Skip to main content

Poor Joe

Poor Joe

Situation reminds me of a striker we used to have, Andy Saville. He was truly lethal at a league lower but when we came up a league he just could not make an impact against better defenders. And he too was pretty much worshipped at deepdale.
 
In a season of several positives the striker situation has been a bit of a disappointment. It was unfortunate to lose Beckford for practically the whole season and then to have the long term injury to May before he'd had time to settle in. Although Doyle has had his moments he doesn't appear to be a long term solution. Garners goal return despite a good work rate has been disappointing. Lack of a regular strike partner could well have contributed to this. Hugill was out of favour for a time after his stupid red card at MK Dons. Never going to set this division alight but I did enjoy his goals at Bolton and Blackburn. The lack of goals is an area that needs addressing. Better fortune in the injury department would be a start.
 
Maybe he has found his level. However, would like to see a few more games alongside Beckford. We played a top team with the bit between their teeth yesterday. Our goalkeeper looked awkward at best. Only outlet seemed long ball.
Quality CBs can handle him more often than not and his aggression gets him nowhere in this league. He needs to adapt to prosper, or to drop a division.

Sent from my E2303 using Tapatalk
 
Beckford needs games. Took time to get going last season.
Garner not good enough.
Doyle not good enough.
Hugill is garbage.

Like spender, I sadly agree.

Hugill has popped up with a few goals lately but if we're serious about kicking on in the next few years then he's simply not the sufficient quality of footballer that we will need in the squad.
 
Amazing

Started a thread around Christmas time , and asked the question is garner good enough? IMO it was obvious half a season ago that he wasn't . And I got slated for it.


Now it seems everyone has changed their tune.

He gives 100% but he isn't championship quality , it's as simple as that .

Do you want a medal? I also said around October time that Grayson is a great manager and will do well with us this season given time. A lot of people wanted him out and though we where relegation fodder. Can I have a medal too?
 
Beckford needs games. Took time to get going last season.
Garner not good enough.
Doyle not good enough.
Hugill is garbage.

I agree with all of this except the Garner bit.

I believe he can be good enough at this level when partnered with a decent striker (IE, players of the calibre of Beckford, at least 1 of which should be signed this summer - hopefully David Nugent on loan if M'Boro get promoted.) He'll never be as prolific as he was in L1, but he can still do an effective enough job at this level to warrant a place in the squad in my opinion via his aerial ability, hold up play, winning free kicks and he does actually score some goals.

Would he be better used as an impact sub? I'm not sure. Ironically, if you're looking for an effective impact sub, look no further than Eoin Doyle, then again...
 
I doubt any striker still in their 20s who have just the season before notched nearly 30 goals in one season go anywhere to settle for being an impact sub.
 
I agree with all of this except the Garner bit.

I believe he can be good enough at this level when partnered with a decent striker (

Exactly - Garner has worked his socks off for the team this season and has done so without throwing the sort of hissy fit that a lot of other players might given that the way he was being played denied him any great opportunity to score goals on his own account.
 
Last edited:
Beckford still has the ability at this level.
Garner I like and think he's still a key player for us. Does he miss easy chances? I don't think so - maybe we don't create enough clear cut and half chances.
No idea about Doyle or Hugill.
Robinson is still young and if he's a hard worker in training I'd be tempted to get him on board - Simon's best placed to make the call here.

All in all if we finish around 10th it's going to be difficult to better that next season - we see clubs who've spent like some of us wish we would and they'll finish below us.
 
We knew Garner hadn't been successful at this level previously but he'd never had a large run of games like he had this season.

He'll have learnt a lot and his two excellent seasons in League 1 mean he still has credit in the bank as far as I'm concerned. I'm not ready to write him off just yet - lets see where we are after the first few months of next season.
 
Back
Top