I'm starting to think Grayson's job here is actually complete.
Maybe he just doesn't have what it takes to get a side like ours into the top two?
Garner isn't a young Rhodes or Beckford, and I think that can't be stated enough. These were 'gold dust' players who improved the team they played in massively at third tier level, altered the mentality of BOTH sides and meant all you needed was a solid team shape to be right up there.
Garner is just a very good player at this level, not in the same class as those two.
The Blackpool promotion was, at least in footballing terms, a very long time ago.
Whatever happens, Simon should be remembered for undoing a great deal of the mayhem he inherited. We finally had organisation, some discipline and a coherent plan, however dull that might have been sometimes.
His signings have been hit and miss, to put it politely.
But here's where football management varies wildly from other walks of life - he's a worrier. In an office environment, this can actually be a very good thing as it prompts more diligence, hard work and better decision-making. A worrier is a good worker if harnassed correctly. The worrier cares, has attention to detail and picks up on things others miss.
In football management, it simply leads to negativity and under-performance. Too many of his signings have reflected that negative worldview, when our quite apparent lack of (for instance) a box-to-box midfielder who can glue the side together is something only he seems oblivious to, despite several goes at solving that problem.
Players like Humphrey and Reid need the freedom to express themselves, do something off the cuff and maybe, god forbid, make the odd mistake. You're wasting them playing the kind of negative football we currently are.
Gallagher has not done badly, but isn't worth the money he's on.
Brownhill, a natural number ten with immense ability, should be playing in his best position. Then you might get consistent performances from the kid.
GET PEOPLE DOING THE THINGS THEY ARE GOOD AT!!
Simon's shape-orientated/worry endlessly about the opposition approach won't do this. Time's up methinks.
As far as replacements go, rather than going on the merry-go-round it might be worth looking at a young, recently retired player who's current and aware of how football is changing. The right man for this club might be in his early-mid 30s and not someone any of us have thought of. Look to Europe, and see who's making an impact in, for instance, the Scandinavian countries. Why not a foreign manager?
And why does it have to be someone we know, or used to play for us? That has been identified as the single biggest reason for botched managerial appointments, appeals to sentiment.