Skip to main content

Potential Replacements for Grayson

Potential Replacements for Grayson

I mentioned it early in the thread in a tongue in cheek kind of way but having read a bit more about his time at Swindon (57% win ratio) it would certainly be an interesting and extremely unpredictable roller coaster ride (unlike Grayson) to have Di Canio in the dugout at Deepdale.

In some ways he is everything you could want from your manager, although maybe it became too much about him and not enough about the club in the end. Did he become a caricature of himself? Is he a skilful and charismatic leader or is he the Italian Westley?

Picked up an article from the BBC website about him..........

Passion, pride, desire, discipline, determination - on the surface Paolo Di Canio's managerial principles sound ideal.

You buy into the philosophy, respect the club, take pride in the badge, and you work hard. Very hard.

It is a concept that can have the players enthralled and the fans enraptured when it works, as witnessed by promotion from League Two with Swindon Town and a place at the top of League One the following season.
Rest of the article below:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/24209814
 
Last edited:
I mentioned it early in the thread in a tongue in cheek kind of way but having read a bit more about his time at Swindon (57% win ratio) it would certainly be an interesting and extremely unpredictable roller coaster ride (unlike Grayson) to have Di Canio in the dugout at Deepdale.

In some ways he is everything you could want from your manager, although maybe it became too much about him and not enough about the club in the end. Did he become a caricature of himself in the end? Is he skilful and charismatic leader or is he the Italian Westley?

Rest of the article below:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/24209814

Comparisons between Di Canio and Westley are unfair - although Paolo's political views, or anyone parroting them, would worry me enormously. The guy's a self-proclaimed fascist who once gave a Mussolini salute to the crowd after scoring a goal for Lazio. Hardly 'PC gone mad' to be disconcerted by that.

Di Canio does allow some freedom from his players on the field to express themselves - it's the stuff around diet and preparation where he can come over as a dictator and perhaps overdid it. All that said, there remain question marks even now about what players do in their own time and whether football teams prepare properly for matches. His results at Swindon suggest he got something right.

Take out the charisma, charm, ability to leave people to it on the field and yes, the love of Mussolini and you have Westley. A guy whose achievements look increasingly to have been built on the efforts of Dreyer in particular. What has he done since Dreyer hasn't been around to change his nappies for him?
 
I'd stick with SG until the end of the season. If we are to make a change now I'd go for Nigel Adkins or make Dreyer caretaker til the end of the season.

He did a good job at Southampton but that was a very good era for them with players coming through. Phil Brown took a team to the Prem. What's Dreyer achieved?
 
He did a good job at Southampton but that was a very good era for them with players coming through. Phil Brown took a team to the Prem. What's Dreyer achieved?

I see Dreyer as a stop gap until a proper appointment at the season's end. Adkins made some shrewd signings and did well before getting the sack somewhat unfairly. He even managed to get a lot of decent performances out of that waster Chaplow!
 
Potential Replacements for Grayson

I see Dreyer as a stop gap until a proper appointment at the season's end. Adkins made some shrewd signings and did well before getting the sack somewhat unfairly. He even managed to get a lot of decent performances out of that waster Chaplow!

Who did he sign...

Southampton had a good batch of youngsters at the time and some great money coming in from sales.

Yes he appeared to be unfairly potted but the team have gone from strength to strength
 
Last edited:
Who did he sign...

Southampton had a good batch of youngsters at the time and some great money coming in from sales.

Yes he appeared to be unfairly potted but the team have gone from strength to strength

He took them up in successive seasons and got the best out of signings like Chaplow, Sharp, Ramirez, Cork. My best mate is a Saints supporter for his sins, and he was a big fan of Adkin's work. You're correct that they've always had a wonderful youth set up which generated good players and income, but they ended up in League 1 and needed a steady hand to get them back up to the top division. Unfortunately, managers come with the same sort of past performance disclaimer as financial products but Adkins has always struck me as a decent manager with the right approach.
 
Who did he sign...

Southampton had a good batch of youngsters at the time and some great money coming in from sales.

Yes he appeared to be unfairly potted but the team have gone from strength to strength

Also did a good job at Scunthorpe. Didn't do well at Reading, but I don't think happenings behind the scenes helped. Adkins would be my 1st choice.
 
I'm that low tonight I can't even think about who ought to replace Grayson.

What I will say is that, as a manager in my own profession for nearly thirty years, I believe that a key requirement is to get the culture right within the team. The manager affects that culture through both direct and indirect means. What really worries me about Grayson in this respect is his obsession with changing players and systems depending on who the opposition are. The message this sends to the players - whether it's intentional or not - is that they aren't good enough to impose themselves on the opposition. I honestly can't remember a manager who seemed to be so driven to do this. How on earth are individual players / partnerships /the team as a whole meant to get any rhythm to their game with all the tinkering that goes on?
 
Gary Neville.

This must be a joke? Do you honestly think Neville would leave his cushy we'll paid job at Sky to come and manage PNE?? And please don't suggest that he could carry on doing his pundit job at the same time - that's the last thing we need.
 
Back
Top