Skip to main content

Poor Joe

Poor Joe

Garner has always missed chances but the difference is he only gets 1 or 2 a game at this level whereas he got 5 or 6 in League One.

Whether that's down to Championship defenders getting the better of him, the service not being good or enough, or both, I don't know.

Feel bad having a pop at him as I love the guy for what he's done for us in recent seasons but we've got to look ahead.

Teams tend to be stronger, faster and taller at this level than league 1.

He needs someone to take the pressure off him, he has been a one man battering ram this season and I think would have scored more if Beckford had been fit all season.
 
End of the season can't come soon enough for Joe its devastating to see how shit he is at the moment. Weakest part of pne today was up front really, it doesn't stick there is no threat over the top or in the channels its just weak as piss, battering ram joie shouting at the ref and fighting with the centre back. It's embarrassing joie. Have a good break pal but at the moment feeling like you're potentially at risk of being at best benched or shifted out while there is still some value there.

It was a good second half I enjoyed it, Burnley were good - solid team but we still caused them problems. All in all not that bad.
 
Last edited:
I think he's done his own legs. His reputation for going to ground has been well-known for a long time. This basically gives anyone marking him free-reign to clatter him all over the place. The Ref will just think he's taking the piss, and let play carry on regardless if it's been a genuine foul or not.

And saying that, there were a few occasions tonight where he was rolling around clutching his ankles, then happily jogged off after the decision was given/declined.

Joey - knock it off. Stay upright, for fucks sake.
 
We lack quality in the final third, says the manager who was allegedly ready to blow £2 million on Stevie May until The Riddler stepped in. And when he finally got his man for a cut down price, he left him sat on the bench??

I'm not a fan of Graysons tactics or style of football and I do wonder whether it would make much difference if we had Messi upfront, when we keep punting aimless long balls up the pitch.
 
I do wonder whether it would make much difference if we had Messi upfront, when we keep punting aimless long balls up the pitch.

To be fair the players show belief and confidence even though most times they're against much better quality teams and Simon deserves a lot of credit. I expected we'd be around bottom 3 all season and well done everyone at PNE that many are complaining we're not doing better than 10th place.
 
We lack quality in the final third, says the manager who was allegedly ready to blow £2 million on Stevie May until The Riddler stepped in. And when he finally got his man for a cut down price, he left him sat on the bench??

I'm not a fan of Graysons tactics or style of football and I do wonder whether it would make much difference if we had Messi upfront, when we keep punting aimless long balls up the pitch.

Must watch a different game to me and most because not every ball is an aimless punt.
 
To be fair the players show belief and confidence even though most times they're against much better quality teams and Simon deserves a lot of credit. I expected we'd be around bottom 3 all season and well done everyone at PNE that many are complaining we're not doing better than 10th place.

I never complained about our league position. I think it's a remarkable achievement. I just really don't like the style of football. It's no coincidence that we did better against Burnley tonight in the second half, when we actually got the ball down and started to play through the middle, instead of just launching the ball from back to front and surrendering possession.
 
Must watch a different game to me and most because not every ball is an aimless punt.

Read my reply to Penny above. We will never agree Ron. We do have a completely different view of the game. I'm not getting into one of your drawn out arguments, because I just can't be arsed.
 
Amazing

Started a thread around Christmas time , and asked the question is garner good enough? IMO it was obvious half a season ago that he wasn't . And I got slated for it.


Now it seems everyone has changed their tune.

He gives 100% but he isn't championship quality , it's as simple as that .
 
Apologies but I felt sorry for Garner tonight. He looked so off form and out of his depth. I hope he can show he's up to this level. I like the fact he gives everything but perhaps it's not enough in the Championship.

Sent from my LG-H815 using Tapatalk

Does the same apply for beckford then? As he was up top all game also
 
Amazing

Started a thread around Christmas time , and asked the question is garner good enough? IMO it was obvious half a season ago that he wasn't . And I got slated for it.


Now it seems everyone has changed their tune.

He gives 100% but he isn't championship quality , it's as simple as that .

Well im not one of that 100%. I fucking love the guy
 
Joe Garner is my 12 year olds favorite player,but after the game today he asked me if he was good enough for the championship and I said no he isn't, but I said years ago there was a lad called Kevn Keegan that wasn't good enough for England, but his heart and his motivation made him an England player. Joe will be just fine next season.
 
Played up front alone most of the season in a pretty defensive team.

Needs help n support rather than being dropped or replaced.

Spot on. Put a fit Beckford alongside him all season and he'd have had plenty this year. Brings so much to the team that sometimes goes unnoticed. I'd be happy with Joe up top again next season, no bother.
 
Much as he loves PNE, I honestly wouldn't be surprised to see garner ask to leave at some point if we keep playing the kind of football that often leaves him on his own up front, provides him with fuck all chances and which has enabled him to notch just two goals from open play all season. Strikers want to score goals. I love him in the side but it's more due to his passion and commitment rather than his ability at this level. The defenders in this league are often ex premier league and even ex England players. They are better and wiser than those he slaughtered every week in league one. Joes style of play is meat and drink to a lot of them.
 
I've been saying for awhile now, That I'd reserve judgment on Garner until he's not playing on his own up front with little or no service. That said he's never proven himself at this level, so maybe he has reached his limit and is at best a good league one striker. I do think things would have been different if Beckford, our only quality, proven striker at this level, had played with him all season.
An upgrade in striker is going to be needed in the summer.
Beckford....still quality at this level
Garner......impact sub
Doyle.......not good enough
May.......who knows
Hugill....best is still to come
 
I've been saying for awhile now, That I'd reserve judgment on Garner until he's not playing on his own up front with little or no service. That said he's never proven himself at this level, so maybe he has reached his limit and is at best a good league one striker. I do think things would have been different if Beckford, our only quality, proven striker at this level, had played with him all season.
An upgrade in striker is going to be needed in the summer.
Beckford....still quality at this level
Garner......impact sub
Doyle.......not good enough
May.......who knows
Hugill....best is still to come
I'd say more like....
Beckford .... Not sure next season as he will be about 33.
Garner ...not quite up to it, loves scoring too much to stick around anywhere as an impact sub.
Doyle...could be worth keeping if cheap enough
May ...don't like kicking a man when he's down (unless he's a lasher) but didn't look good enough
Hugil..not good enough.
We definitely need to sign two new strikers for a promotion push because 42 goals all season would normally see you relegated, not near the top six.
 
I am not ready to hang Garner out to dry yet. The early part of the season was farcical with some of the bookings being ridiculous and actually I think he was hard done to.

Doyle hasn't worked out, Hugill isn't quite there yet and May and Beckford effectively injured all season. Considering how we set up Garner has worked his arse off all year. I do wonder where this striker is coming from to fire us to the Prem...
 
I think people are jumping the gun slightly. More than happy to see how he gets on next season now he's had a season to settle. We still look better with him than without

100% this. We forget he's played most of the season either up front on his own or playing with Doyle which is basically the same.

If Garner isn't good enough for this level God knows what that makes Hugill.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top