Skip to main content

Playing with 10?

Playing with 10?

Gallagher is Premiership quality but he's playing in League 1. If you watch enough North End games then you'll know why that is. If he delivered to his potential then he wouldn't be here, so don't cry when he goes missing for 10 games a season; unless of course you don't rate his contribution for the other 30 odd games!?

A fair assumption.
 
I didn't think Gally was too bad, the only man who tried to make things happen but it wasn't really his day. I did notice Grayson got a bit annoyed with him once or twice and bollocked him from the touchline.
 
Gallagher been any better? Honestly? Feel he is our biggest passenger.

Gallagher has started 16 games, scored 3 and assisted 3. Brownhill has started 13 games, scored 1 and assisted 1. So yes, I feel Gallagher has been better than Brownhill.
 
Gallagher has started 16 games, scored 3 and assisted 3. Brownhill has started 13 games, scored 1 and assisted 1. So yes, I feel Gallagher has been better than Brownhill.

Brownhill a young lad with huge potential, Gallagher who puts no effort in. Brownhill, or Browne, for me.
 
Brownhill a young lad with huge potential, Gallagher who puts no effort in. Brownhill, or Browne, for me.
Whether he has potential or not doesn't matter, it's about who will contribute more to the side when on the pitch, this season and last that's been Gallagher. And while Gallagher's being made a scapegoat because he can't tackle or head a ball, Robinson isn't much good at that either and Kilkenny's the worst of the bunch and since he plays in the centre of midfield I'd say that's a bigger worry than Gallagher, who plays further forward. In reality they're simply weaknesses those players have, just like the defenders aren't great at finishing, and if Gallagher was more consistent and Kilkenny could tackle, they wouldn't be playing for us.
 
Whether he has potential or not doesn't matter, it's about who will contribute more to the side when on the pitch, this season and last that's been Gallagher. And while Gallagher's being made a scapegoat because he can't tackle or head a ball, Robinson isn't much good at that either and Kilkenny's the worst of the bunch and since he plays in the centre of midfield I'd say that's a bigger worry than Gallagher, who plays further forward. In reality they're simply weaknesses those players have, just like the defenders aren't great at finishing, and if Gallagher was more consistent and Kilkenny could tackle, they wouldn't be playing for us.

Disagree all other teams have players who can "head and tackle," apart from us. As a midfielder it is in your job description. Gallagher and Kilkenny go missing in tough games and are not what is needed to go on and win when the going gets tough. Luxury players. We need scrapers as well. Gallagher or Kilkenny in the division above? Why no offers then in summer?
 
Whether he has potential or not doesn't matter, it's about who will contribute more to the side when on the pitch, this season and last that's been Gallagher. And while Gallagher's being made a scapegoat because he can't tackle or head a ball, Robinson isn't much good at that either and Kilkenny's the worst of the bunch and since he plays in the centre of midfield I'd say that's a bigger worry than Gallagher, who plays further forward. In reality they're simply weaknesses those players have, just like the defenders aren't great at finishing, and if Gallagher was more consistent and Kilkenny could tackle, they wouldn't be playing for us.

Amazing words.
 
Disagree all other teams have players who can "head and tackle," apart from us. As a midfielder it is in your job description. Gallagher and Kilkenny go missing in tough games and are not what is needed to go on and win when the going gets tough. Luxury players. We need scrapers as well. Gallagher or Kilkenny in the division above? Why no offers then in summer?

Because there good league 1 standard.

Kilkenny isn't everyones cup of tea, look at him at Bristol City, here he makes us tick nothing more nothing less, like Matic does for Chelsea and Silva for City. If Kilkenny could do it all like some of them do then he would be in the league above.

Gallagher said to Leicester its either PNE or nowhere. His career is in decline as he has just turned 30. Has done it to some extent with Leicester and plays well in some/most games but goes missing in others. If he was consistent he would be in the league above and beyond, he is a very good league 1 player and we have him, or would you rather he play against us? I would rather have him in my starting 11 than against me.

Like PNE99 put why are Robinson and Humphrey not being highlighted for the lack of commitment in challenges, just Gallagher? Humphrey makes up for that lack of his game in his work ethic, Gallagher makes up for that lack to his game with his ability to unlock defenses. Gallaghers set pieces this season have been very good.
 
Disagree all other teams have players who can "head and tackle," apart from us. As a midfielder it is in your job description. Gallagher and Kilkenny go missing in tough games and are not what is needed to go on and win when the going gets tough. Luxury players. We need scrapers as well. Gallagher or Kilkenny in the division above? Why no offers then in summer?
We have players who can tackle and head, Garner and Davies are good in the air, Welsh, Browne and unsurprisingly the defenders can do both. Gallagher and Kilkenny don't go missing in tough games, they just struggle to find the space to have a major effect on the game. The scrappers you mention that thrive when the game is a tough, physical battle aren't as effective when the game opens up and we're trying to break the opposition down. That's why we have a squad of 25 or so players, to give us the different options we need to win games, sometimes a game will call for battlers and sometimes we'll need creative players, we have a good blend of both in the squad, although I wouldn't mind seeing another holding midfielder in there, Keane would fill that role IMO upon his return from Crawley.

Gallagher isn't playing in the division above because he isn't consistent enough and Kilkenny because he offers very little without the ball and while he runs the game, doesn't usually pick many incisive passes through the opposition defence. Coincidentally they're the biggest complaints most people seem to have about them.
 
You could argue we were playing with 9 if you include the player who was enjoying a pint, or pints, of Peroni on Friday evening.

I suppose it depends how you view that sort of thing really.
 
This thread is a load of nonsense. Gallagher has been one of our best players this season. Today, he may or may not have been fully fit, and he didn't effect the game as much as he has recently. That's creative players, they can't be brilliant every game, because the opposition sets out to nullify them, and Rochdale did that well.

We've tried the "attitude is more important that ability" approach before, and it was a proven failure. In terms of ability, there a few players better than Gallagher in this league.

Having said all that, I felt he needed a rest today, irrespective of whether he was carrying an injury - I'd have gone with Kevin Davies just for this game. But to suggest Gallagher doesn't contribute, or isn't worth his place in the side is utter nonsense. It's as if people didn't notice we'd won eight on the bounce with him as our creative fulcrum.
 
Back
Top