpool4x349-1574009_478x359.jpg

Sadly, that’s football (and why I’m increasingly enjoying going to rugby matches).

It’s noticeable though, both at games and online, that the real moaners are staying away.

Who was that tit who appeared towards the end of the Westley regime purely to stir up trouble? Seemed to be about 35 himself, with a bunch of teenage hangers on.

Hilariously, he tried to demand an audience with Westley after one game. Colchester away I think.

Never seen him since. Maybe he started watching Posh.
 
How do you feel about player loyalty? And I don't mean that in terms of the expectation that most fans seem to have that a successful player should never dream to go on to something bigger and better than Preston North End, I mean the loyalty that we as a fanbase show to our players. It seems for some loyalty should only work one way.

This group of players (or vast majority) took us out of the third tier, via a win at Wembley breaking the playoff hoodoo, and finished in a very comfortable 11th place. Let's be clear here, these players have worked their socks off for us in the last couple of years. They are not the lazy wasters we have seen in previous set ups.

So why is it, after two incredibly successful years, I keep reading things like sell Garner, Huntington is not good enough, Clarke is too slow, Welsh is past it, etc. Yes this (or other online formats) are a place for fans to discuss subjects and give opinion, but I think some of you lot need to give your heads a shake. We are not Real Madrid, or even Derby bloody County. We are Preston North End and the only way we have ever achieved success, and ever will in the modern game, is with a group of players that go on to that pitch to represent us give us their all, and this lot do that.

I am not saying we should never sell X, Y and Z because they took us up. Players will come and go, that's the nature of the game. That's what the manager gets paid for, to make those decisions. But whilst those players are here, they deserve a little bit more respect than some people have shown in recent weeks.

clarke-tomblackpool4x349-1574009_478x359.jpg
Nail hit very firmly on the head. Excellent OP.
 
I think it is a myth that you have to spend money to bring in better quality all the time as well.

We brought Beckford, Gallagher, Clarke, Cunningham and Woods in without spending any money and they replaced the likes of Beavon, Mousinho, Cansdell-Sheriff, Buchanan and Keane.

Lower the expectations that you only have a good summer transfer window if you pay money for players. We signed Gallagher, Beckford, Pickford and Cunningham last summer without spending a penny and how did that work out?
 
I think it is a myth that you have to spend money to bring in better quality all the time as well.

We brought Beckford, Gallagher, Clarke, Cunningham and Woods in without spending any money and they replaced the likes of Beavon, Mousinho, Cansdell-Sheriff, Buchanan and Keane.?

Arguably in the case of Beckford and Gallagher they'd be on significant pay packets, certainly a lot more than the likes of the ones they replaced.
 
Arguably in the case of Beckford and Gallagher they'd be on significant pay packets, certainly a lot more than the likes of the ones they replaced.

Weird cases really, because Beckford wouldn't of come here without Grayson being here especially at the time he came originally and Gallagher wouldn't of come here if we weren't anywhere near the M65.
 
But people don't consider that when they come on here moaning that we have had an underwhelming transfer window with no intent shown.

They only care about whats spent in terms of transfer fees.

then when we get Stevie May for money they moan like fuck because he didn't score 15 goals in his 15 minutes or so he actually played.
 
But people don't consider that when they come on here moaning that we have had an underwhelming transfer window with no intent shown.

They only care about whats spent in terms of transfer fees.


No they don't............. Only about half a % of all posters......Which equates to one fiftieth of a % of supporters...... So don't talk through your arse.
 
Or perhaps quite simply, players, like us, get older, can no longer improve, get more injuries, and then take longer to recover.

Just evolution and development isn't it?
 
Or perhaps quite simply, players, like us, get older, can no longer improve, get more injuries, and then take longer to recover.

Just evolution and development isn't it?

I don't think any of or current players are past it though, Clarke, Huntington and Garner are 28, possibly coming into their prime years.

Even Welsh has still done a job when called upon, plenty of players in his position can maintain their performances well into their 30's.

The likes of Grezza, Davidson and O'Neil were still class in their 30's.
 
How do you feel about player loyalty? And I don't mean that in terms of the expectation that most fans seem to have that a successful player should never dream to go on to something bigger and better than Preston North End, I mean the loyalty that we as a fanbase show to our players. It seems for some loyalty should only work one way.

This group of players (or vast majority) took us out of the third tier, via a win at Wembley breaking the playoff hoodoo, and finished in a very comfortable 11th place. Let's be clear here, these players have worked their socks off for us in the last couple of years. They are not the lazy wasters we have seen in previous set ups.

So why is it, after two incredibly successful years, I keep reading things like sell Garner, Huntington is not good enough, Clarke is too slow, Welsh is past it, etc. Yes this (or other online formats) are a place for fans to discuss subjects and give opinion, but I think some of you lot need to give your heads a shake. We are not Real Madrid, or even Derby bloody County. We are Preston North End and the only way we have ever achieved success, and ever will in the modern game, is with a group of players that go on to that pitch to represent us give us their all, and this lot do that.

I am not saying we should never sell X, Y and Z because they took us up. Players will come and go, that's the nature of the game. That's what the manager gets paid for, to make those decisions. But whilst those players are here, they deserve a little bit more respect than some people have shown in recent weeks.

clarke-tomblackpool4x349-1574009_478x359.jpg

Its simple, football is full of fickle fans, specially preston

Clarke will be fine next season, so will hugill, two excellent signings who are enjoying the white shirt.
 
Back
Top