Skip to main content

Poor Referee or.........

Poor Referee or.........

Joined
Feb 20, 2005
Messages
3,089
....maybe not??!

Simmo said that BOTH managers have been unhappy with the referee. Now, I didn`t go to the game, but from what I know, refs seem to have a saying- If only one side is complaining, you must to have done something wrong, but if both sides are unhappy then you`ve done a good job! Let`s hear what people that went have to say about the ref.

Also, I`d like to know if PNEFANATIC`s (and any other refs on here) philosophy is the same as the above.🙄
 
....maybe not??!

Simmo said that BOTH managers have been unhappy with the referee. Now, I didn`t go to the game, but from what I know, refs seem to have a saying- If only one side is complaining, you must to have done something wrong, but if both sides are unhappy then you`ve done a good job! Let`s hear what people that went have to say about the ref.

Also, I`d like to know if PNEFANATIC`s (and any other refs on here) philosophy is the same as the above.🙄

I was at the game and the ref was poor. Sent Dichio off for next to nothing - all because McShane fell to the floor clutching his face. Then he realised he had goofed and then started giving a few decisions our way including booking one of their players for an innoculous challenge on Nugent.

I know there is a gang of people on here who say we shouldn't slag off refs but the guy had a bad day. Probably a few too many sherries yesterday.
 
I aint no refeere, this chap was whistle happy. Who was rather one sided towards WBA. He booked Grezza for duck all but wouldn't book Koumas for worse.

I was deffo a penalty for hand ball from Robinson. He just never let the game flow, what a plank.
 
Absolutely poor referee, completely ruined the game.

A good referee angers neither side, as long as the management are reasonable, and so no one comes out and complains. Preston North End and West Bromwich Albion (A couple of players a side) are geniune footballing people and would not be angered without due reason.

Until I see conclusive video evidence to the contrary I will stick by my decisions from the stand that the officials cost us today, that the sending off of Dichio was a hopeless decision which influenced the result almost as much as the possible penalty we were denied prior to their second
 
The referee was a complete numpty who played to the home crowd. Did any one see while the officials were warming up to the Left of the stand, one of them was waving to the crowd, ran over shook somebodys hand & ran back to complete his warm up giving some one the thumbs up 😕 😕 😕 😕
 
The referee was a complete numpty who played to the home crowd. Did any one see while the officials were warming up to the Left of the stand, one of them was waving to the crowd, ran over shook somebodys hand & ran back to complete his warm up giving some one the thumbs up 😕

Sounds about right, some officials have been known to do that with the away fans at Deepdale in the past 😱

Unfortunately I spent 20 minutes waiting for a tram at West Bromwich Central so I literally walked into the ground for kick off and did not see that happening today.
 
Yes he was poor. It was a standard Dichio challenge, heavily dramatised by the WBA defender- that decsion ruined the game. One of the linesman was also clearly operating in a parallel fixture and only waved his flag when the home supporters suggested he did, usually to the players' frustration and to enhance PNE's suffering.
PNE seem to be a genuinely honest outfit, consistently reflecting the Manager's outlook. Some Champioship outfits are more "professional" and less naive than we are.
Without being too cynical, maybe this is an area where we are missing Mawene and Davidson- not cheating but not being taken advantage of. Maybe that is the steel that we hoped Miller would bring, maybe that is where we need to shop in January......
 
Dichio has raised an arm (to chest height) into the chest of the WBA defender, I have just seen it on SSN.

From this you could construct a case for the RED to be entirely justified.

You COULD construct a case if it was not for John Hartson doing similar things every time the ball was played near to him, which is probably why they were not expecting the red card.

Two wrongs do not make a right, etc, etc, etc But inconsistency like this really gets me angry 😡 😡
 
In that case why did McShane go down clutching his face?😉

PRECISELY 😡

Unless he shrinks immediately prior to contact 😕

Perhaps he was embarassed to be playing for WBA.

It really annoys me that players do this.

It may genuinely be that he covers his face every time he feels pain, it is a natural reaction I suppose. But there is little need to do this in the direction of the Referee.😡
 
All three officials were a joke and ruined the game. DD sending off was don to the crowd and the disgracefulplay acting of the lad; but that's what so many professional players do these days, they're a joke.

Having said that Matt Hill had a shocker and Simpson just seemd to be trying anone in the middle of the park.

Sedgwick actualy played average (a miracle for him) for the last 30minutes. 😱 The first hour, he was shocking again tho . . . 😡
 
Let's look at the ref's contribution to the game.


Nugent fouled on the half way line, no foul given, play goes on, they score.

St Ledger clearly pulled down in the box, play goes on, they go down the other end and score.

Dichio sent off for next to nothing. Hartson was doing the same all game with no booking / free kick.

Endless free kicks for minor fouls - rarely played advantage.

Ellington, Koumas and their left back constantly diving. Nothing done.

All in all, i'd say he ruined the game. We were clearly the better team, even with 10 men and bar two Nash cock-ups we would have come away with at least a point.

It was a carbon copy of the Brum match for me. Good teams win when playing poorly. We lose when we play well it seems!
 
Ellington, Koumas and their left back constantly diving. Nothing done.

Just a thought here - while I didn't think the referee today was very good at all, if a player dives and the referee is conned by it, that's not the referee's fault. That's the player's fault, and it is the players who should be abused for it, not the referee.
 
Just a thought here - while I didn't think the referee today was very good at all, if a player dives and the referee is conned by it, that's not the referee's fault. That's the player's fault, and it is the players who should be abused for it, not the referee.

You are right, but the ref continually waved play on for many of the dives. (Although he did fall for some) The rules state that unsporting behaviour should result in a yellow card. He never even warned their players!
Diving is ruining the game though. What chance to refs have when players themselves are deliberately cheating?
 
I could tell when the ref gave the penalty to us, he would do anything to even it up, and when dichio gave him the chance he jumped at it. He lost control of the game, both fans were singing "you dont know what your doing" at one point.
 
In fairness, he did play advantage and then pull back and book a WBA player for diving towards the end. Apart from that, though, he was truly shocking.
 
The ref and the lineman on our side were both terrible today and played a large role in us getting bugger all from the game when we probably deserved a point.

The linesman was was playing the offside rule by judgingf the reaction of the WBA fans behind rather than actually running the line hence his hugely delayed flagging during the first half.

The ref missed St. Ledger being torn to shreds in the penalty area moments before they went up the other end and scored and he was completely fooled by the West Brom player's diving and fouling.

About the only thing he did get right was Dichios sending off. Yes he did lead with his elbow, though quite innocently, but he clearly took at least one swipe at his marker after ball has gone and it was THIS that got him his red.

tg
 
Diving is ruining the game though. What chance to refs have when players themselves are deliberately cheating?

I realise this, but it's a similar situation to the rule stating that a red card must be shown for foul or abusive language. I don't think a match would last 5 minutes if this was enforced.
 
I realise this, but it's a similar situation to the rule stating that a red card must be shown for foul or abusive language. I don't think a match would last 5 minutes if this was enforced.

Absolutely right, Its all about applying common sense when enforcing the Laws of the game.
 
Back
Top